>the most evil thing he does in the entire game is killing an innocent eyewitness who was going to r…

Home Forums A haunted junk yard >the most evil thing he does in the entire game is killing an innocent eyewitness who was going to r…

  • This topic has 148 replies, 1 voice, and was last updated 7 months ago by Anonymous.
Viewing 35 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #427405
      Anonymous
      Guest

      >the most evil thing he does in the entire game is killing an innocent eyewitness who was going to rat him out to the police
      >and it’s probably not even the canon choice since you can choose to spare his life
      lmao, most morally grey characters in TV and literature are more evil than this guy, what the fuck were they thinking?

    • #427406
      Anonymous
      Guest

      Rockstar of david shitty writing

    • #427407
      Anonymous
      Guest

      very kino Arthur, OP

    • #427408
      Anonymous
      Guest

      He’s unvaccinated

    • #427409
      Anonymous
      Guest

      holy fuck this game has great graphics

      • #427539
        Anonymous
        Guest

        Rockstar is a graphics autist, so it checks out.

    • #427410
      Anonymous
      Guest

      I killed infinitely more people than I had to and it disappoints me Arthur cried like a woman going out. You should have played as Micah.

      • #427411
        Anonymous
        Guest

        Why did they give some mopey incel faggot to play as instead of someone like Micah? At least Micah acted as a bandit and not some le misunderstood white knight. You don’t need to make it super edgy, just a regular criminal/murderer.

    • #427412
      Anonymous
      Guest

      he should unironically have raped or beaten a woman at the beginning of the game

    • #427413
      Anonymous
      Guest

      Show me a better cowboy game in 2021. You cant.

      • #427416
        Anonymous
        Guest

        call of juarez gunslinger

      • #427464
        Anonymous
        Guest

        RDR1

      • #427533
        Anonymous
        Guest

        new vegas, but theyre different. obviously

    • #427414
      Anonymous
      Guest

      Game of the decade, stop being contarian

    • #427415
      Anonymous
      Guest

      > people itt actually acting like Arthur isn’t a fucking chad.

      • #427417
        Anonymous
        Guest

        >incel
        >can’t even ask for happy ending from women that he pays to bathe him
        >Micah fucks his onetis (canon)
        also
        >captcha
        I win

        • #427418
          Anonymous
          Guest

          Arthur has spent most his life banging bitches. When you grow up you’ll learn it’s about quality, not quantity.

          • #427420
            Anonymous
            Guest

            Show me don’t tell me
            also why then make people play objectively boring characters?
            >oh but he is so deep and unique
            not really, oh the old fart is tired of doing his job, but does it anyways then sacrifices himself for someone else, its a fucking trope

            • #427422
              Anonymous
              Guest

              I’m sure you would have retired to your death bed and lived out the rest of your days not choking your lungs up tho innit.

            • #427433
              Anonymous
              Guest

              >not really, oh the old fart is tired of doing his job, but does it anyways then sacrifices himself for someone else, its a fucking trope

              More like a man realising that his adoptive father is a terrible person who grooms orphans into becoming outlaws and that his lifestyle is going to end up killing all of his friends.

              • #427435
                Anonymous
                Guest

                >a criminal realizes that he is a criminal and others have feelings too
                whoah deep… don’t care

                • #427439
                  Anonymous
                  Guest

                  replying to myself but had to add this
                  >a criminal realizes that he is a criminal and others have feelings too
                  you literally learn this at age of 4 or even younger

                • #427441
                  Anonymous
                  Guest

                  >whoah deep… don’t care
                  Yes, everything sounds retarded when you phrase it like a retard. Well done.

                  • #427446
                    Anonymous
                    Guest

                    Ok, then make it sound smart

                    • #427449
                      Anonymous
                      Guest

                      >Ok, then make it sound smart

                      Arthur’s story is not about a criminal realising that people have feelings. It is about a man realising that his entire way of life was doomed from the start, he no longer has any place in the world and that his father figure potentially never really cared for him. He also views the tuberculosis as a punishment, therefore creating conflict between two different potential identities: the bad man who is getting what he deserved or the good man who is able to use the time he has left to help people.

                      There is also the parallel between the downfall of the van der Linde gang and the downfall of the old west in general, with Dutch himself representing the ambiguity of that period of history. Although, as always, death of the author means that all of this might be bullshit.

                      • #427529
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        Why do you make up headcanon just so you can desperately try to make a shit game seem a bit less shit?

                      • #427530
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        >headcanon
                        Everything there is pretty surface level, other than Dutch himself symbolizing the death of the west, which is reaching a bit. The game has its flaws but the writing is solid enough.

        • #427421
          Anonymous
          Guest

          >Micah fucks his onetis (canon)
          ?

          • #427426
            Anonymous
            Guest

            I made it up

            I’m sure you would have retired to your death bed and lived out the rest of your days not choking your lungs up tho innit.

            Why are you making this about me? Are we talking about me or a fucking video game character? Your discussion level is that of a child.
            >w-w-well w-h-hat wo-would yo-you do?

            • #427429
              Anonymous
              Guest

              You seem offended that I didn’t immediately call you a faggot and a cuck. Apparently I should have done.

              • #427432
                Anonymous
                Guest

                just leave the thread brainlet

                You

                Yes, but also everyone who does not want to live around the equivalent of ghetto diverse folk, real life pinkertons were pieces of shit though

                • #427436
                  Anonymous
                  Guest

                  Not that guy but reminder that there were literal cannibals lurking in caves. Arthur and co. were not the biggest problem.

                • #427440
                  Anonymous
                  Guest

                  The story went out of its’ way multiple times to show that unwarranted killing is bad. Dutch killing the innocent girl at the start of the game is what led to them being chased out of Blackwater, and is ultimately what leads to the group being disbanded. It’s okay though, you reap what you sow, hence Milton being gunned down by Jack.

                  • #427473
                    Anonymous
                    Guest

                    >Milton being gunned down by Jack
                    ?

                    • #427474
                      Anonymous
                      Guest

                      Whoops, I’m retarded, it’s Ross that gets killed by Jack. -1 for me.

                      • #427475
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        its not your fault. i was confused too since the pinkerton fags all look the same

          • #427427
            Anonymous
            Guest

            That anon is confusing Eliza with Jenny Kirk. After Lenny dies, Micah has some dialog explaining that he fucked Jenny.

        • #427437
          Anonymous
          Guest

          >>Micah fucks his onetis (canon)
          Huh?

      • #427452
        Anonymous
        Guest

        >chad
        >whiny faggot that is woker than dudes in the 1980s
        kek

      • #427537
        Anonymous
        Guest

        he’s a huge fag

    • #427419
      Anonymous
      Guest

      The most evil thing Arthur does is kill a terminally ill man, while attempting to extort him for payment on a dirty loan, in front of his wife and son.
      The story makes that very clear by killing him for it.

      • #427443
        Anonymous
        Guest

        >The story makes that very clear by killing him for it.
        Yeah. The game let you choose how to proceed, when Arthur starts beating him in the cutscene anyway. What a great game.

    • #427423
      Anonymous
      Guest

      He didn’t say he supports trans rights, so he’s practically a nazi.

    • #427424
      Anonymous
      Guest

      >Ganker does not understand what it means to be a man
      >not knowing good karma route is best route
      not surprising, tbh

      • #427430
        Anonymous
        Guest

        He’s a criminal murderer, no matter how many 1$ bills you give to bums won’t change that.

        • #427431
          Anonymous
          Guest

          You

          • #427457
            Anonymous
            Guest

            Its kind of bad how they had to make the law men look like the bad guys despite from they’re point of view they’re actually in the right

          • #427463
            Anonymous
            Guest

            his only flaw was his initial kindness
            he should have surrounded their camp and shot up everyone
            in the long term it would have spared a ton of innocent lives

    • #427425
      Anonymous
      Guest

      The game was good, deal with it.

      • #427428
        Anonymous
        Guest

        The "game" was shit, cope with it. Oh wait, you already seem to be doing so. Carry on.

    • #427434
      Anonymous
      Guest

      confirmed samefag pooping up the thread gg bros.

    • #427438
      Anonymous
      Guest

      >>the most evil thing he does in the entire game is hogtying women and dropping them in shallow ponds and river beds to drown before butchering their dead bodies with his hunting knife or throwing them off of cliffs after choking them, and killing and robbing literally everyone he passes on the road.
      I don’t understand why he was presented as evil when he’s clearly morally grey

    • #427442
      Anonymous
      Guest

      > the most evil thing he does in the entire game is killing an innocent eyewitness
      > not evil

      Ganker addled brainlet

    • #427444
      Anonymous
      Guest

      miss the bit where he and his posse genocides the population of every town he visits?

      • #427447
        Anonymous
        Guest

        Rhodes was deserved. Strawberry got fucked, though. Would have let Micah get hanged if I could. Front row seats with popcorn and everything.

        • #427448
          Anonymous
          Guest

          >Rhodes was deserved
          Yeah, nah, of you think that then you must be willfully ignoring all the shit they did in that chapter

          • #427450
            Anonymous
            Guest

            >steal moonshine from swamp cretins
            >sell moonshine to hillbilly rednecks
            >this means a gang member must die
            Okay Karen

    • #427445
      Anonymous
      Guest

      HE’S A FUCKING WHITE MALE

    • #427451
      Anonymous
      Guest

      Arthur is a moralfag

      • #427453
        Anonymous
        Guest

        arthur is just a fag. feminist, melanoid lover. ridiculous that a man like that in that time would give a single shit about social issues
        >but he thought he was robin hood!
        yeah but the way hes written he would gladly kill a man for naming the very garden gnome hes supposed to be rebelling against, because hes written with modern sjw ideals and not a man of the period.

        i fucking hated this game, mainly for the gameplay, the story shit im used to by now since almost every game is cucked

        • #427454
          Anonymous
          Guest

          >kill a man for naming the very garden gnome
          I’n convinced the only reason the game doesn’t refer to Strauss as gnomish is that doing so would make it awkward when Arthur kicks him out of camp for predatory money-lending.

          • #427455
            Anonymous
            Guest

            arthur is basically this guy

            • #427458
              Anonymous
              Guest

              Not really, since being feminist and anti-racist in 1899 would have been genuinely revolutionary. Also the gang’s philosophy is more anarcho-primitivist than modern day style social justice.

              • #427461
                Anonymous
                Guest

                sjws also think that theyre genuinely revolutionary

                • #427528
                  Anonymous
                  Guest

                  The fuck is your point, dweeb? The other anon is right.

    • #427456
      Anonymous
      Guest

      ITT just a bunch of edgelords seething that the protagonist doesn’t hate blacks and natives.
      Y’all probably sobbed when you were forced to kill KKK members.

      • #427459
        Anonymous
        Guest

        It doesn’t make sense how Arthur is a bandit, a outlaw, and a murderer that’s killed a TON of people but he draws the line at racism lol

        • #427460
          Anonymous
          Guest

          Yeah, he’s a bandit. Demonized by the government. It kinda makes sense he’d band together with other groups demonized by the government (natives, blacks, etc.

      • #427532
        Anonymous
        Guest

        aren’t they (and the eugenics dude in st denis) exclusively random encounters? you can just leave leave them alone if you want to.

        • #427534
          Anonymous
          Guest

          I can’t imagine you go a full playthrough (even just main questline only) without seeing at least one group of KKK. I’m pretty sure they’re hostile on site too, so it’s either kill, run, or be killed.

          • #427535
            Anonymous
            Guest

            they aren’t hostile on site and they’re completely optional. They’re a random event in the woods in Lemoyne

      • #427540
        Anonymous
        Guest

        Why do you not care about murdering but hearing the word melanoid is too far for you?

    • #427462
      Anonymous
      Guest

      Someone explain to me the Molly situation because it seems like a massive plot hole to me.

      >Molly comes back claiming she’s the rat and told them everything
      >the gang kills her because "those are the rules"
      >it’s later revealed by the main pinkerton guy that Molly didn’t say a word and it was all Micah

      So why the fuck did Molly lie about her being the rat when she wasn’t? she knew she was going to get killed for it so it’s not like they could have bribed her or paid her off. It literally makes no sense what motivation she could have to take the blame for Micah when she didn’t do it. Even if it was pure spite or something, she would have ACTUALLY told the pinkertons information if she just wanted to spite the gang, but she refused to tell them anything and then died to cover for Micah? why?

      • #427465
        Anonymous
        Guest

        because she was drunk off her ass and thought she’d make a shocking reveal

        it was just a cry for attention

        • #427466
          Anonymous
          Guest

          that doesn’t make any sense. If she wanted to she could have actually told the pinkertons something if she wanted attention, and she knew she was going to be killed for it. Why wouldn’t she ACTUALLY tell them something if she wanted the shocking attention. Why lie and face the consequences and not even collect the rewards

          • #427472
            Anonymous
            Guest

            she wasn’t planning on getting killed for it
            she thought that Dutch wouldn’t believe that she really did it and hold her close or something like that

      • #427467
        Anonymous
        Guest

        >So why the fuck did Molly lie about her being the rat when she wasn’t?

        She’s an upper class rich cunt, was drunk and was buttmad at Dutch for not wanting to fuck her her anymore. Making up bullshit to get attention is pretty in character.

        sjws also think that theyre genuinely revolutionary

        Thinking you’re revolutionary and being revolutionary is not the same thing. Also, I doubt corporations really give a fuck about LGBT shit. It’s just marketing.

        • #427468
          Anonymous
          Guest

          >I doubt corporations really give a fuck about LGBT shit
          thats the fucking point

          • #427469
            Anonymous
            Guest

            But SJWs are genuine in their support of LGBT, corporations are not. So SJWs do not actually agree with corporations. The corporations have just co-opted an originally counter-cultural movement. I went to university, I’ve been around leftwingers. Most of them are well aware that the corporations are not really on their side.

            • #427470
              Anonymous
              Guest
              • #427477
                Anonymous
                Guest

                I hope you not implying I’m some kind of discord faggot because if this was the old west we would be dueling in the street over that kind of accusation.

                absolute bullshit because they cheer this shit on at every turn, support every single act of corporate censorship, and act as their foot soldiers on the ground every turn. As soon as one of these corporations faces backlash they claim it’s because of their gay women employees and the SJW mobs rush to their defence. you see it with every film and movie that bombs, you see it in this very thread. stop lying.

                There are hundreds of millions of leftists in the west. No group that large is going to agree on everything and most people conform to what they believe is socially acceptable. That does not mean that every leftwing person is retarded.

                • #427479
                  Anonymous
                  Guest

                  >That does not mean that every leftwing person is retarded
                  sorry friend, you fired the first shot, at your own crotch

                • #427481
                  Anonymous
                  Guest

                  leftists universally love sucking corporate cock. It is way too late in the game to deny this, it’s out in the open for everyone to see. Sorry mate, you’re not a rebel you’re a useful idiot

                  • #427482
                    Anonymous
                    Guest

                    Who is currently more in favor of all the labor strikes happening currently? Leftists or right wingers?

                    • #427483
                      Anonymous
                      Guest

                      deflection

                      • #427484
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        It’s not deflection. That one statement completely dismantles your point. You’re just talking out of your ass.

                      • #427486
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        lefties are in favour of whatever the media and corporations tell them to be in favour of. This is a well known fact. You are 5 years too late to argue otherwise, everyone knows this. Literally the most easily manipulated people on the planet

                      • #427488
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        >This is a well known fact
                        where’d you learn this? oh right, from fox news and your incel cope circle lmao. hypocrite retard go outside for 5 minutes in your life.

                      • #427492
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        You are quite literally 5 years too late to pretend otherwise. It’s well past the point of denial. You will believe whatever you’re told to believe by your handlers, no exceptions.

                      • #427494
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        It seems like you consider MSNBC or CNN to be leftists outlets or something. That’s the only way I can see you coming to that conclusion.
                        If you do think that way, you’re just a retard. Leftists hate those networks probably more than rightoids.

                      • #427497
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        stop killing babies

                      • #427498
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        Stop raping kids

                      • #427509
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        not catholic but their priests are statistically less likely to fiddle kids than your school teachers
                        STOP RAPING KIDS

                      • #427499
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        Lol, fucking sad NPC response. And I’m supposed to be the one brainwashed by corporate media? Look in a mirror. SAD!

                        keep thinking you’re rebellious for believing everything the media says and thinking the people they censor are evil and don’t need to speak lmao. very rebellious qualities you have there fighting for the defence of oligarchs

                      • #427502
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        God damn you are strawmanning so fucking hard. Who are you even arguing against? Because I’ve given no defense of the corporate media. The only thing I’ve said is that your views of leftists are deranged.

                      • #427503
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        bootlicker cope

                      • #427504
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        Keep projecting harder zaddy.

                      • #427505
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        youre talking to different people. the very first person to bring it up and you started arguing against who then called you a tranny was me, the one youre also talking about australia with. someone else, possibly multiple people are the ones whove been pooping on you ever since

                      • #427506
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        There’s 2 different people replying as well. Because I was not called a tranny in any responses.

                      • #427507
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        well the picture was meant to call you a tranny since its a screenshot of a discord tranny crying that the raids arent working

                      • #427490
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        What do you think leftists are? You sound like you’re just regurgitating Cucker Tarlkson talking points.
                        Just because you say something is a well known fact doesn’t make it so. It’s a well known fact that all right wingers all secretly worship Stalin. We both can make up ridiculous statements with no basis in reality.

                      • #427493
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        yeah I’m not going to recount the events of the last decade for you in a single Ganker post lmao. Just continue believing whatever corporate media feeds you and be happy in your stupor as you’re accustomed to

                      • #427496
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        Lol, fucking sad NPC response. And I’m supposed to be the one brainwashed by corporate media? Look in a mirror. SAD!

                      • #427495
                        Anonymous
                        Guest

                        just go watch your favourite corporate sanctioned eceleb goy

                    • #427489
                      Anonymous
                      Guest

                      Leftists stopped pretending to care about the working class years ago, if anyone was actually paying attention.

                  • #427487
                    Anonymous
                    Guest

                    >That does not mean that every leftwing person is retarded
                    sorry friend, you fired the first shot, at your own crotch

                    I’m not the strawman you seem to think I am. I have more than a few opinions that are not allowed in leftist circles. I just don’t think that leftwing = retarded and rightwing = intellectual gigachad.

                    how about this. pinkerton trying to clean up new york while everyone is out west. clashing with italian gangs until youre forced to leave the country because theyre hunting you down, and you go to australia where the western feel returns and youre no longer in the city

                    The northeast doesn’t have that frontier feel. I think the only things that would be fresh whilst still being recognisable as a western would be Australia, Canada or maybe something in the Mexican revolution.

            • #427471
              Anonymous
              Guest

              absolute bullshit because they cheer this shit on at every turn, support every single act of corporate censorship, and act as their foot soldiers on the ground every turn. As soon as one of these corporations faces backlash they claim it’s because of their gay women employees and the SJW mobs rush to their defence. you see it with every film and movie that bombs, you see it in this very thread. stop lying.

    • #427476
      Anonymous
      Guest

      red dead redemption 3 is going to be about a lone pinkerton trying to police a different region while everyone else is dying to arthur. the story is going to be better, but the gameplay will be even more obnoxious and sjw shit will be even more prevalent

    • #427485
      Anonymous
      Guest

      thats just it
      hes a gud boi caught with the right crowd in the wrong time

    • #427500
      Anonymous
      Guest

      Did you somehow forget all the crime he committed with the gang all those years?

    • #427508
      Anonymous
      Guest

      He literally kills like 100 people every time they rob something.

      • #427510
        Anonymous
        Guest

        Cops aren’t people

        • #427511
          Anonymous
          Guest

          based

        • #427515
          Anonymous
          Guest

          They’re sheriffs and deputies from out in the podunk late-1800s west. They weren’t modern burgercommie policeman larpers.

        • #427523
          Anonymous
          Guest

          You get lost on your way to twitter, melanoid lover?

          • #427524
            Anonymous
            Guest

            We don’t much like government employees round these parts, partner.

            • #427525
              Anonymous
              Guest

              Too bad because we don’t care if you like us.

              • #427526
                Anonymous
                Guest

                Pinkertons glow in the fucking dark. You just run them over with your horse. It’s not illegal to kill space aliens.

                • #427527
                  Anonymous
                  Guest

                  Ain’t going to change this, partner. Law always wins.

                  • #427531
                    Anonymous
                    Guest

                    cowardice
                    this scene is pure cowardice
                    i mad
                    pic fucking related

    • #427512
      Anonymous
      Guest

      thats a mighty fine arthur you got there feller

      • #427545
        Anonymous
        Guest

        Arthur posting thread?

    • #427513
      Anonymous
      Guest

      >morally-gray
      >kill innocent US soldiers in the penultimate missions
      Arthur deserves to die.

      • #427514
        Anonymous
        Guest

        >US soldiers
        >innocent
        lel

        • #427516
          Anonymous
          Guest

          >t sandmelanoid

          • #427517
            Anonymous
            Guest

            >t. bootlicker

            • #427518
              Anonymous
              Guest

              >t goatfucker

              • #427519
                Anonymous
                Guest

                >t. incel

                • #427520
                  Anonymous
                  Guest

                  >t. femcel

                  • #427521
                    Anonymous
                    Guest

                    literally no such thing

                    • #427522
                      Anonymous
                      Guest

                      >literally no such thing
                      your brain in a nutshell.

    • #427536
      Anonymous
      Guest

      Audiences are so unbelievably stupid every character has to be one-dimensional. If you want to have a character who is good at the end of a story it has to be constantly pounded into the audiences’ mind or they simply won’t get it.

      • #427538
        Anonymous
        Guest

        Yep. Venom Let There Be Carnage being a success proved that to me. Shit is Transformers tier.

        • #427541
          Anonymous
          Guest

          I think that’s why Squid Games is so popular, it’s not made for the LCD so to your average consumer it looks like incomprehensible magic-tier storytelling, even though it’s merely decent.

    • #427542
      Anonymous
      Guest

      I mean, he’s also a extortionists who beats the shit out of poor debtors and robs and kills people but sure.

    • #427543
      Anonymous
      Guest

      Anon he beats the fuck out of that sick guy entirely because he got butthurt at him. First for asking him to donate to charity (When Arthur goes out of his way to talk to him) and secondly to break up a fight when Arthur’s going too far and gives the guy brain damage. Arthur was a butthurt faggot and got a fitting ending.

    • #427544
      Anonymous
      Guest

      No the most evil thing he did was take money from a man dying of a critical illness, therefore damning the wife and son to a short life of abject poverty and demoralization.

    • #427546
      Anonymous
      Guest

      >what were they thinking
      Rockstar are really fucking bad writers. Normalfags that watch nothing but TV dramas and Capeshit think this is good writing because they’re brainlets.

      • #427547
        Anonymous
        Guest

        based fellow modder

        • #427548
          Anonymous
          Guest

          It pisses me off the online content isn’t in the vanilla game.

          • #427549
            Anonymous
            Guest

            even worse is seeing how quickly people have modded in Mexico. Minus no pathfinding for AI, the entire world space for mexico is still in the game and explorable for some reason. bugs me how much better this game could’ve been

    • #427550
      Anonymous
      Guest

      Are we ever going to get actual bad guy criminals as protagonists?
      Kane and lynch happened but all the faggots hated it
      All mature and dark game these days only have gay anti heroes
      they should’ve went full blood meridian with this game but no we have the stale Reddit anti hero shit
      FUCK YOU

      • #427551
        Anonymous
        Guest

        Based, my exact thoughts. 3, Vice City, and Liberty City Stories are the only GTA games where you play as a bad guy with no "heart of gold" antihero bullshit.

    • #427552
      Anonymous
      Guest

      Yeah, not breaking out Micah and killing a small town

    • #427553
      Anonymous
      Guest

      looks like nic cage

Viewing 35 reply threads
  • The forum ‘A haunted junk yard’ is closed to new topics and replies.