Do people still play Base Set cards?

Do people still play Base Set cards?
With so much hype for these cards you'd think there would be a massive community for playing them, even if just using proxy or tabletop sim.

It's All Fucked Shirt $22.14

Nothing Ever Happens Shirt $21.68

It's All Fucked Shirt $22.14

  1. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Not really, base set TCG is pretty unbalanced and "solved" so if you're ever playing it it'd just be for some fun or nostalgia for a short bit
    The hype for the cards is nothing more than Youtuber soishit where they buy the glowy sparkly Charizard from Kanto from their childhood for half a million and jerk off over it.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Base is okay, though Base-Jungle and Base-Fossil both shit on it. Base-Rocket and god forbid Base-Gym are no fun allowed nightmares though. The former 3 definitely take a shit on any meta in the past several years though.

  2. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Their value is in nostalgia

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Well, people play all sorts of old games out of nostalgia, it seems logical they'd do that with probably the most nostalgic tabletop game around.

  3. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    I'd be interested in playing some ex ruby sapphire format.
    It's a shame Pokémon doesn't have the same interest for vintage formats as Yu-Gi-Oh! has for their Goat and Edison formats.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Not to mention YGO's obnoxious number of video games preserving about the first decade of the game across various time capsules, albeit you are mostly stuck dueling similar batches of themed opponents. It would be neat if the TCG had a bit more of that.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        It's different because YGO's main game IS the tcg. Even the anime is about the tcg. The TCG is essentially a spinoff brand of the mainline pokemon -- the mainline being the games.

        Everything in the anime is for the handheld games, not for the tcg.

        I do agree with you, though. And I do wish there were more officially supported formats with the TCG, things like Gym Leader Challenge.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          The problem with supporting non-rotating formats is that it becomes harder to entice players to buy the newer sets. Instead of them being just a part of the course, you actually have to try and make them fun.
          You're also creating competition between your own product. Ideally you want everyone playing your game to be able to play with everyone else.
          The only reason PTCG might promote alternative formats is because they literally don't care. Players aren't their main customer base.

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            I'm not so sure about that. The other major card games don't rotate sets and people buy the newest sets all the time. Not to mention, collectors are a huge part of pokemon TCG and will buy new sets regardless.
            Also, Magic has multiple officially recognized formats in their game, but it doesn't detract from their main. It enhances it. Hell, I'd suspect having some more "wacky" side games would entice more players that wouldn't normally play (or would be burnt out from regular play) to enter the scene. And if TPCi is worried about losing players to the side games, just keep the highest prizes for the main format, and then have like an 80% prize pool for the secondary games.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Not to mention YGO's obnoxious number of video games preserving about the first decade of the game across various time capsules, albeit you are mostly stuck dueling similar batches of themed opponents. It would be neat if the TCG had a bit more of that.

      How is YGO early-game formats compared to Pokemon and Magic?
      Pokemon TCG is mainly a collector's game anyway, so while Pokemon reprinted Base Set cards multiple times, they really didn't need to evoke the spirit of playing Gen 1.
      Magic's Alpha was such a clusterfrick that they'd rather not reference it. PTCG is the same way actually, it was not really fun to play.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        YGO began as the game of "pick the strongest generic cards", since normal monsters had no differentiating features beyond battle points and spells and traps were either pitiful or amazing because the good ones were super disruptive for no cost. Hence the jokes of going through the trouble of summoning Blue-Eyes only to lost it to a Trap Hole or that the first few sets produced the most banned cards. Obviously Konami had their work cut out for them of course, Kazuki Takahashi had not designed Duel Monsters as real collectable game.

        It's different because YGO's main game IS the tcg. Even the anime is about the tcg. The TCG is essentially a spinoff brand of the mainline pokemon -- the mainline being the games.

        Everything in the anime is for the handheld games, not for the tcg.

        I do agree with you, though. And I do wish there were more officially supported formats with the TCG, things like Gym Leader Challenge.

        Oh, absolutely, the actual playing of the game was always secondary. The YGO video games can act as either a supplement or a proxy for the real thing; for someone who does not play the real game at all or a real player that wants to playtest cards they may never physically own. For the Pokemon TCG that is basically a needless third step. The two Game Boy games seem like very happy accidents from the "license everything to everyone" phase of the franchise. But much the endless battles of the Stadium games, that doesn't mean some of us can't enjoy them anyway.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          People forget the Yu-Gi-Oh series didn't start off as a card battle series, it always comes off silly when people complain about early Yu-Gi-Oh when it became more card focused not following the rules of the card game, when there literally wasn't any rules for the card game yet

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            Yeah the "Battle City Rules" were introduced to merge the Manga rules with the TCG rules. Duel Monsters was literally a MTG parody invented after Takahashi got dragged to a local tournament by one of his friends. Kaiba is inspired by some real life douchebag player there who no-shit had Kaiba's briefcase full of cards. Even today YGO has some remnants of being a Magic parody made by a guy who saw Magic being played but didn't know the rules oor what was going on. "Defense Mode" being sideways came from him seeing people tapping their cards.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        If we are talking competitively, not very good, there were always otks and the game was mostly unbalanced, except for goat format which was the perfect storm of unbalanced cards all legal the same time.
        The ygo video games however? (namely the psp ones) Are really good at keeping the game simple and engaging, the most balanced and beloved retro format is called Edison from 2010.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        YGO began as the game of "pick the strongest generic cards", since normal monsters had no differentiating features beyond battle points and spells and traps were either pitiful or amazing because the good ones were super disruptive for no cost. Hence the jokes of going through the trouble of summoning Blue-Eyes only to lost it to a Trap Hole or that the first few sets produced the most banned cards. Obviously Konami had their work cut out for them of course, Kazuki Takahashi had not designed Duel Monsters as real collectable game.

        [...]
        Oh, absolutely, the actual playing of the game was always secondary. The YGO video games can act as either a supplement or a proxy for the real thing; for someone who does not play the real game at all or a real player that wants to playtest cards they may never physically own. For the Pokemon TCG that is basically a needless third step. The two Game Boy games seem like very happy accidents from the "license everything to everyone" phase of the franchise. But much the endless battles of the Stadium games, that doesn't mean some of us can't enjoy them anyway.

        There's some Youtube videos out there of people playing the very first Japanese set, it's the most moronicly unbalanced shit ever.
        >no summoning costs for anything
        >no monsters have any kind of effect beyond "can get buffed slightly by a type-specific magic card"
        >monster cards are clearly divided into three tiers where each tier is completely untouchable by anything from a lower tier. Tier 1 has two cards, tier 2 has 3, everything else are shitmons from tier 3
        >gameplay is literally just "hope you draw your strongest monsters fast, and hope you get one of the "kill monster directly" magic cards so you can get rid of your opponent's unbeatable walls

        It's moronic as frick and clearly intended more as a toy than anything serious.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Why didn't they make one of these for the GBA? Better graphics, the Ruby/Sapphire era.... I'd still play it to this day if it looked like the RSE games but using the TCG.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      You can find games for old formats, ex especially, on tcgone. I play base-fossil and ex there pretty frequently

  4. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    >he thinks collectors would ever risk damaging their precious cards through play
    ahahahah

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Read the op
      >proxy

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      They are not that expensive and you're not going to use mint cards. I made a couple base set decks and it was fun to play.

  5. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Base set was so solved that magazines like Beckett were printing Haymaker and Rain Dance decklists and essentially saying "This is how you win at this game"

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      I remember Pojo plugging (Do the Wave) Wigglytuff and (Beat Up) Sneseal hard during... must have been Neo Genesis. Were they things?

      >mfw Pojo still exists

      Their Japanese walkthrough of Gold/Silver mistaking Red of Ash is still up, stumbled on it last month and had the best kind of spook.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        I played Do the Wave back in the day
        It was good, but critically undercut by Wigglytuff's fighting weakness, which meant Hitmonchan (and therefore Haymakers) ate it alive

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        Do the wave is one of the best decks in base-fossil, mewtwo and mew shore up the hitmonchan weakness while wiggly dunks on enemy psychics, and Sneasel is extremely strong in the neo formats

  6. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Google lackey tcg

  7. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    >mfw Pojo still exists

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      >having one of their magazines and using it to build decks in the Gameboy TCG because didn't have many cards nor anyone to play with
      Good times

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Pojo is STILL posting daily Pokemon card reviews
      https://www.pojo.com/charizard-ex-obsidian/

      Wonder how many readers these have on average?

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        172 on this one, lmao. Site's dead.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          Is the review even a good one, or is it just some moron writing wrong shit at a wall?

  8. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    There's a Premium hard box Base Set collector's item in December.

    It's like a weird mix of the OG decks Brushfire (Charizard), Blackout (Blastoise) and Overgrowth (Venusaur).

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Nobody is going to play these. Even if you somehow managed to get a copy, it's extremely wasteful to actually sleeve them and play.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      That's barely a Base Set box. It's a bizarre mix of every gen in the game. Plus it's $275 for three decks, who the frick is paying that?

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      It looked at first like it was just Base Set but then they showed off stuff like Rocket's Admin and Vs. Seeker, which just proves that they know HOW to make a good format, they've just refused to for 4 years now.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      you also forgot to mention the set is $300 fricking dollars

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      I really want that, don't care about the price, but I'm kinda annoyed there's a bunch of gold and silver cards in it. I don't have a problem with the newer cards, but I actually just want a set of original base cards.

  9. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Read Jason Klaczynski's blog if you want a good introduction into the retro eras.

    Base-Jungle is okay for the most part. Games can get a little grindy thanks to the energy removal cards and shit like Lickitung, Chansey, Mr Mime, Electabuzz, etc. Expect a lot of your turns to be attach an energy, maybe play energy removal, attack for 10 + status or pass, and hope for a good top deck next turn.

    Rocket set fricked everything up with cards like Imposter Oak's Revenge and Rocket's Sneak Attack. Going first and playing those cards allowed you to frick up your opponent's hand before their turn even begins. Combine that with Dark Vileplume to cuck your opponent out of trainer cards for the entire game.

    Base-Gym is basically the same but now you have Erika's Jigglypuff winning on turn 1 with the right conditions.

    Rocket-Neo is a little more fun. Evolution decks are better now thanks to Cleffa being the perfect early game setup mon. It's a little more luck based because of the babies and focus band forcing you into a lot of coin flips, but you have a lot more variety in decks now. Just make sure to play with Sneasel banned and the Slowking errata and you should have a good time.

    Skip Expedition era, it's just three sets and overall forgettable.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Sounds like none of these is fun then. Base Set - Jungle - Fossil is a stallfest, and the follow-up sets frick it up even more.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        It's either the stalliest game you've ever played or over in a couple turns, never inbetween

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Thnxs for posting. Finally I dont have to watch a 30 minute fricking video w/ a monotone voice

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Oh was Dark Vileplume actually good? I had the misprint weakness card back in the day, was very fond of it.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        Yeah, it was. It saw a lot of play all the way to the Neo era. Best combos were with Snorlax in Base-Gym, and with Smeargle and Murkrow in Base-Neo and Rocket-Neo.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Playing E-card only (Expedition-Skyridge) is a neat little format worth tinkering with once or twice

  10. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Did anyone else use to go to toys r us on the weekend and play the tcg. Fun times

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      gay

  11. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    There have printed an Evolutions set with was basically "Base Set remastered" with many cards slightly changed, but it did not have enough cards to run actual games on. But this is where I started playing, I just had to quickly use cards from other sets to fill the gaps.

    Nowadays I just play custom cards from Base Set.

  12. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Just play the GB game. It's fun and you don't have to worry about the "meta" at all.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Sucks the sequel never got an official translation, nor did they make other TCG adventure games

  13. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Just imagine what the Pokemon TCG could have been if Wizards of the Coast didn't sabotage it in order to funnel new TCG players into Magic.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      I can't believe it took till almost BW era to get away from them

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        What? No, Wizards lost the license just before the original ex era (Ruby and Sapphire), that was when the game became really good and it stayed that way for years until Black and White simplified it to try and appeal more to a younger audience (and then it was simplified again in 2019 with Team Up and I'm genuinely not sure if the game can ever recover from that).

        There have printed an Evolutions set with was basically "Base Set remastered" with many cards slightly changed, but it did not have enough cards to run actual games on. But this is where I started playing, I just had to quickly use cards from other sets to fill the gaps.

        Nowadays I just play custom cards from Base Set.

        >for YEARS pretty much everybody hates Evolutions, it's a worthless set containing basically nothing of value nor anything playable that is constantly shoved into boxes and tins because it was overproduced, booster boxes went on deep discount at points.
        >cut to early 2020
        >Youtubers start opening old product and giving their epic reaction faces to it
        >Evolutions suddenly becomes the most valuable set of the last like 10 years because DUDE IT HAS CHARIZARD FROM KANTOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
        2020 ruined Pokémon TCG collecting.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          >Black and White simplified it to try and appeal more to a younger audience (and then it was simplified again in 2019 with Team Up and I'm genuinely not sure if the game can ever recover from that).
          It can, it would just require TPCi to have the balls to print multiple dog shit sets in a row to reduce the power creep.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          >for YEARS pretty much everybody hates Evolutions
          No, it was terminally online "investors" that hated Evolutions, because it was widely printed and stuck into every box. But Evolutions conceptually was an incredible idea. Massive amounts of people got into Pokemon TCG through Evolutions. It sold out, because it was incredibly fun to open. Charizard isn't even that expensive compared to some newer cards, I see the cheapest is going for ~40 euro? It's a perfect example of a set that was widely bought out by the actual audience, not "investors".

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            No, it wasn't bought by the actual audience, it "shelfwarmed" for shops WELL into the Sun and Moon era, it didn't get many people into the TCG either, at least not compared to other sets, I'm really not sure where you're getting that from (it also didn't sell out by the way, at least not on any significant scale).

            It was players and collectors that were sick of seeing that set shoved in to every single box, not "investors", it was the same as Steam Siege, terrible sets that contained almost nothing good taking up spots that could've went to actual solid sets like Guardians Rising, Burning Shadows or even earlier XY block sets.

            Furthermore, "Investors" for modern Pokémon at that point in time were basically irrelevant, it was only in 2020 that modern Pokémon card "investing" became a thing.
            As an example, the pre-release promo for Evolutions Charizard was going for about £25-40 in 2018, 2 years later in 2020 it was going for £400-600 ungraded.

            Your post is almost completely wrong.

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              >No, it wasn't bought by the actual audience, it "shelfwarmed" for shops WELL into the Sun and Moon era, it didn't get many people into the TCG either, at least not compared to other sets, I'm really not sure where you're getting that from (it also didn't sell out by the way, at least not on any significant scale).
              This is a classic case of "seeing what you want to believe". Yes, the people who were established players got tired of Evolutions and investroons didn't want to touch the product because it was printed so widely. But it kept selling at a steady pace, because regular customers - which aren't loudmouths on social media - found the product fun to open. It was exciting, it was nostalgic, it had something regular X&Y and S&M products didn't have, which was fun. No matter how fans of nu-Pokemon can delude themselves, opening a Charizard is fun.
              >it was only in 2020 that modern Pokémon card "investing" became a thing.
              Again, typical gay that only follows what Youtube says. Every single store is a part-time or full-time investor, they hold and trade product and they hold and trade singles. "Investing" in the Jake Paul sense did become popular when the market drastically self-corrected, because the Pokemon product was undervalued and PoGo brought a lot of new customers. These customers grabbed the packs that looked the most exciting to them - and that was Evolutions.

              So stop saying "everybody" when you mean "a couple of deluded people on the internet" and not actual customers.

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                Silence israelite

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      I can't believe it took till almost BW era to get away from them

      QRD?

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        They constantly fricked up translations like pic related (original card should read only works when active), to the point where you have to wonder if it was intentional to gimp the game. Even worse, they never fix the error with an errata and force people to play with it as worded. This shit was legal for two years before they decided to finally ban it.

        They removed the 15+ division at one point, with the intention clearly being for Pokemon to be the kid's game and MtG to be the game for adults.

  14. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    I wanna do a major hack of the gameboy tcg game(completely revamp each card's attacks, types, HP, energy costs, etc) as well as the computer teams.

    Besides nerfing or removing Professor Oak, Energy Removal and Gust of Wind, what do you think would help avoid the major pitfalls of the meta?
    Should evolution cards have greatly reduced energy costs? Or just be way more powerful? Should the single stage basics everyone abuses take longer to set up? Have less HP?...

    What would your overall game design philosophy be?

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      There's a few people that have already done it, you can look up this set for example:
      https://base-set-remastered.tumblr.com/set-display

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        yo this looks broken already

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          >rain dance with this
          I am cum destroyer of worlds

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            It's each type of basic energy, and Rain Dance only applies to water energy, so it would only be able to do 20 max.

            >these are stage 1 pokemon that need to evolve from a useless 10HP card
            wtf were they thinking?

            They're trash, just like in the games

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        some pretty bizarre choices here

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          I play it with my friend and it's pretty well thought-out, but it's definitely more it's own thing than a genuine "fix" of base set.

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            That's because there's no "fixing" Base Set.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        >got rid of Poison powder on ivy
        Frick off not reading anything more

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        This shit is even less balanced and even more of a stallfest

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          Why is it a stallfest? What enables stall in a format like Base Set?

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            Energy Removal and lack of recovery like Nightly Garbage Run

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              Also a lack of powerful attacks on evolutions

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              Also a lack of powerful attacks on evolutions

              That part I understand, but why was the other anon claiming it's "more of a stallfest", then? I don't see Energy Removal on this list.

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            [...]
            That part I understand, but why was the other anon claiming it's "more of a stallfest", then? I don't see Energy Removal on this list.

            Super energy removal has a lower cost and super potion is cheap too

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              I don't see a Super Energy Removal?

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                Look harder. Also they didn't do anything to fricking haymaker lol

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                I see "Super Energy Retrieval", but there's no "Super Energy Removal".

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        >gyarados is STILL grass weakness
        why

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        >many stage 2s are significantly weaker with the trade off of rare candy being busted shit
        Frick this gay ass format

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        Is there a place I can browse the real cards of base set in such an intuitive hi res manner?

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          pkmncards.com

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            thanks fren

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        I barely know anything about the TCG balance, but isn't this Supporter very good?

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          It is literally only a +1 but yeah it is still good since you get to pick what to pitch

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          In terms of modern formats I think it would be sometimes playable, but it's nowhere need something like Prof Research which is objectively the best supporter. Draw cards are all about how many new cards you get to see, 5 is on the low side.

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            >Professor's Research is just classic Professor Oak
            Some things never change

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              This post sums it up

              >modern Professor Oak is a supporter
              >modern energy removal and gust of wind require a coin flip to succeed, while guaranteed removal/gust cards are limited to supporters
              >Computer Search is now limited to 1 time use through Ace Spec or V-Star attacks, or luck based like Cram-o-matic
              It's actually nutty how broken the initial trainer cards were.

              You can put the Base Set trainers in any other format, except for maybe the Energy Removals since energy acceleration is easier in modern play, and they'd be just as broken.

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                Don't want to write a wall of text but putting all of these effects on Supporters didn't change how broken they are and often unfun to play against.
                Boss's Orders is still a shit card - sure, it's effect is worse with cancer triple-prizers, but it always reduces the endgame to "do they have a Boss or not". Custom Catcher was the only great thing about the (early) Tag Team format, because it made gusting a more involved process.
                Equally Crushing Hammer made SwSh a nightmare when an already braindead VMAX format was also dependent on random coin flips for Hammers.
                And Professor's Research is simply too strong to beat, seeing 7 new cards is extremely good and it encourages milling through your deck for fast set-up - another reason why SuMo with Cynthia only was so good.

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                Energy removal would be just as broken if not more so

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            >objectively best supporter
            Bosses order crosses your path

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      The best thing you could do is hack in supporter rules. Or replace Oak with Elm. You need a big draw card like this or the game simply won’t work.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Evolutions need both more HP on average and lower energy costs(or more damage for their energy). This will naturally balance things for the basics.

      Here’s a simple example—give Machamp like 120 HP, and increase the power of Seismic Toss to 70. 100 should be the bare minimum for stage 2 Pokémon. 70 for Stage 1. But never break the 120 HP limit. Machamp needs more help than this, but it’s a start.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      remove/nerf the attacks from the basics that deal big numbers.
      frick special punch
      frick thunder punch
      frick psyburn
      frick slash

      wanna cause a lot of damage? then you must evolve

      and scrap do the wave, frick that shit

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        [...]
        seconding this. why evolve pokemon when you have basics with this level of damage output

        Would this change anything(or everything)?

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          There is no issue with these cards, they suck big time lategame when the opponent starts having stage 2 evos around.
          The issue is, and has always been, trainer card spam.

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            Yeah I'm sick with the glorification of the big 4 haymaker attackers.
            Truth to be told only Scyther is actually great because nothing resists grass in gen 1 TGC and it can power-up its first Slash with Swords Dance, plus no retreat cost and resists fighting on its own.
            Fire weakness only really matters against Fossil Magmar since fire is a kinda shit type otherwise.
            The other 3 are easily countered by even 30 HP stage 1 shit like Rattata and Diglett because their types do have resistances.
            Water was the overall bet type because nothing resisted it, it almost always had completely drawback-free attacks and Rain Dance Blastoise showed us what happens when you don't place a restriction on a type of card (trainer cards being spammable was moronic).

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              Monchan is obscene and can instantly steal games. But yeah those two are silly

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              This is one of the most idiotic posts I've read in a long time

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            You are exactly right, Haymaker wasn't good because the featured Pokemon were overpowered, it was good because everything else was useless in the face of Trainer spam with Energy Removal, Lass and other random bullshit.
            The more you consider how many broken cards there are in the format, the more you realize you cannot just move a few numbers around and make it balanced. The game is broken at its core.

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              A standard Haymaker deck has about 10 mons, 15 energies and 45 trainer cards that can potentially be spammed in a single turn.
              You can only play an energy card per turn unless you run Rain Dance, and none of the basics is truly overwhelming, so trainer cards are clearly the issue.
              Either limit them to one per type or one per turn, maybe even both.

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                >10 mons, 15 energies and 45 trainer cards
                that's 70 cards anon

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          I don't think this would lead people to want to use evolution cards, just other powerful basics like lapras, magmar...

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          I hope that "Special Punch" is at least 3 coins because if it's 2 it's gonna deal an average of 20 damage so Jab is unironically a better sure way to attack.

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            Alternatively is it is 3 coins you are averaging 30 damage and can occasionally one shot the fat normal types

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        30-40 is big damage now? Evolutions can do 60-80, and if it does around 30-50 usually it has some nice additional effect.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          >30-40 is big damage now?
          yes it fricking is, when you can access it that fricking fast without needing to evolve

          There is no issue with these cards, they suck big time lategame when the opponent starts having stage 2 evos around.
          The issue is, and has always been, trainer card spam.

          >when the opponent starts having stage 2 evos around.
          so never? how clueless about the game are you? literally the only stage 2 pokemon that's useful is blastoise and you jump to it with pokemon breeder

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          Yes, because they require less setup and are less vulnerable to the ever present energy removal. 40 2kos most meta threats and 30 can 2ko all the 70s that make up the meta with a plus power

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      remove/nerf the attacks from the basics that deal big numbers.
      frick special punch
      frick thunder punch
      frick psyburn
      frick slash

      wanna cause a lot of damage? then you must evolve

      and scrap do the wave, frick that shit

      seconding this. why evolve pokemon when you have basics with this level of damage output

  15. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Be Gyarados
    >Be flying type in addition to water meaning it doubles your electric weakness and cancels your weakness to grass
    >The tcg homosexuals decide to make you weak to grass for no reason even though most water pokemon(magikarp included!) are weak to electric
    WHY

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      No player uses Garydos even back in the day.

      Magikarp gets rekt easily by Gust of Wind and Lapras is much easier to use.

      Those chuds running Rain Dance decks have Pokemon Breeder so they don't need to bring Wartortles.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        >No player uses Garydos even back in the day.
        I did, for precisely that reason
        Pre-Articuno, Rain Dance basically required it for Electabuzz

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      >gyarados is STILL grass weakness
      why

      Grass Weakness makes it a tech in Water Decks to counter Electabuzz who steamrolls them otherwise

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        But it just doesn't make any sense. I get that it's a semi-abstract card game and there's wiggle room to bend concepts but you're not gonna be like "well let's give farfetch'd flamethrower, make it weak to psychic and resist water because it would work really well for strategy X to counter Y"

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          Can't really defend it, but I think the real frickup was the decision to not have the Blastoise line be weak to Grass to play on the Rock-Paper-Scissors thing the starters had. If they had done that then Gyarados might have been given a more appropriate weakness like in the games.

          [...]
          seconding this. why evolve pokemon when you have basics with this level of damage output

          Diamond/Pearl years were the closest to getting this right by the Weakness/Resistance overhaul: basics took +10, Stage 1 +20 and Stage 2 +30. Big Basics, SPs and Rulebox Pokemon (Lv. X) took the original x2 Damage. Then HGSS and later BW noped out of all that when it did the hard reset of all the Turn rules and brought back x2 for everyone.

  16. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    >these are stage 1 pokemon that need to evolve from a useless 10HP card
    wtf were they thinking?

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Here's what annoys me the most to this day

      >Basic
      >Stage I
      >Stage II
      and not
      >Stage I
      >Stage II
      >Stage III

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        are you literally unable to read?
        >omastar
        >evolves from stage 2
        >"evolves from omanyte put omastar on the stage 1 card"

        it literally IS exactly what you typed
        charizard blastoise venusaur = stage 3

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          >zoomer doesn't remember the fossils all being evolutions of Mysterious Fossil

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          Good bait.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      The few characters in the video game that use fossil Pokémon also use powerful basic Pokémon like Scyther and Clefairy Dolls

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Here's the pokemon you had to evolve twice bro, wasn't it worth all the effort?

      it's like they designed them as basics then later thought out about introducing the moronic fossil mechanic and didn't bother to balance them accordingly just left them as they were

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Because Aerodactyl would have been OP as frick if it was a basic mon.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        Why are you people so incredibly moronic?
        >Our arbitrary made up card is too OP, how should we fix this? Why by making a ridiculously contrived system to prevent this of course, it's not like Aerodactyl's attributes are completely arbitrary and could have been altered so they aren't OP

        But even if we go along with the moronic mysterious fossil idea, if Omanyte and Kabuto are stage 1 pokemon then naturally they should have been way more powerful to make up for this.
        You're trying to justify the designer's stupidity with your own

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          There are only 3 fossil evolution lines in Gen 1 and it's not like they had a crystal orb that told them more would have been introduced in Gen 3, hell Pokemon was supposed to end with Gen 2.
          Not everything needs to be good. 2 shitmon lines in exchange for balancing an otherwise OP card is a good compromise.

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            There's no reason Omanyte and Kabuto couldn't have been made stronger
            There's no reason that if the fossil gimmick was dropped Aerodactyl couldn't have been a totally different card

            I can confidently declare you a moron

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              They wanted to introduce an evolution lock mechanic and thematically it makes sense to give it to Aerodactyl, but as a basic pokemon it would have been easily the strongest card in the game so making it an evolution was necessary.
              Kabutops and Omastar would have been shitmons regardless, much like Cloyster, Porygon and the other BJF shitmons. Not all 151 mons needed to be viable.
              This obsession with balance is what has ruined gaming in the last 2 decades, just let it go.

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                Kabutops is officially the oldest pokemon so if they were so hellbent on the evo lock mechanic they could have given it to it...

                Also Aerodactyl doesnt even come from a fossil in the mainline so they could have done the old amber instead of the fossil and it would be limited to Aerodactyl so the others could have been kept as basics...

                If Muk's toxic gas is thematically sufficient to stop pokepowers why can't Weezing toxic gas be thematically sufficient to stop evolutions...

                Maybe Parasects spores can prevent pokemon from growing...

                ... Essentially there's a million ways they could have gone about it, to act like the mysterious fossil mechanic or Omanyte/Kabuto being laughably terrible was fundamental is ridiculous. And yes not every pokemon will be part of the competitive meta and no designer can truly predict all the ins and out of it but to create such an obvious disparity is straight up bad design, to dismiss this glaring flaw with "they would have been shit anyway" it's pathetic

  17. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Here's the pokemon you had to evolve twice bro, wasn't it worth all the effort?

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      >Lapras from the same set has 10 more HP and only does 10 less max damage on Water Gun
      it's like there was zero attempt to even balance these cards

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Over the years, I've sat down and designed a deck that at least attempts to make use of every single card from Base through Fossil
      I've never once even considered Omastar

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      you know that pokemon notorious for having THE highest defense of all gen 1 pokemon? let's give it 50HP!

      My theory is that they made a lot of the more abundant water/grass/fighting/normal pokemon deliberately trash so those types don't have an advantage, while most of the limited fire/electric/psychic pokemon were in their mind viable. This way all types would have a similar amount of options since the apparent larger choice in the common types would be disregarded by default in serious play.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Man what was up with the fossils. Was there ever a genuinely good reason to go to the trouble of including Mysterious Fossil in your deck.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        just aerodactyl to stop blastoise/wigglytuff

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        Outside of Aerodactyl some infinite loop involving it, Donphan and a Japan Only Omanyte card which led to Omanyte being restricted on Japan's HoF list

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        >not playing unlimited
        >not having a deck of only fossils and dolls
        >not demoralizing your opponent by literally milling them to death
        its my favorite deck of all time
        no one will face it twice
        but over the years enough "fossil" cards have come out to build an entire stall deck around them

        pure kino
        all items;;
        then use 1-2 of the celebi that flip a coin instead of being knocked out they go back in the deck kek

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          Literally just auto win or loss based on if they have attacks that hit bench. Yeah real fun. Also expanded is only HGSS later. I am doubtful there is 12+ fossils anyways

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      >2 for 60
      I'm not a lucklet, so this is pretty kino tbh

  18. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    you know that pokemon notorious for having THE highest defense of all gen 1 pokemon? let's give it 50HP!

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      I don't know if they managed to get feedback from Base Set before printing the expansions, but some of the cards in these sets are so gimped compared to Base Set that it baffles me

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Feels like an early attempt at a Dark pokemon tbh, slightly op attacks but trash hp

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        The attacks are terrible because none guarantees damage. Also average 30 damage is barely better than Rattata.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          It's definitely very RNG heavy, but it's low risk, high reward
          Would be great in a poor man's-style deck if it's hp wasn't such trash

  19. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    >modern Professor Oak is a supporter
    >modern energy removal and gust of wind require a coin flip to succeed, while guaranteed removal/gust cards are limited to supporters
    >Computer Search is now limited to 1 time use through Ace Spec or V-Star attacks, or luck based like Cram-o-matic
    It's actually nutty how broken the initial trainer cards were.

  20. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Started the game boy recently

    Is he any good? I don't really see him mentioned any where

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      NPC decks are horribly inconsistent and rarely get out a single evolution before the game is over. Maybe if you find people to play with it can see some use, but chances are people you play with are going to play meta. 60HP + Grass weakness makes it an easy target for Scyther, which nearly every deck will run.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Very situational
      Destroys Rain Dance
      Absolutely useless against a Haymaker
      For the GB game, he'll probably cripple you more than help unless you very intentionally build a deck of strong basics like a Haymaker

  21. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    been running Gengar and Dragonair in the tcg GB game. It's a big investment to get a dragonair lead and gengar in the bench, but with 2 double colorless energy, I can just ensure the opponent has no energies to use on top of moving damage counters wherever I want. What can I do to make it more consistent?

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      4 Oak
      4 Bill
      3-4 Breeder
      2 Computer Search
      2 Item Finder

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Not sure what your end game is with that combo
      Both are decent cards, but don't seem to fit together in any logical way?

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        Active pokemon can't touch Dragonair because they don't have energy, and I can string them along forever while Gengar moves their damage counters to knock out benched pokemon through Curse.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          >2-3 Lickitung
          Primary attacker to stall with until you get everything else setup
          >2 Chansey
          Another sponge
          >1-2 Scyther
          Free retreater that you can occasionally attack with
          >1-2 Mewtwo, Energy Conversion Gastly
          Mewtwo can be a backup attacker, and both Mewtwo (using Fuji) and Gastly can recycle your DCE from the discard. Gastly also doubles as a free retreater if needed.
          >max on both energy removals
          obvious
          >run the same number of breeder as you have Gengar
          also obvious, but consider leaving at least 1 Gastly unevolved to access Energy Conversion
          >3 Oak, skip on Bill
          You're already pressed for deck space because of Gengar and Dragonair, so just run Oak as your primary draw
          >2 Scoop Up, 1-2 Fuji
          Scoop Up to clean your Lickitung off the board, Fuji to do the same but also recycle your DCE

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          >run the same number of breeder as you have Gengar
          I disagree. Most times I'd say sure, but Haunter is such a good stall
          Also, Bill > Oak

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            If you're worried about consistency but don't want to run Oak>Bill, there's your problem. Bill is too few cards drawn to grab what you need. If you're worried about discarding with Oak, remember you have access to Item Finder, Energy Retrieval, EC Gastly, Mewtwo, and Fuji to recycle most of what you need. The reason why I wouldn't run both Oak and Bill is because you're already pressed for deck space. If you can find the space for it then by all means run it.

            As cool as Haunter's power is, still run a 3-1-3 or 2-1-2 line with 3, 2, or even just 1 breeder. You'll be able to get out Gengar more consistently and the deck really doesn't need another staller if you add Licki and Chansey. Gastly actually has the same stall potential as Haunter with Lick and the same HP.

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              I'd run Haunter over Chansey (or Licki, matter of preference I guess) because the normal-types will get eaten alive by someone like Hitmonchan, whereas Haunter counters them well.
              Banking solely on Oak leads to getting decked if you're not playing a deck built around winning fast, which this doesn't seem like this is.
              He wants his opponents sitting there energyless while they die a slow death. That takes a few too many turns to just draw your whole deck like that

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                >Hitmonchan
                I suggested Mewtwo and Scyther, and Gastly has the same HP as Haunter and can hit them for 20 damage off 1 with a 50% chance for para with the added benefit of recycling energy. Haunter adds nothing that Gastly doesn't already do outside of being 1 step closer to Gengar. It should only be run because you're not always guaranteed to get Breeder (or Computer or Item Finder to fetch it) and Gengar in the same hand. Otherwise it's better to leave it as Gastly for the utility or immediately skip to Gengar.

                A deck like that also needs Oak because an evolution deck is going to be slow by design, so any additional speed is a bonus. Solely Bill isn't enough to setup your board fast enough. Once you reach the mid and endgame, you stop playing Oak unless you desperately need to dig for that one resource, and instead start relying on Computer, Item Finder, EC Gastly / Mewtwo + Fuji to grab/recycle resources.

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                Scyther is good but you only get so many double colorless and I suspect he'd want to save them for Dragonair
                Mewtwo I've always found kind of overrated. Having to spend a turn as the active pokemon just powering up is such a huge waste

                > Haunter adds nothing that Gastly doesn't already do
                Haunter takes that 50% of not being hit and ups it to 75% with sleep

                >A deck like that also needs Oak because an evolution deck is going to be slow by design, so any additional speed is a bonus
                You might be right here.

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                >defining pokemon of the format is overrated
                You are extremely wrong, but your fixation with a thick haunter line tells me as much. I love playing with off meta cards too but show mewtwo some respect, aside from the explosive setup potential at the cost of an attack, it also recycles resources or can be set up manually, it's an extremely versatile card and bent the meta around it on release for a reason.

  22. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Is it autistic of me to think Pokemon Breeder is a bogus card because there's nothing specifically connecting the basic and stage 2 pokemon in game?

    Like there is nothing in the Blastoise card or the Squirtle card connecting the two. Evolution cards only tell you the pokemon they evolve from. Blastoise states it evolves from Wartortle and nothing more so essentially this mechanic relies on the player general pokemon knowledge as the player might not even have a Wartortle card that states it evolves from Squirtle.

    Know what I mean?

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      >Is it autistic of me
      yes

      but I do see your point

  23. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    yes. the base–neo format is still quite popular in japan with the hall of fame rules.

  24. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    remember to thank Cleffa for saving your shit format

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Yeah, and then

      They constantly fricked up translations like pic related (original card should read only works when active), to the point where you have to wonder if it was intentional to gimp the game. Even worse, they never fix the error with an errata and force people to play with it as worded. This shit was legal for two years before they decided to finally ban it.

      They removed the 15+ division at one point, with the intention clearly being for Pokemon to be the kid's game and MtG to be the game for adults.

      in the same set ruined it.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      >"save"
      >it's just another card that's mandatory in every deck
      The bar is in hell.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        It helps smooth out/normalize games which is nice, better than other staples that mostly serve to make things swingier imo. It's definitely a less egregious staple than others in the same format (though the baby rule is definitely obnoxious as frick)

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Peak attack name

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        and it just gets better

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        and it just gets better

        and then it gets worse because TPCi didn't get the joke and put too many e's

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          What? The Neo Genesis and HGSS cards both have seven E's in the attack name.

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            The e's represent how many cards you draw, or at least that is what it seems like when you look at the initial two that were translated by WotC.

            remember to thank Cleffa for saving your shit format

            Neo Genesis "Eeeeeeek" has 7 e's, draws you 7 cards.

            and it just gets better

            Promo "Eek" has 2 e's, draws you 2 cards.

            [...]
            and then it gets worse because TPCi didn't get the joke and put too many e's

            HGSS Cleffa was nerfed from drawing 7 cards to 6, so its "Eeeeeeek" should have 6 e's accordingly. It doesn't.

            I kind of forgot the Cleffa from the DPPt and ex blocks are also guilty of this frick up. DP Cleffa is a new spelling "Eeek" with 3 e's, but only draws you a single card.

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              Huh, I never noticed that.

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              Couldn't really name it 'Ek'

  25. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Cleffa is so cute

  26. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Gen 2(Gen poo) was a mistake

  27. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    holy soulerino

  28. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Whenver I see a picture of the cards I can fricking smell them. It even happens playing the GB game.

  29. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Yes, and I do have poxys printed to play with friends. Each player can only have 1 of each trainer card in their deck and we limit the amount of pokemon to 1 basic if it doesn't evolve, 2 basics if it evolves once, and 3 basics if it evolves twice. So you will only have 1 card like Hitmonchan in your fighting deck but you could have 3 Machops, 2 Machokes, and 1 Machamp. Makes for more fun games, highly recommend. Base rules suck.

  30. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    >modern cards still have a resistance of just -30 despite the massive HP and damage outputs
    Credit at least to the older formats for resistance actually being relevant. Now it's just a number that's there and does nothing. I guess they didn't want to scale it with the power creep since it would mean cards should have -100 or more resistance.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      You would be surprised how much -30 can swing games. It is not a massive wall like base set but having it can avoid the OHKO which swings the game massively back in your favor

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Jesus isn't it a fricking mess having to manage damage counters for such large numbers?

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        Most people aren't mentally challenged like yourself, so no, it's not an issue.

  31. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Okay so people keep saying the original format is fundamentally broken so what would it take to unbroke it? What was it the made the game improve?
    What cards need to be removed or reworked? What cards need to be introduced?

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      1.) Supporter rule
      2.) Wiping gust of wind and energy removal off the face of the earth

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Don't really listen to

      1.) Supporter rule
      2.) Wiping gust of wind and energy removal off the face of the earth

      It's not really easy to "fix" original formats without killing what is interesting in them. It's kinda like other card games in their early formats - most creatures (in this case Pokemon) are just various taste of unga-bunga beater while spells (in this case support cards) are extremely powerful, and it's not just GoW, Energy Removal or whatever this gay lost too many games to.
      Pic related can literally win you game turn one against certain opponents. It especially kills any strats based on 3rd stage Pokemon because Pokemon Breeder is such a vital card for them.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        Those are easily the biggest problems, you sound like you're coping. Also what a petty thing to disagree over; it wasn't a comprehensive list. There's a shitton of reasons why the PTCG is shallow.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          It's shallow because there's like 7 good, playable Pokemon that don't demand from you to play extra cards just to make them work + Entire "Power" is in support cards. It's just how the game was made.

          Still, if we go with Base-Gym it has some spice to it. Blastoise + Misty's Poliwhirl is fun to play even if you need to frick around with Stage 3 and Stage 2 mons.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      more forced luck/randomness

      unironically

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Being a broken, sloppy mess is the entire appeal of playing base set. Formats like ex and DP exist if you want to play a retro format with a semblance of balance.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      The biggest problem is that most pokemon, especially evolutions, are completely unplayable so the first step would be nerfing the OP pokemon and give evolutions cards some major boosts.
      The other major problem is trainer abuse so lessening their effects or even imposing limits to how many trainer cards you can put in a deck.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        Wizards tried to limit Trainers with Prop 15/3, but dropped it after only a day. Basically it was Base-Gym and imposed a limit of 3 copies of a Trainer and 15 overall Trainers in a deck.

        https://jklaczpokemon.com/prop-15-3/

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        Issue - how do you even start weakining stuff like this? And yes, this is one of centerpieces of Haymaker, de fact THE DECK of Base/Base-Gym.

        These Pokemon are not strong because of OMFG SO BROKEN EFFECTS, but because they can come onto field quickly and start hitting for 20 when opponent is still setting up. Slap on it DAMN PLUS POWER and you OHKO opponent's little guys before they can evolve them.

        There's nothing really to "nerf" besides literally rewriting entire rules.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          There is no cost to playing this card, that's the problem. And while I like the energy system, it's really limiting in cases like these, because just adding more energy cost would make it lopsided.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          >make Jab do 10
          >make Special Punch do 30
          >change the HP to 60
          wow, that was so difficult

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            Now it gets to be a slightly better Growlithe with no potential, fun.

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              If that means giving Growlithe and dozens of other pokemon a chance of being worthwhile pokemon then yeah, fun!

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                Are you actually moronic? The goal is for there to be NO shit cards. Why even have Hitmonchan in at all, then?

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                >The goal is for there to be NO shit cards.

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                Lol. I remember when Tamashii revealed her boyfriend, ppl in the comment section was roasting him. A bunch of comments wondering how he end up with her.

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                It's a balancing act. If you're making many other pokemon viable that's a step in the right direction. Then as you realize Hitmonchan is 100% obsolete you try to find subtle ways to boost it as so that he could potentially be useful in certain situations without overdoing it.

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                I understand the process, but unfortunately all you've really done is make everything less fun to use. The real aims should be:
                1.) Make everything able to compete with Hitmonchan
                2.) Introduce proper non-battle roles to make cards usable and good
                3.) Put a heavy emphasis on Pokémon Powers (this game's best mechanic)
                Hitmonchan is broken, yes, but it's also VERY fun to use. Everything else should be made just as fun as it to use. 10 damage per turn is not fun.

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            >Nerfing isn't the answer
            moron

            Gee idk if the problem is they make too much damage too fast maybe just maybe you should make them do less damage/up the energy costs.

            >The goal is for there to be NO shit cards.

            > Person asks how to repair OG Pokemon TCG
            > People tell them why it's not really possible and how game is shallow
            > GEEE LETS JUST ADD MORE CARDS TO THE PILE OF TOILET PAPER AND LESS TO ACTUALLY PLAYABLE SHIT.

            Anyway, the only reasons to even play old Pokemon TCG formats is nostalgia, novelty or if you're one of the handful of ppl that just like this kind of game. All of them make any balancing moot.

            You are moronic, there's no way to nerf or balance out that one.

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              It's kind of astounding just how obtuse you're being.

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                It's autism, you think one way and one way only making you oblivious to other the possibilities

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            You can't make a star-rarity card that weak.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          There is no cost to playing this card, that's the problem. And while I like the energy system, it's really limiting in cases like these, because just adding more energy cost would make it lopsided.

          Also should add--
          Nerfing isn't the answer, it's bringing everything else up to par. Or at least trying to, as much as you can within the confines of this game.

          >make Jab do 10
          >make Special Punch do 30
          >change the HP to 60
          wow, that was so difficult

          Wow, now it's meh. Good job.

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            >Nerfing isn't the answer
            moron

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              It's not. I'm sorry you're mentally incompetent, but this game is just far too lopsided towards a Pokémon like Hitmonchan by default. Hitmonchan should be the gold standard for cards, as in, everything else should be designed around the same benchmark with increased or decreased values based on cost/risk to use. Because if you just nerf things, you're just putting good cards on the shitty cards' level. That doesn't make them all good or fun to use-- that makes them all bad and lame to use. This sort of laziness you're exhibiting is exactly why this game was so poorly thought out.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          Gee idk if the problem is they make too much damage too fast maybe just maybe you should make them do less damage/up the energy costs.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          New rule, all basic Pokémon THAT CAN EVOLVE will, after a flip of a coin, take half damage from attacks that turn if that flip is in their favor, however it be, rounded up to the nearest multiple of 10 if it isnt already a multiple of 10. This rule is not in effect if the targeted mon is a baby mon, because they already have a damage neutering flip.
          There, fixed the problem of shit killing runs before they begin, without directly nerving stronger basic mons.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      The game would be objectively better by just shamelessly copying the DCG as much as possible without encroaching on the Pokémon concept.
      The Pokémon Card Game is awful dogshit because the game's idea of balancing is to expand ever upwards, rather than horizontally like the DCG.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Limit trainer cards to one use per turn.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Remove or nerf most trainer cards and give pokemon plenty of attacks that have trainer-like effects. lots of drawing cards, searching for cards, remove energy from opponent, switch opponent pokemon...

  32. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    https://tcgone.net/ occassionally you can find ppl playing old metas here. Just don't tell TPCi.

  33. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    I really want to like this game but I'm such a brainlet. Or perhaps a lazy brainlet.

  34. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Idk why people have so many issuss with Hitmonchan in BJF. Fighting is the most resisted type, even a Pidgey counters it.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Hitmonchan lives off the reputation from the early days of the game and Haymaker being the only thing people know about Base era. It was really only the best mon for one set until Scyther and Mewtwo came along, both of which mog it.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      moron

      This post is giving "bro Charizard is easily the most OP card in game it causes 100.damage"

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        Charizard is good lategame with Venusaur. Hitmonchan is shit past turn 3.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          Funny

  35. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Gen 1 format can be fun but it is pretty limited and solved at this point
    Gen 3 was when the TCG actually peaked but many people don't know that
    There is a romhack for PTCG that adds gen 2 cards which is very impressive in itself https://www.pokecommunity.com/showthread.php?t=489886
    I feel like if they had just made a single PTCG game on the GBA we'd have so many more hacks like this
    It's kinda sad that there is still really no good platform for playing older PTCG formats

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      >romhack with neo/expedition era cards
      based
      >card and balance changes
      cringe

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        I've played the hack and think some of the changes suck, but this mentality of "the original designers can do no wrong" is shit. Frick off.

  36. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    It's frustrating, I can't really seem to grasp Pokemon TCG everytime I try to pick it up I just give up due to not having "direction" i can't really comprehend on whether to place energies on bench mons or active and even stuff like whats the point of even using weak cards like bibarel idk

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      People will say "PTCG is one of the simplest card games around", but not realize it's also one of the most un-intuitive card games unless you netdeck since day 1.
      You'd think it's a game about Pokemon, but it's actually a game about Trainer card engines and the Pokemon are simply those that can abuse them.

  37. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    I heard people discovered way after that stall is stronger than haymaker in Base Set, is it true?

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Yes

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Yep, say hello to the real king of Base-Fossil

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        >hitmonchan food

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          Obviously you wouldn't just use Lickitung, you'd pair it with things like Scyther, Mewtwo, Mr. Mime

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            >Gusts your "king" and one shots it
            What now? Hitmonchan is was and continues go be the true king. Mr. Mime is a contender though

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              Even with Special Punch, chan has to use a Pluspower to one shot Lickitung, which means more cards wasted in the Haymaker deck to get that Pluspower and, if not used, another turn for the stall deck to do whatever they want
              And that's assuming they're just gonna let you set up 3 energies on Hitmonchan

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                Card advantage hardly matters in base set. Prize trading or denying prize trading is far far more important

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                The point is that Lickitung's power isn't beating matchups 1v1, it'll only ever do 10 damage at a time, the point is even against its most threatening opponent, Hitmonchan, it's still a fat frick who can sit on the field for a few turns which is all it wants to do, waste time and let the opponent burn their own deck with Oaks and Bills
                It's not impenetrable, but it's really annoying to fight against

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                I don't disagree at all merely with the presentation of calling it "king". Hitmonchan is the king. Lickitung is top 10 at least though

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                Digging against the stall deck very much matters, hitmonchan can snag a prize on licki with gust+pp+special punch but it's not taking all 6 prizes from the rest of the mons on stall, hitmonchan is good but there's a reason it was the first thing to go as the meta developed. Ironically, it's that shift that brought a niche back for it in bludgeoning decks that get too greedy with normals but it's still not invalidating lickitung stall

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                To add to this anon, basically every Licki deck plays max Scoop Ups, (Super) Energy Removals, Item Finders, and at least 1 Fuji. There's a ton of options to deny that Special Punch OHKO, plus the rest of the deck is comprised of mons that shit on Hitmonchan. If your Licki gets hit by a Plus Power Special Punch for the OHKO, you fricked up somewhere.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          oh no, anyways

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            >only other Mon on my bench is free retreat my homie scyther
            Good luck and better hope you flip heads lmao

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Yeah, stall is extremely annoying

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      If stall gets off the ground haymaker physically cannot win. As in it is actually impossible. It isn't that hard to get off either

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Every degenerate format has some form of stall, but back in the day people really didn't pay attention to stall tactics that much.
      Haymaker is, at best, a Tier 2 deck. There are just too many ways to completely stop the game.

  38. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    I enjoyed that game and its sequel.

    I wish 3rd one existed for NEO, and a 4th for E-card.

  39. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    >you can't play Base Set seriously, it's broken
    >but you cannot balance Base Set with numbers, it's broken
    >but if you try to change Base Set fundamentally, then it's no longer Base Set
    you frickers just don't want to have fun

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      >You can play Base Set and it's an interesting format, it's just not balanced. Fun and balance are separate concepts.
      >You can change the balance of Gen 1 cards while keeping the spirit of Base Set craziness, but you cannot make it "balanced" by just changing some numbers.
      >If you change the rules of Gen 1 TCG (like adding Supporters), it's a viable way to have a "nostalgic time" but it won't really be like playing Base Set.
      There, fixed.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      The fun of playing base is for nostalgia and how stupidly unbalanced it is. The only way you "balance" it is with widespread changes and moron shit like

      There's a few people that have already done it, you can look up this set for example:
      https://base-set-remastered.tumblr.com/set-display

      which completely defeats the point of even playing base.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        >and
        There are plenty of people who want to play Base Set for nostalgia, buy are discouraged after learning/seeing all the broken shit going on. Your experiences aren't universal.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        The amount of people of people who owned base set cards and played with them correctly is below 1%. Let alone zoomers who only know them from youtube videos. If they ask "how does base set play" and you respond "like garbage", that's the extent of interest they'll have in it.

  40. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Base set is for people who don't like most of the post-151 "pokémon"(me). Would I like it to be more balanced? 100%

    I didn't grow up with it so I have have no nostalgic attachment to it, I just don't want to engage with a game where this garbage(and everything that proceeds it which granted is way way worse) is part of the universe.

  41. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Yes. For the TCG, I only play Gen 1 and Gen 2 sets. TCG on GameBoy Color is fun

  42. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    GX was a mistake and I will die on that hill

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      I skipped Sun and Moon. Wasn't GX just ex with a special move?

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        you tell me if this is just ex

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          That's not fair. ADP is one if not the strongest card of all time

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      GXes saved the game after 6 years of Big Basic dominance, GXes were amazing and I love them. TAG TEAM GXes on the other hand took the game that had just been saved and killed it again, not a single Sword and Shield set helped to set the game on a good path so now it's just 'I really hope they don't mess up with Scarlet and Violet sets".

  43. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    nostalgia bomb

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      What was Zap's gimmick again?

      I know that Overgrowth focuses on evolving fast, Blackout removes energy and hits fast with Hitmonchan while Brushfire has dem Charizard.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        guess

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          >bunch of garbage and mewtwo
          I forgot how israeli some of these decks were

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            it's the poopy mewtwo not the good one

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              That mewtwo is an auto win if they don't run energy removal. Pretty funny

              Yeah the "Battle City Rules" were introduced to merge the Manga rules with the TCG rules. Duel Monsters was literally a MTG parody invented after Takahashi got dragged to a local tournament by one of his friends. Kaiba is inspired by some real life douchebag player there who no-shit had Kaiba's briefcase full of cards. Even today YGO has some remnants of being a Magic parody made by a guy who saw Magic being played but didn't know the rules oor what was going on. "Defense Mode" being sideways came from him seeing people tapping their cards.

              >somewhere out there there is a 50 year old MtG player with a suitcase of rare cards who probably knows he is the inspiration of kaiba
              Kino

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              How is that good? homie only does 10+ damage and most of the good cards at most only need to have 3 energy on them.

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                it's not, it's terrible

                this is the mewtwo everyone raves about

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                It isn't, that's the poopy Mewtwo

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            It was the fastest way to start a deck outside of the Starter deck with Machamp.

            At least you can buy a box of boosters plus Trainer boxes now even if themed decks no longer exist.

  44. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Looks kino and not for poorgays

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Why is Lugia always normal instead of Psychic?

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        My headcanon is they still regret making Lugia Psychic instead of Water type. It only has Psychic in the first place because it was a busted type in the previous gen and they wanted Lugia to have a strong impact.

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          Lugia might be in the worst legendary in terms of figuring out what its lore is actually supposed to be.
          Lives in the ocean but not water? Pair to Ho-oh but nothing to do with Ho-oh's lore?

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            Lugia is OC character of Takeshi Shudo, director of OG anime and first three movies.

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            Lugia is OC character of Takeshi Shudo, director of OG anime and first three movies.

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              >I was gulping down alcohol and drugs. I started to feel like I wanted to die
              >over a pokemon
              How the frick did these autists and weirdos ever make it out of their mother's basement, let alone make a highly successful media franchise?

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                Well, passion?
                In 80s and 90s your typical person working on Anime was an oldschool otaku that practically spend most of his life on doujin conventions writing fanzines, fan comics, sometimes fan animations etc. Hell, even Gamefreak started as that - they previously were group writing fanzines about games and anime and kinda bonded over Minky Momo... which was directed by Shudo, lol.

                New rule, all basic Pokémon THAT CAN EVOLVE will, after a flip of a coin, take half damage from attacks that turn if that flip is in their favor, however it be, rounded up to the nearest multiple of 10 if it isnt already a multiple of 10. This rule is not in effect if the targeted mon is a baby mon, because they already have a damage neutering flip.
                There, fixed the problem of shit killing runs before they begin, without directly nerving stronger basic mons.

                And here we have autism in it's less cool version. An overly broken, complicated and verbose answer to non-issue that makes zero sense both from gameplay and lore perspective.

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                https://twitter.com/KennyLauderdal3/status/1664340735779282970
                https://twitter.com/KennyLauderdal3/status/1667016482985836545

                This drug-addicted alcoholic was there before even Pokemon was a thing.

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                Neat

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                I remember when my goddess Tamashiihiroka talked about Momo and Game Freak. She's so sexy and always gives us that good shit. Her boyfriend is a lucky guy.

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              >Lugia's creator was a drug bug
              That explains why Lugia has weird wing hands. Only a dude on drugs would think of something so fricked up.

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              >nooooooooo my OC waifu can't have a male voice I'm gonna drink myself to death
              the absolute state of lugiagays

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            Originally the legendary for Silver was a Komainu-esque pokemon (which fits far better for Johto aesthetically), Lugia was made the legendary to tie in with the second movie, hence it feeling very disconnected from the rest of Johto's lore.

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        Defaults to Flying to differentiate I guess.

  45. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    why do I exist?

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      If Porygon's Conversions could stick even on retreat like Smeargle and it had 50 HP, it could have been a fun tech in certain decks.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Being able to change the resistance of your opponent's damage sponge isn't bad in theory.

  46. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    i only played base set, how different is the present day game?

    how do i build a deck?

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      https://jklaczpokemon.com/

      Good resource for learning about the retro eras with a shitload of sample deck lists for each era.

  47. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    For a poor kid who couldn't afford many cards the gbc game was god sent. Having access to everything and an AI to play against at all times was the best thing to happen to me

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      If you had a gameboy you were not poor. Check your privilege

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        Cringe

  48. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    >tfw I remember that box of base set, jungle, and fossil commons and uncommons I threw away when I was 24 because I was too grown for childish things

  49. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Maybe once for the nostalgia. Though personally as a, what the ygogays call me, "Yugiboomer" I think a poke-version of Progression would be more fun. It lets you play with the old school cards again while learning newer stuff set by set.

  50. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    bretty cool eh?

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Shame Courtney has zero art

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        I would simp for Courtney so hard
        Pity her deck is absolute trash

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          >spend all the game hearing about the hype of the oh so great legendary cards
          >they are... that

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            At least Legendary Zapdos is good for memes

            • 9 months ago
              Anonymous

              What's the play here? Run 4 Zapdos as your only Pokemon and only have 1 out at a time? Maybe Mr. Mime?

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                Oh there's no play except to say "frick it" and see what happens

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                he does it in the sequel,

                https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Dee_(TCG_GB)

                kino battle like most other ghost trainers

              • 9 months ago
                Anonymous

                One is attempt to FTK your opponent by repeatedly putting down and scooping up Zapdos to Peal the opponent's initial bench to death
                The other is have one Zapdos out and stall with energy removals, defenders, potions, etc. until you can spam Big Thunder

  51. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    This thread unironically had more TCG discussion than the actual TCG thread.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      same, wouldn't mind a general to play games with other anons through lackey or tcgone

  52. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Now that I think about it, we should be able to duel online in the Switch version of this game, right?

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Yep. I got matches scheduled for later this week

      • 9 months ago
        Anonymous

        Now I really wish they put Card GB2 on here, there's far more interesting decks to build

        • 9 months ago
          Anonymous

          Also far more AIDS

          • 9 months ago
            Anonymous

            but the FUN

  53. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    As someone who never played the TCG before, I played this on NSO for the first time yesterday. 4 clubs beaten, Imakuni exterminated, but got fricked by Ronald. I don't know shit about deckbuilding but I seem to be doing alright so far. All clubs remaining will give my grass deck a hard time so I will need to switch things up going forward

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Grass is unironically one of the best types in BJF because nothing resists it and don't have a universal weakness (unlike fire and electric). A deck built on Venusaur+Exeggutor+Pokemon Center can pretty much beat everything. It's basically a middle ground between Rain Dance hyper offense and Psychic stall.

  54. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Energy removal, only works on basic Pokemon?

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      This but it can't be used on the first turn a pokemon is in play. That way you are not punishing a Charmander for attaching an energy.

  55. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    Are the gba games genuinely the only singleplayer pokemon tcg experiences? I fell in love with Yugioh and MTG through Legacy of the Duelist and Forge, but the lack of singleplayer Pokemon TCG stuff has prevented me from getting into it.

    • 9 months ago
      Anonymous

      Well, there's also this...

  56. 9 months ago
    Anonymous

    great thread

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *