Should I buy this or Luigis Mansion 2 HD? I haven't played wonder or lm 1 though.

Should I buy this or Luigis Mansion 2 HD?
I haven't played wonder or lm 1 though.

Tip Your Landlord Shirt $21.68

DMT Has Friends For Me Shirt $21.68

Tip Your Landlord Shirt $21.68

  1. 3 days ago
    Anonymous

    Depends on if you prefer mario or luigi games

  2. 3 days ago
    Anonymous

    What Mario games have you played/enjoyed?

    • 3 days ago
      Anonymous

      I like mario 64, sunshine, paper mario 1-2

      • 3 days ago
        Anonymous

        Then get Odyssey. Emulate Luigi's Mansion 1 before trying the sequels.

        • 3 days ago
          Anonymous

          Alright sounds good.
          Do you need to play LM 1 before playing 2?
          I dont like to emulate anymore so I'm stuck with whatever I can get on the switch.

          • 3 days ago
            Anonymous

            >Do you need to play LM 1 before playing 2?
            LM1 is unironically the best one. It has the best atmosphere and is the only one who even tries to be a horror game.
            The others are good, but they are more comical with most of the horror gone and were outsorced.
            The sequels are also direct sequels, so yes, you have to play them in order.
            And LM1 is very short anyway, so it won't take long to beat it.

  3. 3 days ago
    Anonymous

    Different type of games, but definitely get Odyssey, this is not really a discussion. Ignore contrarians, Odyssey is a masterpiece.

    • 3 days ago
      Anonymous

      I am, I just wish I could get Galaxy 1+2 first but they aren't on the switch.

      • 3 days ago
        Anonymous

        3D Mario All-stars came out and it was only available for a limited time and didn't include Galaxy 2.
        Sometimes when people say "Nintendo is leaving money on the table" or "Nintendo hates to make money" I think it's usually not true, but 3D Mario All-stars was the perfect example of that. It'd keep selling and they made it limited for no real reason.
        And because of that I haven't played Galaxy 2 to this day which sucks

        https://i.imgur.com/0jSCGla.jpeg

        Should I buy this or Luigis Mansion 2 HD?
        I haven't played wonder or lm 1 though.

        If you love Mario then get Odyssey, it's great.

        • 3 days ago
          Anonymous

          >And because of that I haven't played Galaxy 2 to this day which sucks
          It's not because of that, if you were so desperate to play Galaxy 2 you easily could right now

          • 3 days ago
            Anonymous

            >ACHUALLLY IT'S NOT BECAUSE NINTENDO DIDN'T INCLUDE THE GAME

            • 3 days ago
              Anonymous

              I have no idea what kind of reply that is. Again, if you wanted to play it so bad there's a good solution. You just don't want to play it and would rather give money to Nintendo

              • 3 days ago
                Anonymous

                I couldn't care less that you're a fanboy but just get over yourself, it's 2024

              • 3 days ago
                Anonymous

                There's no fanboyism here, I'm just saying it's not because of Nintendo you're not playing Galaxy 2.
                You can easily emulate it right now, access to Galaxy 2 isn't an impossibility.
                If you want to offer Nintendo money for a crappy port that's on you for being an idiot but don't pretend you don't have means of playing it right now.

              • 3 days ago
                Anonymous

                >I'm just saying it's not because of Nintendo
                It is, moron.

              • 3 days ago
                Anonymous

                I see, you don't have a PC then, that's sad
                Who's the biggest fanboy here, you who would rather wait patiently for Nintendo to re-release a 15 year old game which you will buy for 60 bucks without second thought or me who already played it many years ago emulated without offering a cent to them?

              • 3 days ago
                Anonymous

                Peak consoomer

  4. 3 days ago
    Anonymous

    Odyssey is very good until you reach the ending - postgame just adds bloat and there's barely anything new to experience ("catch the rabbit" in every world, "Koopa Race" in every world, "find Peach" in every world, "use binoculars to spot something" in every world, more musical notes / hat dummy challenges in every world, etc., and mystery rocks just spawn a bunch of random moons; optional content in last world also disappoints). The only really good postgame content is the optional world you get right after ending.
    LM2 is pretty short but sweet, and optional modes / postgame content is also not for everyone's taste.
    I'd say Odyssey is a better investment for your money (it's a great game to experience at least once) and even base game is pretty long (as long as you don't rush through everything) - LM2 is much shorter and I think HD remaster is overpriced.

    • 3 days ago
      Anonymous

      I liked the postgame pipes but yeah it's just more of the same
      Getting all the moons surprisingly wasn't as bad as anons made it sound in here
      I'm not going to gold grind all the outfits though

      • 3 days ago
        Anonymous

        Postgame challenge rooms were fine but some of them were literally repeats of previous ones but with some new condition (like "Make-A-Mario-Face" #2 or that Bullet Bill challenge room where now you had to do a fast sequence of long jumps in a row, press a button/switch and then instantly go back and do that long jump sequence again).
        >Getting all the moons surprisingly wasn't as bad as anons made it sound in here
        I didn't imply it was THAT bad, but it surely wasn't really exciting (again, moonrocks spawned some random ass moons - some just popped up in open field and took zero effort to grab, some were spawned in some trivial platforming segments and some were spawned in new or rehashed challenge rooms; binocular / Peach / Koopa Races / rabbit ones were fine at first, but it is because they were so trivial that I didn't feel much about them outside of "okay, 20 minutes later I'm done with all new moons in this kingdom, time to do that again in next 10 kingdoms". Mushroom Kingdom was fricking perfect for postgame content and after 100% it I felt that pretty much every other postgame moon was unnecessary (outside of maybe Darker Side of the Moon, but my gripe with it was that it was supposed to be the ultimate platforming challenge of the game yet you didn't even have to use full potential of Odyssey's moveset to beat it.
        >I'm not going to gold grind all the outfits though
        I always felt those stupidly expensive costumes were added for people who stick around to play Luigi's Balloon World

  5. 3 days ago
    Anonymous

    Luigi's Mansion 2 was so much fun on the 3ds I never completed it knowing that one day my life would be turbo shit and I would need it in my life again.

    Mario's Odyssey was mediocre leaving the audience like mario himself in-game wanting for more.

  6. 3 days ago
    Anonymous

    If you're going to play a Luigi's Mansion game on Switch, you might as well get the third one instead. Looks better, plays better, has more content, etc.

    • 3 days ago
      Anonymous

      I dunno, I got bored halfway through and haven't picked it up again. They haven't been able to recreate the soul and atmosphere of the original

  7. 3 days ago
    Anonymous

    Don't support remasters, get Odyssey

  8. 3 days ago
    Anonymous

    emulate LM1 its the only one worth playing anyway. Odyssey is genuinely the best game on the Switch so its a must play.

  9. 3 days ago
    Anonymous

    Odyssey was the most boring Mario game i've ever played

  10. 3 days ago
    Anonymous

    Why not luigi's mansion 3?
    It's probably better as a begginer game than 2, although I personally enjoyed 1 more than 3, has more soul to it, while 3 is just too much gimmicks that really don't add to the experience, specially the water battles where you have to maneuver the boat at the same time you fight the boss.

    • 3 days ago
      Anonymous

      Because unlike most other mario games the luigi's mansion games have continuity.

  11. 3 days ago
    Anonymous

    I bought oddesy and it's been fun so far.
    Trying to find all these moon pieces before moving on is rough.
    I'm stuck on one involving chain chomps but I've already cleared the pool mini game area and messed with them all already

  12. 3 days ago
    Anonymous

    go with Luigi’s mansion is you’re a millennial. I bought odyssey used and it’s pretty boring. seems really slow paced and the worlds are pretty empty which is amplified by how meh the aesthetics are

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *