Was Half-Life: Alyx a failure?

Well?

Beware Cat Shirt $21.68

POSIWID: The Purpose Of A System Is What It Does Shirt $21.68

Beware Cat Shirt $21.68

  1. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    I stopped caring about half life when the sfm scene for it died

    • 4 years ago
      Anonymous

      Hasn't its SFM scene had a bit of a resurgence lately with S2FM releasing? At least, there are a few people out there posting stuff somewhat regularly now.

  2. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    Not financially which is the only thing that matters to valve.

  3. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    Far from it. It exceeded valves expectations. The Valve index sold out much to their surprise. given that VR isnt mainstream- yet, it basically succeeded.

  4. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    Nah, I think it was great. My only fault with it is that it's another half life game with a shitty weapon selection. No two hand rifles or special energy weapons. Just a pistol, shotgun, and smg. Nades don't count and we didn't even get a melee weapon.

  5. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    Even if the game doesnt make gains by the end of the year, it will keep selling for at least 10 years as a must buy for VR for almost full price. so no, it wasnt a failure

  6. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    game desperately needed melee. Valve was cucks and thought people would hurt themselves or something

    Boneworks proved melee can be done. Its actually really fun in that game

    • 4 years ago
      Anonymous

      Valve removed melee because people thought they were playing as Gordan swinging a crowbar around and they didn't want people thinking that.

      • 4 years ago
        Anonymous

        >Valve playtesters

        • 4 years ago
          Anonymous

          >we had to remove [feature] because our playtesters couldn't figure out [basic concept]
          Why is it such a recurring thing with Valve? Where the hell do they find their playtesters?

      • 4 years ago
        Anonymous

        Even if that's the case, it's their fault for not coming up with a different solution while still retaining melee, just as it's their fault for not giving players the option of playing through the bigger winding cave system in EP2 that they cut out and made worse for everyone else just because a playtester was a moron.

      • 4 years ago
        Anonymous

        How do I become a playtester, from the sounds of things they have pretty low standards for entry.

    • 4 years ago
      Anonymous

      I feel like they were outdone in gameplay and replayability by Boneworks and Pavlov, the gun mechanics are so much more diverse and interesting in those games. The biggest highlight for me in Alyx was being able to interact with every object semi-authentically. Scavenging was interesting for the first few hours I guess.

  7. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    Not at all, but it wasn't Half Life 3.

  8. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    If you judge the success by the age old method of how much butthurt it generated on Ganker, then it was a tremendous success.

    • 4 years ago
      Anonymous

      If you judge "butthurt" by how much people aren't desperately defending something to justify their purchase of the required hardware to play it, then yeah it generated a lot of "butthurt"

  9. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    in every conceivable metric, yes

  10. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    what do you do in this game when you run out of ammo? just die? really frikkin stupid. The combat isnt difficult in the slightest its just artificial difficulty of not having enough ammo.. thanks to no melee system

    • 4 years ago
      Anonymous

      >running out of ammo
      How? yes the soldiers are often sponge bullets but missing with a pistol is an achievement, unless you have butter fingers.

  11. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    IMO no

  12. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    Retconned the cliffhanger ending of Episode 2 because they're pussies.

  13. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    Half Life Alyx is my favorite VR game. Can't wait to play it some day

  14. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    Absolutely not. If you have VR and played, you'd know.

  15. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    >retconned the ending of EP2, killing any interest in the franchise
    >didnt move enough units, failed to break evil
    >the platform it was supposed to be the killer app for is essentially dead and failed to garner any serious interest
    >absolutely nothing new or interesting in it story, writing or gameplaywise, trying to play as safe as humanly possible

    Yeah no shit its a failure on every possible level.

  16. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    For a game that requires extra 600$+ to play? Yeah

  17. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    It's a good game but also a pretty big disappointment after all those years of waiting.

  18. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    It was a major success and is even extremely overrated, definitely not a half-life 3, but a must buy if you have vr. By far the best game on the platform.

  19. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    people with VR will say its the best thing ever regardless because of the buyers remorse. Its pointless to ask

    • 4 years ago
      Anonymous

      >No! You're just poor!

  20. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    I'm about 3 hours in and I'm enjoying it. It feels like Half-Life, which shocked me since I expected it to be modernized in the worst ways imaginable with regenerating health and stuff like that. Though I do wish the characters would shut up, this game isn't as funny as its writers think it is. If only there was some mute protagonist they could've used instead of Alyx...
    But unless something really special happens between now and the end it's not the VR killer app everyone is saying it is. It's one of the best VR games out there but VR still has no killer app and VR will remain niche until it does. So in regards to them trying to make a VR killer app they failed, but they did succeed in making a Half-Life sequel when it comes to Alyx's gameplay.

    • 4 years ago
      Anonymous

      >If only there was some mute protagonist they could've used instead of Alyx...
      Of course, who could forget the main character of the franchise, Adrian Shephard

      • 4 years ago
        Anonymous

        Bring him back you bastards

  21. 4 years ago
    Anonymous

    No but it remains the only real game on VR. VR itself is the failure.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *