Instead of fallowing Ultimate up with a reboot, 3D arena fighter or a Ultimate 2.0, should we get a Melee remake instead?

Instead of fallowing Ultimate up with a reboot, 3D arena fighter or a Ultimate 2.0, should we get a Melee remake instead?

Thalidomide Vintage Ad Shirt $22.14

Yakub: World's Greatest Dad Shirt $21.68

Thalidomide Vintage Ad Shirt $22.14

  1. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Nobody would play a Melee remake

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      fpbp

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      this
      Knowing enough about melee tourney scene, they would find some minor differences in the HD remake and swear off it forever and keep playing the gamecube version for tournaments

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        Knowing Nintendo, there would be several changes that make it objectively worse than the original. But nintendorks will complain people aren't putting up with a lesser product.

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      If its almost 1:1 and has 99% of the physics? Yea I think they would. But they dont trust nintendo to not pull the plug and I cant blame them

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      If it had the same speed and physics, reworked visuals, with additional trophies spanning across the entire gamecube era...
      But without all the bugs and glitches, you'll a) test the loyalty of meleegays, b) experience melee how it was intended to be, and c) provide "new" material for consoomers to consoom
      It's a win-win-win

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        The movement and techniques aren't glitches and never have been rentfree brawlgay. It's sad that 15 or more years later, the plethora of options melee has lives RENT FREE In your mind and you cant possibly fathom that people are just BETTER at a MORE COMPLEX GAME than you like. You still have this insane idea in your head when the games creators themselves have noted, ackknowledged, confirmed the existence of, and allowed those techniques and mechanics in the game. If it wasn't intended, and was a bug these things woulda been removed in the PAL revision that was put out months later.

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          i was going to reply to that anon what he would consider "glitches" and "bugs" but then you acted like a Black person right away when you read one word

          • 7 months ago
            Anonymous

            You know damn well he and every other homosexual thats been arguing with people since brawls release, considers everything that hes incapable of doing a bug or exploit.

            Way to expose your new.

            • 7 months ago
              Anonymous

              being an angry homosexual about a game you would never play just continues to make meleegays look moronic. you could just not reply to his hypothetical.

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      this
      melee is shit but homosexuals will pretend otherwise because they done nothing but play one garbage game
      it's like saying double dash or even wii is the best mario kart in current year

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      fpbp

      this
      Knowing enough about melee tourney scene, they would find some minor differences in the HD remake and swear off it forever and keep playing the gamecube version for tournaments

      If it had the same speed and physics, reworked visuals, with additional trophies spanning across the entire gamecube era...
      But without all the bugs and glitches, you'll a) test the loyalty of meleegays, b) experience melee how it was intended to be, and c) provide "new" material for consoomers to consoom
      It's a win-win-win

      this
      melee is shit but homosexuals will pretend otherwise because they done nothing but play one garbage game
      it's like saying double dash or even wii is the best mario kart in current year

      >Hook PC up to my OLED TV
      >Boot up Slippi with Melee HD textures and widescreen patch
      >Play melee in 4k, virtually no input lag
      >Queue up for a match, don't have to pay an NSO subscription fee
      >All the matches have are smooth, hardly any wifi shitters, input lag virtually nonexistent
      Yeah, you guys are right. I wouldn't play it. Nintendo would never top this.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        >muh input lag
        I play ultimate online all the time and it feels just like offline. If you're telling me you can feel lag in ultimate online you are a fricking liar.

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          >I play ultimate online all the time and it feels just like offline

          • 7 months ago
            Anonymous

            Are you 50 years old? Are your reactions that bad?

            skill issue. use a lan adapter or stop being american.

            • 7 months ago
              Anonymous

              >is a bongler
              >hasn't noticed his frame rate is capped in all games since the 90s due to shitty pal hardware

              lmao, nevermind anon I take it all back. enjoy your 12fps. god save the queen.

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          Are you 50 years old? Are your reactions that bad?

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          >I play ultimate online all the time and it feels just like offline. If you're telling me you can feel lag in ultimate online you are a fricking liar.

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      Fbpb. Melee elitists would seethe over the smallest change, and nobody else wants to play a smaller roster with no additions. People who want an HD Melee or whatever are genuinely moronic.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        You wouldn't play it either

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          I kinda implied that, yes.

  2. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    You can't remake perfection

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      >implying that half of rooster isn't stitched with duck tape

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      But OP is talking about Melee, the second worst entry after Sm4sh.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        Okay Brawlgay.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        Melee isn't anywhere close to being as bad as Sm4sh

  3. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Nintendo literally hates this game more than anything their competitors have done

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      I'll never understand why Nintendo fricking hates their older games, their fans, and competitive Smash as a whole. Like are they just moronic or something? I don't get it.

  4. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    If there was a remake of melee they'd absolutely remove everything melee is known and loved for.

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      >If there was a remake of melee they'd absolutely remove everything melee is known and loved for.
      Why? TTYD is getting a remake and it is retaining its original artstyle with animation and graphical updates while adding some new features, Nintendo is probably going to do the same with melee.

      >should we get a Melee remake instead?
      leave that to the modders. something like Smash Remix for Melee would be cool yeah but pointless other than aesthetics considering Project M exists

      though I would love a Sonic Mania treatment being an officially published ROM-hack

      >leave that to the modders. something like Smash Remix for Melee would be cool yeah but pointless other than aesthetics considering Project M exists
      Akaneia Build does exactly like that.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        >new features
        like 30fps?

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        >Nintendo is probably going to do the same with melee.

        Kek lmao, not before all these other GameCube Gems, especially F-Zero GX now that we got 99, they would be crazy to not continue that F-Zero Momentum.

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          >gems
          return to reddit immediately

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          >air ride
          only if it has online
          >tp
          no
          >ww
          already got one you greedy frick
          >junglememe
          overrated trash platforming
          >wario world
          overrated but worth it to bring back the real wario and not garlic fart man
          >ttyd
          they made all the floors a hideous glossy texture, some backgrounds are bloomed out the ass in an ugly way, but the rest is hype outside the fact fan trans shit will be legitimized
          >starfox assault
          would be hype with online
          >starfox adventures
          no one cares after we saw what happened to dinosaur planet. That's the game people want
          >fzero gx
          make it fzero gx 99 and sold

          • 7 months ago
            Anonymous

            Now rate the wanted Wii Remakes

            >Why Mario Party 9?

            I did it for a friend, but you’re free to replace MP9 with another Wii Game or even a GameCube Mario Party

            • 7 months ago
              Anonymous

              >shake it
              would be cool
              >spm
              frick. off.
              >sluggers
              would be cool with online
              >prime 3
              yeah no shit, not even worth bringing up it's obviously happening
              >barrel blast
              bait
              >punch out
              should be the first fricking port
              >galaxy
              all-stars exists, what the frick is wrong with you? And it proved that Galaxy standing side by side with the platformers that actually gave mario a proper moveset, it's actually a glossy piece of shit gameplay wise and all it had going for it were heavy themes, a bombastic and epic presentation with an appropriately epic score. 2 DITCHES THAT for 3D World bullshit, it's a fricking level pack with silly wacky brightly-lit hyjinx the same as 3D Land and everything after, it's literally nsmb shit.
              >MP9
              I played one round and I was just confused, but I think it's probably a piece of shit

              the only games that are justified with a port aside from punch out are probably just sin and punishment 2, echoes of time, tatsunoko and strikers charged because it's just that good

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                >Galaxy

                Don’t you need glasses? The game literally says Super Mario Galaxy 2, for your information, people were miffed it wasn’t part of 3D All Stars and they still are.

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          TP got remastered already though

          • 7 months ago
            Anonymous

            Ok Wii U Owner

            • 7 months ago
              Anonymous

              I needed to play Smash, bro

            • 7 months ago
              Anonymous

              >owning a wii u
              lmao like anyone actually does that

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        Original anon is talking about Melee's game play. People have found tricks or glitches or whatever you call them that Sakurai just loathes and could potentially be removed in a remake.

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          Didn't know momentum was a glitch.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        >Why?
        Because Bandai Namco with direction by 2023 Sakurai is a different development team than HAL labs directed by sakurai in 2001.

        kinda ramblely, but it's basically my thoughts on the issue of remakes.

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      I don't even think that matters. Melee players are the most stubborn, autistic playerbase imaginable. They won't move to other games in the same series, they won't move to other games tailor-made specifically for them. They absolutely wouldn't move to a remake. Even if it's completely 1-to-1, even if Nintendo puts out a Melee ISO rip with an HD texture pack, the players STILL would not migrate. They'd find something, the most inane shit possible, and deem the port "unplayable". These frickers are going to be hauling around CRTs and Gamecubes until the day they die. That's just the kind of players Melee has.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        >Melee players are the most stubborn, autistic playerbase imaginable.
        Yes
        >They won't move to other games in the same series
        Because they suck
        >they won't move to other games tailor-made specifically for them
        Because they only do the gameplay and forsake everything else in a game
        They absolutely wouldn't move to a remake. Even if it's completely 1-to-1, even if Nintendo puts out a Melee ISO rip with an HD texture pack, the players STILL would not migrate.
        At this point they probably won't because Nintendo keeps fricking with the melee community for no reason, but they would move to it, assuming it wouldn't have input delay which it might because of modern TVs

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          why are melee Black folk so autistic about "muh crt input delay!"? No other fighting game community shrieks about it like them.

          • 7 months ago
            Anonymous

            Input delay is real moron-kun. Melee is played on wii with only analog video ports, digital conversion can add lag. Modern consoles can use monitors with high refresh rates

          • 7 months ago
            Anonymous

            >No other fighting game community shrieks about it like them.
            Every other fighting game community is whipped and moves onto the new game as soon as it comes out, which happen to only be on consoles with no analog video output.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        >They absolutely wouldn't move to a remake
        Well Melee on PC is free and has god tier netcode. Nintendo remakes are usually extremely low effort and considering they can't even figure out basic online play for their flagship smash game I don't see why they'd put in the effort for what would essentially be an experiment to test a market. Emulated Melee as it is now is better than anything Nintendo would realistically make, full stop.

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          yeah this
          Nintendo lost (never had?) their chance to appeal to this audience and they're pissy about it

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        >They won't move to other games in the same series
        except they do play those games, just not competitively
        playing one smash game competitively doesn't mean you hate and swear to never play any of the others

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        melee is played on wiis at tournaments and on pc play on hd graphics they've made themselves

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        yeah, now imagine seething about that.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        melee gays are so moronic they would rather risk rsi than have turbo buttons to do the pressing for them
        >but muh competition has to injure me
        >but that keyboard controller is cheating!

  5. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    >should we get a Melee remake instead?
    leave that to the modders. something like Smash Remix for Melee would be cool yeah but pointless other than aesthetics considering Project M exists

    though I would love a Sonic Mania treatment being an officially published ROM-hack

  6. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Let's do it. Only put in final destination in the remake.

  7. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    frick off pedo

  8. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    That's fixing moronic

  9. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    >3D arena fighter
    kill yourlself Black person
    >melee remake
    for frick sake, have a nice day NOW

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      Just play project M. Wii with component cables or dolphin plus a gc controller adapter. Its ez fun. Inb4 some contrarian says pm is bad.

      3d arena fighters are fun. Obviously smash won’t be one, but your disproportionate vitriol makes you seem like a loser.

  10. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    it would only be accepted if the only gameplay changes were
    >PAL release
    >fix game and watch (shield, l-cancel not working)
    >wobbling removed without affecting the controllability of the climbers
    and maybe one or two other things i can't think of right now

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      Nobody would play PAL Melee and they still don't for a reason because they nerfed even characters that needed buffs

  11. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    I'd rather have a proper starfox remake tbh

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      Will anybody pick this up when it comes out? I’m definitely going to check it out, I already have Advance Wars Reboot Camp

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        trace memory is not really a game you'd want to play twice, even if you loved it, (which i did).
        But, once again nintendo shackles the fans with
        >you WILL buy the remaster if you POSSIBLY want a slim chance at a new entry sometime in the future (:

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      64 was a remake
      64 3D was a remake
      Zero was a remake
      please no more remakes

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        >64 was a remake
        no it wasn't you disingenuous Black person

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          yeah that's like saying civ 2 is a remake of civ 1 lol

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          64 was a remake of StarFox 1, no matter how much you try to cope

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        Reboot and remake aren't the same thing, dumbass.

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          Nope, it was a remake
          same planets
          same gameplay
          same story
          re
          make

  12. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    you are making Melee Remix, you have to double the roster
    >13 backports(veterans of later smash bros game)
    >13 newcomers
    who do you add?

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      Goku squidward tommy pickles the dad from seventh heaven uhhh what else

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        Alf

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      Melee doesn't need a bigger roster

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        indeed, melee's roster it's already bloated, fox is all it needs

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          >why yes, I don't play Melee
          >How could you tell?

          • 7 months ago
            Anonymous

            things doesn't improve that if you count the other few viable chracters, homosexual

            • 7 months ago
              Anonymous

              Yoshi won.
              You lost.

            • 7 months ago
              Anonymous

              >Viable characters in Melee
              >Fox, Falco, Marth, Pikachu, Yoshi, Shiek, Falcon, Puff, Peach
              You don't know Melee, don't pretend like you do. Now go on a tangent about how Meleegays all stink and are pedophiles out of butthurt

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                >only 9 characters
                yeah exactly, that's pretty bad, and if they somehow balance the game and made all the characters viable you would still be complaning abut how they ruin your game, homosexual

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                I've never understood why it's only ever a problem that Melee has top tiers and no other game.
                Like you never see people go on about how Josie or Claudio haven't won anything in Tekken 7.

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                That's not counting the characters that have potential out of a roster of 25, only the characters that have been proven viable, homosexual.

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                you don't play fighting games, quit pretending you care about this

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                Only 9 characters ***capable of winning majors/supermajors.

                If you're just playing at locals then it literally doesn't matter, you can win with any character, even fricking Bowser

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                Almost none of those are viable, the old top players are just leaving

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                The best current player is literally a Marth with a Roy secondary
                On top of that, Yoshi has been winning Majors almost nonstop and Sheik just won one recently

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                I still wouldn't put Yoshi in the list of viable characters. It's just aMSa. Unless the current generation of players has yielded any other Yoshi players (I stopped paying attention almost a decade ago now).

                Same with Pikachu and Axe.

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                That proves that Yoshi is viable though. Oh sure you have to work harder and have weird quirks you need to understand, but the character can win and is viable.

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                >just because somebody won with them doesn't mean they are viable to win

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                >the lottery is a good and easy way to make money, just pick the right numbers

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                Yeah. Stop being bad.

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                he doesn't have a Roy secondary. he only bust out Are Boy to sleep on people with.
                he does have an ICs for Sheik, though...

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                >i stopped paying attention in 2016

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                >9 character roster
                I like melee but lmao. Competitive smash is a joke.

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                thats relatively standard in other fighters to use like 40% of the roster

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                That's not true outside of a few meme legacy games like Super turbo and MvC2. And also, smash isn't a fighting game, so it should follow the same dumb made up rules.

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                Those are pretty viable to solo main. A lot of mid tiers are viable too if you dual main them. Sheik unironically gatekeeps a lot of the mid tiers harder than fox and marth do, so having a pick to deal with her opens up a lot of other characters.

  13. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Only entitled contrarians boomers still plays this. If they remake melee without all the annoying glitches and exploits competitive gays use, then nobody will give a shit about this game.

  14. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Nintendo wants nothing to do with the FGC, and I don't blame them.

  15. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Nintendo are fricking moronic for not doing more to profit off of melee, but I have zero faith in them making a good remake.

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      pandering to some sweaty smelly fat fcuk c**ts (aka the FGC) is not as profitable as making games for normal people

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        finding ways to make sure people play your game in your pre approved fashion also doesn't get them more money, but here we are

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        you don't have to pander to the scene to simply make the physics fun again, I don't play compedo but Melee is more fun for the physics

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        those buttholes are willing to spend 500$ on custom made controls if anything they would the wales if they knew how to capitalize them

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      melee is the antithesis of nintendo, which is why they, and sakurai loathe it, and the fans love it.
      Nintendo absolutely hate that a game they intended to be "casual", is played so competitively and taken so seriously.

  16. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    HD Trilogy with online would be better

  17. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    I find it funny how Ganker's epic stance of le old good, new bad suddenly doesn't apply when people actually continue to play the old game.

  18. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    >remake a game that is remarked as a great fighting game because of glitches that came out as features core to competitive gaming
    >expecting nintendo to not patch everything out
    the best they can do is remaster the game and not touch anything so the nigras stuck in the game won't have to carry CRTs.

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      What glitches?

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        Wobbling. It ruined every ice climber match.

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          Wobbling isn't a glitch though.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        >implying wave dashing and all those autistic crap were a totally intentional thing made by the developers

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          yes

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          Yeah, devs acknowledged wavedashing was a thing.

          don't play coy, now

          Still haven't named any.

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          devs outright said they noticed wavedashing during development but didn't fix it because they didn't think anyone would really use it

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          I don't care if it was intentional or not. It's fun.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        don't play coy, now

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      >the best they can do is remaster the game and not touch anything so the nigras stuck in the game won't have to carry CRTs.
      They won't remaster the game, the only assets that were survived from Melee are the songs everything else were lost after Brawl.

  19. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Imagine how different things would be if Melee got ported to the Wii with Online after Sakurai turned down making Brawl, as stated by Iwata.

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      >Wii with Online
      PFFFT, but yeah if they had keep the game as it was and just add a couple of characters and maybe fix actual problems like wobbling or mr game and watch shield, then yeah, gc melee would had died and maybe even wii gamecube would had died in favor of smash4 (implying that they don't return to melee bc of bayo and cloud)

  20. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    You already got a remake with ultimate you goy

  21. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Meleegays wouldn't play a Melee remake simply because it couldn't be on CRT, they are that autistic

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      My locals play on modern monitors.

  22. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Whoever made this, I hope you’re here MeleeChad

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      This is the reason why I don’t want to play melee. My mains are bowser and kirby

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        same, kirby is the one i'm interested in the most because he's fun but he sucks
        i don't even do it for the sake of being a contrarian, very next game my preferred pick is meta knight because he's so cool, also i like mr g&w and luigi

  23. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    yeah they can fix all the bugs.

  24. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    do you really think they could do anything other than ruin a melee remake?

  25. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    no, they'd ruin it

  26. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Should Melee have been a 2002 release? I think it should've gotten some more time in the oven.

    >Extra time to add remaining essentials like Wario, Diddy, and a second Kirby character
    >Making Ganondorf more unique as a fighter
    >Giving Fire Emblem a proper stage
    >Fixing unfinished characters like Mr. Game & Watch

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      You wouldn’t have gotten Dr. Mario, Falco, Pichu, Roy, Young Link or Ganondorf. They were added as filler since they couldn’t make another original character. Pretty sure I read the choice was 4-5 clones or an original character, it was going to be Dedede.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        Here's your Fall 2002 Melee roster, bro.
        No, Ganondorf is NOT a clone here.

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          You fricking wish

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          Marill is hilarious here! Wouldn’t it just be a WaterChu?

          • 7 months ago
            Anonymous

            Gen 2 still needs a shillmon, but since Pichu was meant to be an extra clone, Marill would fit well in its place here, being a simple-to-make character who'd also be the only fighter on this roster with water-based attacks.
            Marill, Wolf, and this version of Ganondorf would basically be like the non-Luigi hidden fighters from 64, where they use other characters as frameworks but have mostly original movesets (or at least in Wolf's case, he'd be more distinct than Falco was).

            • 7 months ago
              Anonymous

              Why not Scizor? Oh right we’re on time constraints I understand, shame Smash will never have a playable Insectoid

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          Add Blood Falcon for shits and giggles or even Goroh as a half-assed clone with a sword attack.

          • 7 months ago
            Anonymous

            I actually saved Goroh for how I would've done Brawl (specifically, keep HAL as the main devs, have the game literally just be Melee but prettier in terms of engine, and target a Holiday 2008 release from the start)

            • 7 months ago
              Anonymous

              >Toon Zelda
              >Stafy
              >Rool
              >Isaac
              >Ray-01
              That is a fairly balanced roster, good job.

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                Yeah, my main mentality is that since a later-released Melee would've already had some of the harder hitters like Diddy, Wario and King Dedede, Brawl would need to dig a bit deeper for picks, which isn't a bad thing mind you. Toon Zelda and Tetra would pretty much be a more natural evolution of a transforming Zelda (while normal Zelda is made a bit more distinct gameplay-wise from how she was in Melee).
                K. Rool, Krystal, Lyn and Isaac would be characters added primarily on demand, but also to let some of these series catch up to others in character count.
                Starfy and Ray would be added as characters from series that were going strong at the time Brawl would be in development. I chose the Ray from the GameCube Custom Robo, since that was the installment that came out internationally.
                Pac-Man was requested to be in Brawl by Miyamoto himself, but didn't get in since Sakurai was only aware of the pizza circle design, which is something I'd definitely remedy.
                Lastly you have the Mach Rider as an Ice Climbers-type inclusion, mainly on the basis that Wario, being a Melee veteran here in this hypothetical, wouldn't use his bike from WarioWare, so someone else would have to go the vehicular combat route instead.

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                Good picks, once again.
                I kinda wish Brawl got delayed to around Summer 2008. MAYBE Tetra/T. Zelda and Dixie could have been added alongside Dr. Mario and maybe Roy. Brawl's roster filled in some holes but it needed maybe one more row. I remember people expected around 50-ish characters in the playable roster.

  27. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    No, Melee is already perfect a perfectly rushed game

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      I wonder how Light would do against Mang0

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        he would need at least 6 months of grinding to even make it competitive
        same for mang0 in the other direction

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          Still it's always interesting to see Ultimate players play Melee and vice versa

          • 7 months ago
            Anonymous

            watching Skyjay pummel ibdw was definitely funny

            • 7 months ago
              Anonymous

              Seeing Nairo stomp Mang0 repeatedly with Ganondorf was always hilarious
              Need more Ultimate players playing Melee though

  28. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    All Pedogays should kill themselves, your game is trash

  29. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    >should we make an original game
    >Nah let's just remake a shit gam

  30. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Lmao people work fast

    https://ssbmtextures.com/characters/elephant-daisy/?fbclid=IwAR2v3c_3NltbNeXe-qCxL_KyOtTW_4Osbh4zZIyeckown4Y2jl-sYFDhjtc_aem_AXhFTgFYW8GWK_ViM8kv6ssIA7r_86asgknxtWvxOV_s8N_LiRo9ZZ01FoWfGmOZC0g&mibextid=Zxz2cZ

  31. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    It would be shit. Just give Melee a facelift.

  32. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    I just found out that Melee never had a trophy for Diddy Kong and Wolf. weirder that Wolf is in the intro but nope he has no trophy

  33. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Everything that made Melee revolutionary, and good cannot be replicated in a remake and the feelings it had cannot be recaptured

    The only people who think otherwise are delusional meleegays, or zoomers who weren't old enough to play it when it was new in the first place

  34. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Compgays wouldn't like it but I would at least appreciate it

  35. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    At this point sure why the frick not, because they cant remove the original. Nintendo will nerf it, make adjustments, kill the meta of the game and completely shit on what makes the game fun to appeal to people who are bad at videogames. I didnt say casual because there are some fricks that wear it like a badge of honor. nerfing and ruining series for people who are Bad At Videogames shouldn't be a thing but here we are 3 entries later after melee.

    Whats sad is ultimates not bad I like it, but the input delay is absolutely unplayable.

    t.A melee mid tier main for many years, the game is as it is and i dont need Nintendo's pandering or your shit sympathy.

  36. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Melee remake
    holy shit just learn to emulate and stop begging for remakes or remasters

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      Cope, Nintendo said emulation of their games on non-Nintendo platforms is illegal.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        Yeah and I say it's illegal for Nintendo to contact me in any capacity

  37. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    >should we get a Melee remake instead?
    No.
    Melee is flawed as frick but it has a great aesthetic and music that I don't think modern nintendo would be able to replicate.

  38. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Pick 12

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      Roll in pit, Charizard, metaknight, dedede, wario, and heracross. You don't need more than that.

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      Charizard
      Meta Knight
      Daisy
      Diddy Kong
      Ayumi Tachibana

  39. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    name 5 fighters where over half of the roster is good and can hang with toptiers

  40. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    God no, they'd ruin a Melee remake

  41. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    not much of a point in remaking a game that is already
    >on PC
    >runs on shitbox
    >has mods
    >has rollback netcode
    >has ranked netplay
    and is free.

    I mean I'm sure if they were to release it, plenty of drones would buy it. but I don't see how they could possibly make me give a frick

  42. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Putting it on the Switch would be a mistake because Nintendo haven't been able to fix their fricking controllers drifting after a little wear-and-tear for like the seven years the switch has been alive
    Melee would fricking destroy so many joycons

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      tap sticking already destroyed a lot of 3DS

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      just make yet another gcc adapter and print even more gccs lmao

  43. 7 months ago
    Trooth Bombz "THE AUTHENTIC MEME" from /asp/

    Mario Party 2 costumes mechanic where everybody's design changes based on the level. Use that to justify cutting back on characters.

  44. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    That doesn't make Nintendo money. The casuals wouldn't buy it because it has less content than Ultimate and doesn't have the reboot excuse to fall back on, competitive players would find SOMETHING wrong, like nerfing Marth's grab range, and boycott.

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      smash sells itself on brand

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        Yes it does, but casuals are fickle creatures, and i doubt a Melee remake would sell more than a hypothetical reboot. The casual sees less stages, characters, music, no third parties, and they wonder why they would buy instead of Ultimate. Competitive players are very dedicated to Melee, to a fault i'd say. It wouldn't take much to piss them off.

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          come on, look how shit Pokemon is and it still sells on brand

          • 7 months ago
            Anonymous

            True, but casuals are also moronic. Don't get me wrong, a Melee remake would sell, especially if it's the first Smash Bros ona new console, but the only reason that makes sense, to me, to remake it over just rebooting/making a new game would be getting compgays to switch over, and as already said, they will find an excuse not to, if Nintendo doesn't piss them off by up and remove wavedashing.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        I think you mean characters

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      Casuals specifically buy Smash because of the competitive scene but it's clear you have no idea what the frick you're talking about. They don't need to play competitively to get hyped for Smash because Competitive's scene as a whole hypes it up for Nintendo without doing anything. You don't have to watch competitive Smash or engage in it for word to spread to you, otherwise you homosexuals wouldn't be here every Smash thread b***hing and moaning about what you think competitive Smash is.

  45. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Thank the lord above melee is finally dying

  46. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Just make a traditional fighting game.

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      moron GOD

  47. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Melee remake for autists
    No thanks. They can keep playing that instead. Let me get a new title.

  48. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    No. Super Mario Movie Smash. 1v1. Stages are dynamic and in arenas. Ghost crowds let you watch seasonal tournaments live at the the stadium.

    8 player larger mode turned into 64 player Battle Royale set in huge map with major features/layouts of old maps kind of stitched together for a larger whole that loops back onto itself.

    That is the way forward for Smash.

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      It evolves the game and satisfies everyone. Smash needs a fresh start without destroying it's heritage.

      1v1 players can get a more focused smash game and it onboards the esports element that is currently on life support.

      Actual changes I would want for gameplay would be a tighter camera and a game clock reduction of about 10 percent.

      No one cares about larger 4+ player Smash. A battle royale mode taps into the zeitgeist in a way that other games don't have.

      A large battle royale map can also be used for single player. Running missions for each character with Mario style enemies in the costumes of the player character's game origin. Or something like that.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        It would be wild to see a big map with Mario, Zelda, Metroid, Kirby and other game enemies all kind of interacting with each other in a goofy Nintendo way. Use the new Mario Wonder style and fill the game with ambience, but a chaotic ambience of all these wrong enemies butting heads with each other.

  49. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    no. smelee is dogshit and nintendo finally burned its corpse today

  50. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    why would there ever need to be a melee remake? why would you even want one? so you can pay 40 bucks to break your joycons and 60 for an adapter+controller?
    >20xx
    >akenia
    >slippi
    theres your remake moron (and all for free to boot)
    that being said, using amiibos in melee would be pretty fricking cool

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      melee gays would never be happy since they prefer their shitty controller and would want a impossible controller remake with a remake of melee
      which would be a modern version of the gamecube controller with analog gates and no stick kick or whatever the frick it's called
      but you were never meant to flick your stick like a fricking animal while playing games and even then they would never go out of their way to include wave dashing since it's a garbage unintended mechanic

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQzhu35mR2w yes

        Yeah, devs acknowledged wavedashing was a thing.
        [...]
        Still haven't named any.

        devs outright said they noticed wavedashing during development but didn't fix it because they didn't think anyone would really use it

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          I'll never understand why people who don't even play Smash get so caught up on fricking wavedashing of all things, you're literally just short jumping and air dodging back to the ground quickly. There's no complicated inputs you need to do to perform it and devs fricking new about it and gave advice on how to do it optimally. Dumbest shit I've ever seen.

  51. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    I would like a Pokemon spritebased smash like Rivals of Aether then again that could just exist with a bunch of workshop characters

  52. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    >100% the same except you can't jump out of shine

  53. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    I vouch for Smash 99

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      Rosterhomosexualry needs to die. You gays don't even play the game.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        what gives you that impression?

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          Post your gsp.

          • 7 months ago
            Anonymous

            I don't play online but I have 100% WoL

            • 7 months ago
              Anonymous

              I thought so.

              >noooo you shouldn't care for the crossover aspect of a crossover game!
              back to marvel vs capcom """infinite""" for you

              If you don't play the game, your opinion doesn't matter.

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                the online is shit and I don't want to pay for it

              • 7 months ago
                Anonymous

                Just reduce universal input delay and put aerial momentum back in. There, that's all that needs to be changed from a gameplay standpoint.
                Happy?

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        >noooo you shouldn't care for the crossover aspect of a crossover game!
        back to marvel vs capcom """infinite""" for you

  54. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    Make the next entry a trad fighter.

  55. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    >everyone supporting the smash modding community when in reality is infested with trannies that spam shitty pink-blue flag skins

  56. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    anyone else
    >play ultimate
    >watch melee
    Melee is way too hard but this game makes me laugh my ass off

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      you can easily play melee
      it's just shit and only attracts the worst people and has pathetic gays who never stopped playing

      ultimate is just a better game for new players and older players

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        >ultimate is just a better game for new players and older player
        how so?

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      I play Ultimate and watch Melee yeah but mostly because I feel like it's too late for me to get into Melee plus I'm a brainlet that can't setup Slippi where it won't lag my potato.

  57. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    I would get back into Melee if Akaneai build adds content like Smash Remix

    Beyond Melee will never be finished with that mentally unstable troon incharge but I commend adding Raichu and Skullkid

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      akaneia is on my shitlist because they added that little blond Jimmy Neutron looking b***h Lucas before Wario or King Dedede

  58. 7 months ago
    Anonymous

    what went wrong with ultimate?

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      It's not a good game.

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      Doesn't Ultimate have it's majors? I imagine the audience is different to.

      Melee top 8 being so early kinda suck, I miss staying up until 1 am because the tournament ran later than schedule, tbdesu.

    • 7 months ago
      Anonymous

      The DLC was complete and utter shit.
      >ARMS
      >Minecraft
      >Another FF rep
      >More Xenoshit
      >More Fire Emblem
      >Kingdom Sharts
      >Kaz-who?-ya
      >Literally a generic Piranha Plant from any given Mario game
      Joker okay-ish though.

      • 7 months ago
        Anonymous

        Aside of the FE guy the dlc pack is really good, but I think all of those should have been in the base game.

        • 7 months ago
          Anonymous

          I think it was all shit. I vaguely remember hearing about how franchises that were already represented in Smash before wouldn't be getting new characters in Ultimate, yet Sephiroth, Pyra/Myrtha, Byleth, and Piranha Plant all got in despite the fact that;
          >Cloud was added in Smash 4
          >Shulk was added in Smash 4
          >Marth and Roy were added in Melee
          >Mario and Luigi were in Smash 64

          • 7 months ago
            Anonymous

            Sakurai is never to be trusted. Remember when Brawl was going to have no clones?

            • 7 months ago
              Anonymous

              Doesn't mean I can't be pissed off over it. I would've loved to have had characters like;
              >Shantae (Frick you, Mii outfits don't count.)
              >Asuka or Yumi (Senran Kagura)
              >Neptune or Blanc (Neptunia)
              >Literally any character from Lethal League
              >A Valve rep (I'd go for Heavy or The Tank)
              >Reimu or Marisa (Touhou)
              Hell if it's gonna fricking break his own rule, why not add Paper Mario? There's plenty of badges to choose from for his moveset, ontop of being able to utilize his Partners for additional moves or his final smash or something. God I fricking hate Ultimate.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *