SMTsisters, we can't be losing
 Shopping Cart Returner Shirt $21.68 |
 Tip Your Landlord Shirt $21.68 |
Shopping Cart Returner Shirt $21.68 |
Persona 3 and Persona 2 are ATLUS fans most wanted remakes
SMTsisters, we can't be losing
Shopping Cart Returner Shirt $21.68 |
Tip Your Landlord Shirt $21.68 |
Shopping Cart Returner Shirt $21.68 |
>Raidou 1
it deserves to be re-made, by another devs.
>DDS1
Not necessary, also, chiaki is cute af.
>by another devs
Yamai is literally the last competent dev at atlus, why would anyone but him remake his own game
I know that, the issue is Atlus can't make arpgs property, raidou 1 had the right idea (imagine the broken will be the buffs/debuffs), they're good in turn based combat but i'd let another studio to make it but with yamai watching the things like a hawk.
Persona started at 3
Ok, so it's basically confirmed they'll remake+new entry raidou. Persona may be higher on that list, but the ports won't come out untill next year, so a remake being in the works right now makes no sense
>milk and diming people with a P3P demo to then show off a definitive version of Persona 3
Atlus absolutely would
never forget that the original catherine got ported to pc well after atlus announced full body
porting p3p at the same time as making a remake to sell later definitely isn't out of the question for them
P2 won't get shit because nobody fricking buys it.
The rest either got ported already, or at best MIGHT get one.
>+new entry raidou
I don’t think so. Raidou is banned in China and Korea, because of his appearance. Plus, his games subtly say that Japan dindu nuffiin in WW2.
That's a man in OP, right?
>Persona 2
Overrated, and playable.
Persona 1 needs/deserves a remake far more.
>Persona 3
Atlus doesn't need to do much other than modding FeMC into the Festival edition.
>Persona 1 needs/deserves a remake far more.
If anything P2 needs more the remake because the combat is so easy and honestly quite shite. By comparison the combat in P1 is quite better even if its more complicated.
Both still need a remake tho.
DDS needs an HD remaster like nocturne so zoomies can experience them
Persona 2 is so overrated on the internet
Unlike nu-sona, right?
Well P3 and P4 are actually good, the P2 games are mediocre but people prop them up because it's the contrarian choice
>raidou
DDS remake would be amazing, I can see Atlus making it into an action rpg with combat similar to Strikers. It’s not my favorite combat ever by a long shot but just seeing the story be remade with much better animation, graphics and sound quality would be worth it for me.
Atlus has no problem with turn based combat, unlike a lot of other jrpg devs. I don't see how or why they would change the genre of their games, especially since they can just do Raidou if they want a fricking action game
>I don't see how or why they would change the genre of their games
True, but consider how Atlus already has two turn-based series in Persona (that targets the general public) and SMT (that targets hobbyists), you can totally remake DDS with turn-based combat and target the hobbyists, since they are the ones who cared about the original in the first place, but since they are probably still gonna buy the game anyways because what they primarily cared about was the story anyways, why not use it to experiment, to try and pitch DDS as its own unique thing, to try to gain experience on how to create a proper action rpg (which atlus isn’t particularly good at atm)?
It’s only a logical move, to try to diversify your output specially in these times when turn-based rpgs just don’t sell like they used to. All according to keikaku see? (Keikaku means plan).
I don't know why you are ignoring the simple fact that raidou exists but whatever, draw your own "logical" conclusions
Yes, raidou exists, but whereas keeping 3 different IPs with similar aesthetics and turn-based combat can be a bit dicey, the market is such that there would easily be enough demand to maintain both DDS and Raidou as different IPs with action combat without them canibalizing eachother.
And then there’s the factor that DDS will probably never turn into a series of its own, DDS 1+2 are a self contained affair and I’ll honestly eat my shorts if DDS 3 is ever a thing. In that way, making DDS into an action RPG would make sense to test out ideas for a possible Raidou reboot, which is sensible when you consider that there’s not been a raidou game in more than a decade.
Let's ignore Soul Hackers right. Proving Atlus will make more turn based regardless.
>Let's ignore Soul Hackers right.
Well, you want to talk about it then?, because I feel that it’s obvious that they’ve completely ditched the kind of aesthetic and atmosphere the original Soul Hackers and the Devil Summoner games were going for. It feels like SH2 takes more from Tokyo Mirage Sessions than it does its own namesake.
They’ve done this because they knew that turn-based games live or die by their aesthetic presentation and it needed to stand out both from SMT and Persona, the result is kind of a chimera imho, and I feel like we would have been served better as fans if they had kept the original’s identity and tried to differentiate the IP through gameplay instead. Who knows?, maybe it could have been 50% RPG, 50% a mystery VN type of thing. The originals were about being devil summoner AND a detective too after all.
>ARPG
>player can change the characters in DDS, including argilla and heat.
>same artwork
>Estoma and Riberama as skills
I wish, but the author's rights..
Meh, they need something new.
osoiyo anon-kun.
SEX with that woman
I'd accept a Raidou remake BUT only if it combined both games together.
Digital Devil Kino 1+2 need remakes
the upcoming P3 port is a bitter pill, pretty much seals it from ever getting a definitive edition.
>The garbage SMTIV games are on there
>Even Apocalypse which only released about 6 years ago
Literally 3ds games, they could have come out yesterday and they'd still need a remake
What would you do to them, make them full 3D? Seems like a bit of a waste of time. I guess they could un-frick up the SMTIV combat but there's not really anything substantial to do to them. Then again it is Atlus we're talking about
I'm not saying they should do it, I'm just saying that it makes sense that IV fans would want a version of the game on a real console
they need to make the models, everything else is already there,
A question for al of you people, if they remade SMTIV would you like to see it heavily altered to try and recreate the original concept for the game, which included many of the elements from apocalypse that ended up getting scrapped and later becoming a (heavily altered) sequel?
Koga Saburo looks like a Yugioh monster but I can't think of which one
It kinda reminds me of a gouki monster
Hate on Doi all you want, but he genuinely did a good job with re-illustrating the guest designs in Apocalypse, so I'd like to see him do the rest, for better or worse. Yamai should also return as a director. He's the only one I trust to respect Kaneko's rough draft of IV, but realistically they'll probably let some random young programmer direct and frick it up.
The fact that Atlu doesn’t put the same kind of stock producing Persona than they do when it comes to SMT is both a curse and a blessing, both thanks to hacks eager to try terrible ideas and slightly less hack-y guys eager to try genius ones.
It'd just be another spinoff at that point
Make it SMT6 but incorporate all those elements
Dont give a frick
Make the game actually fun to play first
Makoto Yuki bros? OUR EMO BOY WON!
>Persona 3 remake
Pointless, it's still perfectly playable and comparable to 4 and 5
>Persona 1 and 2
Worthwhile and necessary, those games are held back by the gameplay being as old as it is
Persona.....2?
Ain't the ending of BOTH the P2 games is that they literally retcon themselves out of existance?
So no
>Ain't the ending of BOTH the P2 games is that they literally retcon themselves out of existance?
no?
only IS is retconned. The current Persona timeline takes place after EP.
Maybe you should play videogames before pretending you know anything about them.
P1 deserves it more than 2 or 3.
If they pull the trigger, I say take the RE approach and go in order.
Frick, man. I just want to play SMT 1 and 2. Officially, I mean.
>I want to pay Atlus money
why?
>
1&2
They already had those fricking PSP ""remakes"". The japs can utterly frickiing neck themselves. They deserve another nuke in particular though for Persona 4 even making the top fricking 10. You Black folk already got GOLDEN and it's on the FRICKING PC.
Where the -FRICK- is my SMT1, 2 and possibly If... REMAKE? Like Goddamn,come on.
Not remakes.
you already have PS1, sega CD, GBA, and mobile versions frick off
I WANT TO VISIT THE NUKED TOKYO AND TOKYO MILLENIUM IN 3D
TARD
NO ONE WANT TO REMAKE ONE OF THE BEST GAME EVER MADE
SHIN MEGAMI TENSEI 1?
JAPAN IS DEAD
I sincerely hope them broadcasting results means something for real persona fans. All we've got from this anniversary is the 20th arc system works fighting game, the worst version of p3 and the one good thing, 4G on PS4/5. Other than that this anniversary blows as an actual fan of purse owner
>this anniversary blows as an actual fan of purse owner
They could announce p6 after sh2 comes out, but it will just end up like p5. It's better if they just take their time instead of rushing announcements for the anniversary
who the fricked voted for P4?
>SMT IV and IVA remakes
I'd rather they remade I and II. IV and IVA are still very playable.
>DUDE P2'S WRITING IS SOOOO GODLIKE
don't fall for this meme, it's just as cringe and anime as any other jarpig, the pacing is horrible, the characters awaken their persona in the first 10 minutes and no one even acknowledges it. full of cringe characters like pic related or that one dev self insert that ruins every scene. whiplash transitions between melodrama and bad comedy. main character is an edgy loner but also a total mysterious hunk that everyone in school thinks is super sugoi. eikichi is an unfunny cartoon character. I could go on and on
>I could go on and on
Please do
FRICKING PERSONA 3 PORTABLE
I'M STILL MAD
FRICKING USELESS SEGA c**tS
A remake of Persona 3 would actually be welcome, as it would be a great opportunity to fix all the flaws that piece of shit has. It's the worst paced Persona game with a decent soundtrack, there's a lot to improve on.
It's like how I wish Capcom would have remade Code Veronica instead of an already solid game like RE4.
filtered
>persona 3 fanboy can only speak in buzzwords
I guess I would too if I were in your shoes, it's hard to defend Persona 3's myriad of flaws otherwise.
>It's like how I wish Capcom would have remade Code Veronica instead of an already solid game like RE4
based
lmao there's no fixing P3 unless you make it a new game in the first place
I don't want any remakes. I want Raidou 3 and Persona 6
atlus is incredibly mismanaged and the persona studio is saving their asses
they should've greenlit a 3 remake in the style of 5 after p5's success while a skeleton team worked on royal
Mainline SMT has always been boring, dull, souless grinding shit. Endless dungeon crawling with nothing to break it up. All of the SMT offshoots have always been better, because they add what is missing from the mainline: Actual fricking story and characters.
>All of those have already had remakes of some sort except SMTIV and DDS
Wow...
Threads like these remind me that not even P3gays like their game, otherwise they wouldn't be so desperate for a remake.
P3gays are just nostalgic zoomers that cling to 3 because it was muh first persona game. P4 is a mechanical improvement over 3, and P3's story was a let down compared to P2's.
>zoomers
it came out in 2006
this is the most attractive female in the entire nation of Japan btw
Cutie
>Remake raidou
>Gets completely banned in china and korea
nice
Goddamnit we don't need a Persona 3 remake, I'm in fact against any Persona remake and revivals of series that's missing staff that were vital to them
Persona games are intrinsically tied to the era they were made, especially P1&P2 duology.
I don't trust anyone to faithfully recreate P3, it's basically impossible.
I am however fine with remasters or rereleases that strictly improve or enhances features in the games that were unbalanced or unintended.
I'd rather Atlus just moves forward and creates an entirely new game that's carried by their current staff, SH2 is a necessary sacrifice that has to flop so they won't reach out and bastardize anything old anymore.
Either move on from the past or transform it in such a way that it can stand on its own two feet while respecting the previous work.
My main concern with a P3 remake is they'll frick the ending up like they did in literally every adaptation. FES and P3P frick with the game's themes too with Chidori and Shinjiro respectively.
I just want a definitive P3 with The Answer/Episode Aegis chapter, Aigis SL, and an unlockable FeMC playthrough.
>they'll frick the ending up
You can't frick up P3s ending because it's hard canon and referenced across all future games,especially the crossovers like Q or Arena. Besides literally one of the endings is about what happens if the MC doesn't fulfill their destiny and does what has to be done.
lulz
Persona is also #3 and #4, lmao. SMTchuds can't stop losing. Literally the only one not there is 5.
Who the frick voted for 4? It’s still perfectly playable through Golden.
Zoomers hate "old" graphics. Personally I think the PS2 models are charming.
Etrianfriends we made it. We're not dead yet.
Gib Next. NOW.
How much you want to bet that more people want Soul Hackers remake than "Soul Hackers" 2?
Soul Hackers already was remade. And so was Persona 2.
the P2 remakes play the exact same and therefore do not address their problems.
The GUI is completely different, and 90% of JRPG gameplay is the battle against the GUI.
That doesn't change the high encounter rate or extremely repetitive combat or the grind to get Persona cards
This is the people who voted in the survey:
Shin Megami Tensei titles the most people played as their first:
1. Shin Megami Tensei [Super Famicom]
2. Digital Devil Story: Megami Tensei [Famicom]
3. Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne [PS2]
4. Devil Children: Red Book/Black Book [GBC]
5. Shin Megami Tensei V and Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne HD
Persona titles the most people played as their first:
1. Revelations: Persona [PS1/Windows]
2. Persona 3 Portable [PSP]
3. Persona 3 [PS2]
4. Persona 5 [PS3/PS4]
5. Persona 4 [PS2]