Whats your opinion on pic related?

Meh, forgotten land did so many things right that this one feels mid. The SNES and NES games are better imo.

mediocre like 95% of the kirby franchise

Enjoyed my whole revisit on it and I love Sand and Mecha Abilities

Played it via rental from Gamefly because no way was i buying something I played a decade ago for $60. Wish it had online, Both the Main mode and the mini-games. Now that all the missions are done there's nothing to fucking do anymore. Same exact problem Luigi mansion 3's minigame mode had. sure would've liked to play rtld with Ganker.
Also should've incorporated the extra challenge mode from the 20th anniversary, they ran on the same engine so it should not have been hard to do other than pure laziness.

in fact everything you can say about this remake is lazy. Should've had more returning abilities in it. Dont give a shit about Magolor his mode, its just fighting a bunch of enemies in backwards levels from the main game and bosses are just more reskins. Also no letting you solo play as Waddle Dee, Meta Knight or Dedede still locked behind needing a second controller.
Still say Kirby 64 is the game that should've been the one to get remade. Original rtdl still holds up just fine.

Mario 3 etc have better physics. There's just nothing original here that also feels satisfying to overcome in the same way the first kirby game (or mario 3 etc) did.

The extra gamemodes, the one that rank you are worth playing though. I don't know how much of these are different from their wii counterpart.

Magadolor's extra mode also ranks you but you just grind and buy powerups so you can chain more efficiently; I had the same issue with 3D Land or whatever it's called. Blowout Blast is better. There's powerups but they aren't incoroped into the level design as well as older kirby games. And I'm tired of Nintendo 'remaking' games. Come with something new.

Very good remake, liked it alot. Magolor's Epilogue is one of my favorite postgame modes in the series now, the True Arena is a good contender for best in the series, and game's just very solid overall.

I wished it had some more challenge stages for the other copy abilities because I genuinely love trying to get Platinums in those, the "speedrunner" aspect of Kirby is often one of my favorite parts of this series when its emphasized in modes like Guest Star and Metaknightmare.

here was clearly a lot of passion put into it, Magoland has so much shit to do and elevates the remake to be up there with one of games I'd probably bring to a party like with Mario Kart or Smash for Checkerboard Chase on Turbo speed alone. Would replay again in two months or so.

Pointless and honestly doesn't look like it changes drastically but what new stuff is there is pretty good and visually it looks good too. Respect for the new Magalor soul boss too. I still don't think it was a complete gamechanger like Super star ultra however

At what point will jannies do their fucking job and ban Eric/Victor for intentionally shitting up threads and constant tripfagging and console warring for Sony, his ban would be a genuine improvement for the board

It's a decent remake. It kept a lot of the old ability mechanics such as being unable to jump cancel out of their dash aerials to try to stay true to the original game while adding in some new moves such as twister slash for sword and a chargeable hammer flip. A couple of the levels added some conveniences to reduce backtracking if you missed a sphere which is a plus, but otherwise it's still the same mediocre level design rtdl had. Bosses getting i-frames when getting hit returns and there were some minor nerfs in damage for some of the top abilities in this game (aerial quad shock, hammer, fighter), which slightly makes the arenas a bit harder. Mecha is really fun with its moveset and the dash into instant laser, though it really would've benefited in a game w/o boss i-frames since single hit damages are preferred. Sand is one of the best abilities as it has a lot of coverage options, a sand fist that rivals old hammer flip's damage, and leaf's guard with an OOS jump attack. The new magolor subgame is fun especially with that combo counter that encourages landing multiple hits on an enemy, moving fast, & avoiding damage. The new bosses are a bit mediocre and too easy at times mostly because HAL chose to base it off of the story mode versions instead of extra mode. the Master Crown fight is neat, though it focused more on spectacle than difficulty. HR-D3 getting some buffs to its moveset was a surprise & Galacta having Aeon Hero's move was nice since by this point, everyone is familiar with how he fights. The True Arena Magolor Soul fight receiving a big revamp is definitely one of the highlights for me since it was a joke of a fight back then. Overall, a nice experience for most kirby fans & a decent entry point for newer ones coming in from Forgotten Land.