Most overrated video games chosen by Game Journalists (2023)

Their list starts with Witcher 3
Witcher 3
New Vegas
Half Life 2
GTA4
Fortnite
Guitar Hero
SA2
Bioshock Infinite
Call of Duty
Dead Island
Cuphead
Nu-God of War
Gears 4
MK 2011
LBP
AC4 Black Flag
Inside
FF7
COD Black Ops
Skyward Sword
Carmageddon
Halo 4
Borderlands
Max Payne 3
Candy Crush
Mario Galaxy
GTA San Andreas
La noire
Slenderman
Pokemon Go
Overwatch
Sims
Ace Attorney
Angry Birds
FNAF
WOW
Among Us
Minecraft
Oblivion
Pokemon Gen 1
Timesplitters
DMC 2
Tomb Raider 1996
Bully
Crazy Taxi
Goldeneye
Battlefront (original)
DK64
Pitfall
POP Forgotten Sands
Bioshock
Portal (2007)
Fallout 3
Uncharted 2
Tekken 8
Mario Kart 64
MGS4
Pokemon Legends
Flappy Bird
Horizon Zero Dawn
RE7
The Last of Us
Tetris (all versions)
Smash Bros Franchise
Kingdom Hearts
Lemmings 2
Fifa
Wii Fit
Gran Turismo 7

Shopping Cart Returner Shirt $21.68

Yakub: World's Greatest Dad Shirt $21.68

Shopping Cart Returner Shirt $21.68

  1. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    journalists only know about popualr games anyway so its easy to agree with an overrated list vs a best list

  2. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Tekken 8
    The game isn't even out yet.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      And everyone thinks it's Tekken 7.5 anyway. With the 0.5 being not that good.

  3. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Pokemon GO
    Despite being handled like shit, you have to be purposefully obtuse to pretend it wasn’t a global phenomenon for several months. There wasn’t anything “overrated” about it, even if it did wind up petering out.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      It being so big is what made it overrated. Being overrated is the attention the game gets outweighing how good the game is, and Pokemon Go is not a good enough game for that attention

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      It being popular and a global phenomenon doesn't mean you can't overrate the quality of it. You even say it was handled like shit. That's what a list like this is pointing out. The flaws were glossed over at the time because of hype, popularity or just poor reviewing methods.
      The finale of Lost had insane viewership numbers but it wasn't overrated because of it, people actually acknowledged the flaws and called it out on it. Go, on the other hand, had a lot of review publications turning a blind eye to how mishandled and barebones it was and made it out to be the second coming of christ on hype and the whole "every kids dream come true" concept of it alone. It was overrated.

      • 6 months ago
        Anonymous

        There was nothing wrong with the lost finale though.

  4. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    also who tf is hyping up lemmings 2?

  5. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Half Life 2
    based

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      Based on YOU not having any FRIENDS!! >:[([

      Captcha: ur4g4y

  6. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    My list: Anything made after 2016

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      Same here, but 2006 instead

      • 6 months ago
        Anonymous

        Same but 1989 instead.

        • 6 months ago
          Anonymous

          That's bold.
          Can you tell me your favourite games?
          I can only think of one that I'd consider for my top ten than came out before 1989.

          • 6 months ago
            Anonymous

            Phantasy star 2, technically it was a 1990 release in NA but it was still released early 89 in nipland

            • 6 months ago
              Anonymous

              That's bold.
              Can you tell me your favourite games?
              I can only think of one that I'd consider for my top ten than came out before 1989.

              Other games I remember playing back then and really liking were Commando, The OG Punch-out in 87, and Metal Gear in the same year.

            • 6 months ago
              Anonymous

              I could see someone putting Ys I & II on their list.

              Both good choices. I think there are plenty of good games made before 1990 that hold up today (as I say, I'd put at least one on my personal top ten), but I think it's a bit too restrictive considering how many good games there were in the 90's.

              • 6 months ago
                Anonymous

                Oh yeah I was just spitballing, you'd have to be a nostalgia blind moron to unironically think there was nothing good made after 89, I don't think I could justify putting more than 3-5 pre-1989 games on a top 100 list even.

          • 6 months ago
            Anonymous

            I could see someone putting Ys I & II on their list.

        • 6 months ago
          Anonymous

          Same but 1975.

  7. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Never heard of gosocial in my life before. Trying to fish for clicks on your pathetic article, OP?

  8. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Flappy Bird
    literally nobody has thought of this game in years, how can it be overrated?

  9. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    DK64? Nobody talks about that game, if anything it's underrated

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      *underhated

  10. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >minecraft
    >new vegas
    >RE7
    so they just let doom Gankertard right articles now?

  11. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Am I missing it or is there not a single Zelda on here? I'd say BOTW should be a shoe-in.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      Skyward Sword, i guess the author only chose games they consider bad.

      • 6 months ago
        Anonymous

        I'd ask how SS of all Zeldas is considered overrated when it's considered one of the weaker games but this list has games like DK64 and MGS4 on it so yeah that sounds about right.

        • 6 months ago
          Anonymous

          SS is hands down the weakest 3D non-mobile Zelda title
          Overrated Zelda title would easily be WW

  12. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Seems like a conflict of interest, when most big game journalists are paid under the table to inflate hype for big-budget shitty games like these.

  13. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >DMC 2
    >Halo 4
    who the frick is hyping these at all? If anything I would've gone with halo 2 and DMC1.
    >The Last of Us
    surprised this one slipped out of one their mouths

  14. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Gay Journalists

  15. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    no skyrim? seriously?

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      Rightfully had oblivion on the list but not that piece of shit game.

      • 6 months ago
        Anonymous

        Seethe contrarian

  16. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Carmageddon
    What the frick kind of random ass game to pick on is this

  17. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Overrated means literally nothing.
    The best game in all of history could be 'overrated'

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      Good thing there are no good games on their list

  18. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Are they just listning popular game? I never seen anyone claim "Sims" is some kind of groundbreaking or the best game ever in the world. But just popular.
    Like nearly all the games in this list. Like I never seen anyone claim Bully is some kind of super legendary best game in the world shit.

  19. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Skyward Sword
    this game was never overrated. If one game is overrated that it's BotW.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      moron, when it came out Journalists were comparing it with Ocarina of Time, showering it with 10/10s and claiming it was the best game of all time.

  20. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Portal (2007) Lolz. Yeah portal was overrated. There are some other stupid ones on there but this stands out. It’s like saying pong was overrated.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      They said it was too easy to be considered a good game and shat on it's length

      • 6 months ago
        Anonymous

        Didn't realize Portal was into anal

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      Portal is one of the most overrated games in history though. Super simple puzzle game hyped liked crazy because of "GAMER CULTURE!" and Valve.

  21. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >no stalker

    garbage list

  22. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Cuphead
    People use it to dunk on jounos, not overrated
    >LBP
    Not overrated that game was amazing I only bought it after playing it at a friends house not because of hype
    >Mario Galaxy
    Legit amazing beaten by galaxy 2 although I would understand saying it was better than 64
    >Pokrmon Legends Arceus
    Best 3D pokemon game by far it's not even funny not overrated
    >Kingdom Hearts
    Even if you don't like square or disney it was revolutionary at the time for it's combat and mishmashed unrelated gameplay elements into a cohesive adventure. Legit silly to call it overrated as everyone lauds 2 over it anyway.

  23. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    looks like bait

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      Checks out to me, it needs Elden Ring, GTA V and BOTW though

  24. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    That’s far too many games. You can’t just pick every popular game made in the last 20 years and shove them all on a massive list like that it’s moronic.

    At least they got one thing right. Witcher 3 is bafflingly overrated, like it feels like some kind of psyop to frick with me whenever someone starts going on about how they actually think that game is some kind of masterpiece.

  25. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Popular=overrated

  26. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Dead Island
    Doesn't everyone say this game is shit?

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      no i will defend dead island to the grave even while i acknowledge that dying light is objectively superior

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      The only people that say its shit are the are dumbasses that played with digital melee controls.
      One of the game's big features was the dismemberment/crippling system, made even better by how you could precisely aim a melee swing to cripple or chop a limb off.
      Game got even better when you had a full party of people to dick around the island with and dunk on the undead.

      • 6 months ago
        Anonymous

        My favorite part about that game is how when you play it alone, it's a survival horror game. but when you play it with friends it instantly turns into this goofy ass chav sim where you run around and beat up old defenseless people(zombies) and rob them blind

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      Yeah it's shit, probably the prime example of "unnecessary tacked-on RPG mechanics that actively make the game worse and contribute nothing" I can think of. Cool melee mechanics though.

  27. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Max Payne 3
    that game is underrated as frick

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      >Max Payne 3
      >game

  28. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Most of these games are shit journos themselves hyped up
    Is this their way of subtly saying that their opinions are shit and they only say what they're payed to?

  29. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Final Fantasy 7 should always take the number 1 spot. Everyone absolutely adores it, but I'm convinced few actually played it. The very last thing I did was lose track of Ultimate weapon. Couldn't even finish it. I regret the purchase.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      >The very last thing I did was lose track of Ultimate weapon
      Filtered

  30. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Witcher 3
    >Fornite
    >Bioshock Infinite
    >Nu-GoW
    >Gears 4
    >AC4 Black Flag
    >GTA: SA
    >L.A. Noire
    >GoldenEye
    >Uncharted 2
    >Horizon: Zero Dawn
    >Gran Turismo 7

    Yes.

  31. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Their list starts with Witcher 3
    >Witcher 3
    Agreed
    >New Vegas
    Disagree, just because it's a cult classic doesn't mean it's over hyped.
    >Half Life 2
    No, it was as good as people claim it to be on release.
    >GTA4
    Both ways. Those that hate it and those that loved it.
    >Fortnite
    No idea, never played it.
    >Guitar Hero
    Yes, it's shit.
    >SA2
    Don't know what this fricking abbreviation is for so no idea. Next time write the title moron
    >Bioshock Infinite
    Agree, it's dog shit. Supposedly a mediocre DLC made up for this slightly.
    >Call of Duty
    Depends on which one, but no. It's ground breaking in a lot of ways. Most of them in a bad way.
    >Dead Island
    Agree, it's shit.
    >Cuphead
    Hand drawn animation is impressive. So, no. Disagree, work of art.
    >Nu-God of War
    Agreed, it's dog shit.
    >Gears 4
    Only played it briefly, but all of the Gears of War series is over hyped and lame. The generic ogre turd that was a guest character on killer instinct should win the aware for worse outside franchise usage.
    >MK 2011
    Played and it's worse than it's prequels. Did bring up a great deal of the problem of the anti White discrimination issues, though. So politically relevant? Maybe.
    >LBP
    Again, write the title you stupid fricking homosexual.
    >AC4 Black Flag
    Disagree, it was good. Not great, but good. Worth most of the praise it got.
    >Inside
    Agreed, it's shit.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      >FF7
      Disagree, was a good game and genre defining.
      >COD Black Ops
      Same thing as COD. It was a hallmark of both good and shit practices and game play design.
      >Skyward Sword
      Agreed, it's shit that's been done elsewhere and done better. Even within its own series.
      >Carmageddon
      No idea, never played it.
      >Halo 4
      Agreed, but then that goes for the entire HALO series.
      >Borderlands
      Agreed.
      >Max Payne 3
      Disagree, but because I never heard anyone hyping this game. It's a good third person shooter, but there's not much else to say about it.
      >Candy Crush
      No idea, never played it.
      >Mario Galaxy
      Played it briefly. It's alright.
      >GTA San Andreas
      Disagree, genre defining.
      >La noire
      Disagree, genre defining. But, only good for one go through for obvious reasons.
      >Slenderman
      Agree, dog shit.
      >Pokemon Go
      No idea, never played it.
      >Overwatch
      No idea same reason as the other no ideas.
      >Sims
      Genre defining, so it checks out. Disagree in it being overhyped.
      >Ace Attorney
      Disagree, excellent point and click series.
      >Angry Birds
      No idea.
      >FNAF
      Write the full title moronic homosexual.
      >WOW
      Same as above, but I think you're referring to World of Warcraft. But, no it wasn't over hyped. It created an entire genre. Still sucked, though. Like all of those games do.
      >Among Us
      No idea
      >Minecraft
      Seen plenty of footage for it incidentally, and I don't get the appeal. Agree.
      >Oblivion
      Disagree, it's what allowed Bethesda to put out shit game after shit game and somehow have a loyal following for over ten years. That's worth hype in and of itself.
      >Pokemon Gen 1
      Disagree, genre defining.
      >Timesplitters
      Disagree.

      • 6 months ago
        Anonymous

        >GTA San Andreas
        >genre defining
        In what way? We had GTA 3 before it.

        • 6 months ago
          Anonymous

          He's a redditor

          • 6 months ago
            Anonymous

            Take that back you fricking prostitute.

        • 6 months ago
          Anonymous

          GTA 3 was sort of like a beta to San Andreas. It defined the open world, city mission, wacky in between mission game design. And, the formula that Rockstar lazily repeated a dozen times afterwards. As well as fifty million other lame as frick companies.

          • 6 months ago
            Anonymous

            You mean it defined everything a game before it had already done?

            • 6 months ago
              Anonymous

              It did the things that GTA 3 did, but far more of them, and in a solid "package" that San Andreas ended up being sold as under different titles and formats. GTA 3 didn't have flying vehicles, barely any water craft. Didn't have comprehensive melee. Stats. And, a bunch of the other shit that you see come up again, and again, and again in the GTA clones. In fact, GTA 3 is derivative of earlier and equally bland open world titles.

              • 6 months ago
                Anonymous

                Vice City had nearly all this and was the better game compared to GTA SA

              • 6 months ago
                Anonymous

                That's because you don't play as a Black person in Vice City.

      • 6 months ago
        Anonymous

        >DMC 2
        It's legendarily shit. Played it for the first time the other day out of morbid curiosity. Was almost unplayable. Not even good for a once through. So, disagree. Hype for it's dog shit was and still is actually understated.
        >Tomb Raider 1996
        Agreed.
        >Bully
        Unique open world beat 'em up. Not much else too add. I don't agree that it's hyped, though.
        >Crazy Taxi
        Sort of agree. It's a legendary game and unique title. But, it's hype is OLD. Almost nobody even knows what that game is now.
        >Goldeneye
        Genre defining and on a shit game console, too. Disagree.
        >Battlefront (original)
        No idea.
        >DK64
        Disagree, what hype does this title get?
        >Pitfall
        No idea
        >POP Forgotten Sands
        No idea
        >Bioshock
        Agree
        >Portal (2007)
        Disagree, unique feature that's never been replicated outside of its sequel.
        >Fallout 3
        Agree, it's shit.
        >Uncharted 2
        Agree, it's shit. And, it replaced the Jak series to boot.
        >Tekken 8
        No idea.
        >Mario Kart 64
        Disagree, game was very fun and deserves all the praise it received and still does.
        >MGS4
        Amazing technology for the console it was on and a shame it didn't get more game play and a pc release. But, I don't recall it getting much hype.
        >Pokemon Legends
        No idea
        >Flappy Bird
        No idea
        >Horizon Zero Dawn
        Agree it's shit
        >RE7
        Agree, it's meh.
        >The Last of Us
        Agree, it's shit
        >Tetris (all versions)
        Disagree, most moronic of all the hot takes. Genre defining and hobby defining.
        >Smash Bros Franchise
        Disagree, it's good.
        >Kingdom Hearts
        Disagree, it's good.
        >Lemmings 2
        No idea
        >Fifa
        Agree, it's shit.
        >Wii Fit
        Disagree, this never got that much hype
        >Gran Turismo 7
        No idea, but there are a lot of great racing games out there.

        • 6 months ago
          Anonymous

          >But, I don't recall it getting much hype.
          Maybe because you were 2 when it released? Shut your fricking mouth and put a trip on so I can filter your moronic posts.

          • 6 months ago
            Anonymous

            Journalists spamming shit isn't the same thing as hype.

        • 6 months ago
          Anonymous

          >>DMC 2
          >It's legendarily shit.
          Everyone agrees with that. No hypes it up. It's inclusion is moronic and your rant is even dumber than it's inclusion.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      >Disagree, just because it's a cult classic doesn't mean it's over hyped.
      It's a troony classic that's the only cult that likes it

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      >FF7
      Disagree, was a good game and genre defining.
      >COD Black Ops
      Same thing as COD. It was a hallmark of both good and shit practices and game play design.
      >Skyward Sword
      Agreed, it's shit that's been done elsewhere and done better. Even within its own series.
      >Carmageddon
      No idea, never played it.
      >Halo 4
      Agreed, but then that goes for the entire HALO series.
      >Borderlands
      Agreed.
      >Max Payne 3
      Disagree, but because I never heard anyone hyping this game. It's a good third person shooter, but there's not much else to say about it.
      >Candy Crush
      No idea, never played it.
      >Mario Galaxy
      Played it briefly. It's alright.
      >GTA San Andreas
      Disagree, genre defining.
      >La noire
      Disagree, genre defining. But, only good for one go through for obvious reasons.
      >Slenderman
      Agree, dog shit.
      >Pokemon Go
      No idea, never played it.
      >Overwatch
      No idea same reason as the other no ideas.
      >Sims
      Genre defining, so it checks out. Disagree in it being overhyped.
      >Ace Attorney
      Disagree, excellent point and click series.
      >Angry Birds
      No idea.
      >FNAF
      Write the full title moronic homosexual.
      >WOW
      Same as above, but I think you're referring to World of Warcraft. But, no it wasn't over hyped. It created an entire genre. Still sucked, though. Like all of those games do.
      >Among Us
      No idea
      >Minecraft
      Seen plenty of footage for it incidentally, and I don't get the appeal. Agree.
      >Oblivion
      Disagree, it's what allowed Bethesda to put out shit game after shit game and somehow have a loyal following for over ten years. That's worth hype in and of itself.
      >Pokemon Gen 1
      Disagree, genre defining.
      >Timesplitters
      Disagree.

      >DMC 2
      It's legendarily shit. Played it for the first time the other day out of morbid curiosity. Was almost unplayable. Not even good for a once through. So, disagree. Hype for it's dog shit was and still is actually understated.
      >Tomb Raider 1996
      Agreed.
      >Bully
      Unique open world beat 'em up. Not much else too add. I don't agree that it's hyped, though.
      >Crazy Taxi
      Sort of agree. It's a legendary game and unique title. But, it's hype is OLD. Almost nobody even knows what that game is now.
      >Goldeneye
      Genre defining and on a shit game console, too. Disagree.
      >Battlefront (original)
      No idea.
      >DK64
      Disagree, what hype does this title get?
      >Pitfall
      No idea
      >POP Forgotten Sands
      No idea
      >Bioshock
      Agree
      >Portal (2007)
      Disagree, unique feature that's never been replicated outside of its sequel.
      >Fallout 3
      Agree, it's shit.
      >Uncharted 2
      Agree, it's shit. And, it replaced the Jak series to boot.
      >Tekken 8
      No idea.
      >Mario Kart 64
      Disagree, game was very fun and deserves all the praise it received and still does.
      >MGS4
      Amazing technology for the console it was on and a shame it didn't get more game play and a pc release. But, I don't recall it getting much hype.
      >Pokemon Legends
      No idea
      >Flappy Bird
      No idea
      >Horizon Zero Dawn
      Agree it's shit
      >RE7
      Agree, it's meh.
      >The Last of Us
      Agree, it's shit
      >Tetris (all versions)
      Disagree, most moronic of all the hot takes. Genre defining and hobby defining.
      >Smash Bros Franchise
      Disagree, it's good.
      >Kingdom Hearts
      Disagree, it's good.
      >Lemmings 2
      No idea
      >Fifa
      Agree, it's shit.
      >Wii Fit
      Disagree, this never got that much hype
      >Gran Turismo 7
      No idea, but there are a lot of great racing games out there.

      Frick off, no one cares if you have no idea about something and "genre defining" and "groundbreaking" doesn't mean it isn't overrated. They spawned overrated trash genres and trends.

  32. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    if everyone owns a title and it's very, very good compared to the average of the genre, it isn't overrated.

    witcher 3 cant be overrated when skyrim exists. skyrim is the game everyone knows because it was rereleased 17 times.

    skyward sward isn't underrated at all, no one talks about it. now breath of the wind is overrated. it put zelda in an open world, big woop. then 6 years later it was rereleased as totk with a garrys mod gimmick. beyond overrated.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      There's plenty of hate for skyrim, you don't have to look far. Meanwhile Witcher 3 is praised as gods gift from the heavens, like obviously Witcher 3 is the overrated one there

      • 6 months ago
        Anonymous

        >There's plenty of hate for skyrim,
        Yes but unlike hate for most of the other games on the list hate for Skyrim is almost always met with immense amounts of vitriol and insistence that your opinion isn't genuine as if it's impossible to not like Skyrim.
        And the thing that makes it so overrated is that this is the case despite the fact that Skyrim is strictly worse than a game in the same series made over a decade prior, and that game was already an overrated one.

        • 6 months ago
          Anonymous

          >hate for Skyrim is almost always met with immense amounts of vitriol and insistence that your opinion isn't genuine as if it's impossible to not like Skyrim.
          I don't see it. Skyrim is like bioshock infinite where yeah it got a lot of praise on release, but the tides quickly turned and the common opinion is that it's kind of mediocre.

          • 6 months ago
            Anonymous

            >I don't see it.
            Because you don't interact with anyone outside of Ganker.

  33. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >these games we overrated ourselves are overrated
    Now that's some peak irony.

  34. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Lemmings 2

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      At least half of this list feels like it was randomly generated

  35. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Mario Kart 64
    >overrated

    Literally the only game in the series with proper feeling of speed and allowed to have actual casual filters.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      It is shit though. DKR mogs it into oblivion.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      It's shit, F-Zero X mogs it. Diddy Kong Racing has a argument for being the GREATEST racing game of all time

  36. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >DMC 2
    >overrated
    By who? It is the most hated game in the series by everyone who has played the series. (I don't count Donte)

  37. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >only one Zelda game
    this author is not a serious person.

  38. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >no dark souls or bloodborne
    shit list

  39. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    This list is so contrarian, I almost mistook it for Ganker's shit taste.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      >Contrarian
      No Shadow of the Colossus
      No Ocarina of Time
      No Chrono Trigger
      No Planescape Torment
      No Metal Gear Solid 2
      No Deus Ex
      No Souls games
      No Resident Evil 4
      No Silent Hill at all
      No Fatal Frame
      No Castlevania games
      No Metroid games
      No SoulCalibur or Street Fighter
      It lacks any relevant game that people care about

      Yet you trannies claim it's contrarian. Pretty moronic statement homosexual

  40. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Pretty good...Except
    Goldeneye
    Bioshock
    Uncharted 2
    Tetris
    Those are actually very good

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      Nobody likes Tetris, it's a time waster they get because it's mindless. You fricking moron, it has no business being claimed as "Le heckin profound art" or being the best game of all time like everyone rates it as

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      >GoldenEye
      Overrated piece of shit that's mogged into oblivion by Perfect Dark, which never gets any credit
      >Bioshock
      Worse than System Shock 1 and 2 in every way, only praised for the meme twist. Worse than Nu-Prey as well, Signalis is also far better
      >Uncharted 2
      Worse than any of the PS1 Tomb Raider games, nothing but poorly designed cover shooting and walking segments
      >Tetris
      Meme game, no different than pong or Angry Birds

      • 6 months ago
        Anonymous

        Perfect Dark had some of the worst level designs in gaming history

        • 6 months ago
          Anonymous

          moronic tendie

  41. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >"journos BAD!"
    >"journos criticizing the choices of journos GOOD!"

    Kill everyone itt

  42. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    No Baldur's Gate 3?

  43. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Most overrated.
    >Gears 4.
    >DMC2.
    >Halo 4
    This is taking a piss, a lot of these games on the list either are universally pan'd or literal WHO PLAYED THIS shit, only a few are there that shouldnt be but also should be.

    I mean Pokemon Legends, really? IT was loved?

  44. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Clever. There's something on here to piss off basically anyone. I wonder how many morons right here on Ganker will give them a click.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      They were right on every choice other than SS which should be BOTW

      • 6 months ago
        Anonymous

        Okay moron.

      • 6 months ago
        Anonymous

        >They were right on every choice
        >Flappy Bird, POP Forgotten Sands, Lemings 2, DMC 2, etc.

        • 6 months ago
          Anonymous

          Don't forget how much people hype up Wii Fit!

        • 6 months ago
          Anonymous

          >t also garnered positive reception and was a commercial success; as of March 2022, it is the seventh best-selling game on the Wii, with a total of 21.13 million copies sold. Wii Fit has sold a combined total of 43.8 million copies, making the game one of the best-selling video games of all time.

  45. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >game "journalist"
    Oh! right.

  46. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Kingdom Hearts
    >Not Kingdom Hearts 2
    Weird choice. Would have been wrong either way, but 2 absolutely gets a shit ton more praise. (Kh1 is the most comfykino game to ever exist btw)

  47. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Overrated =/= bad

  48. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Witcher 3
    >new vegas
    Both of these are 100% true. As for the rest, agree on some/disagree/properly rated/haven't played.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      >Both of these are 100% true. As for the rest, agree on some/disagree/properly rated/haven't played.
      NO! Troon Vegas is troony game

  49. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    I'm sure that whatever ''games'' they like are totally cool and unique.

  50. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >W3
    Kinda, it's good in the sense everything else in the genre (AAA WRPG) is bad
    >NV
    100%, game has everything bad about FO3 and then some. Bugs out the ass, gayass millenial writing for companions. Being able to RP as a slaver/rich man's simp doesn't salvage it
    >HL2
    Absolutely, hyped new shiny tech on release but the actual gameplay isn't that great.
    >GTA4
    Overrated by journos on realese not the majority opinion but yes.
    >Fortnite
    Idk I'm not 12.
    >GH
    Party game so who gives a shit. Fair rating is how drunk you are and who you play with.
    >SA2
    Which SA? There's a dozen games with that acronym.
    >Infinite
    WAIT A MINUTE THAT CARD
    >CoD
    Nah the original was fairly rated.
    >Dead Island
    Wat. Game got 8s all around only thing rated highly is the trailer.

    All in all top 10 isn't bad, especially for journos.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      SA2 = Sonic

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      >Being able to RP as a slaver/rich man's simp doesn't salvage it
      Funny thing, you were able to be a real slaver in F3. Even enslave little girl. No such thing in FNV, only gay cosplayers.

  51. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >hype schlop to high heavens
    >later decide that said schlop was overrated
    WHOA, new kind of grift

  52. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    They're not talking about us, are they bros?

  53. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    So pretty much everything? Journalists proving once a again they're fricking morons. The list should actually consist of every asscreed, every R* game ever made and every playstation movie game.

  54. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Oblivion but no Skyrim
    They're literally the same game

  55. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Halo 4
    >DMC 2
    >MGS4
    >Gran Turismo 7
    Huh?

  56. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >gear 4
    >overrated
    how pretty much everyone wasn't very fond of it and the same more or less applies to 5 also,this whole list feels like someone just picked a list of popular games even more considering games like tekken 8 aren't even out yet

  57. 6 months ago
    Anonymous
    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      All of those games are terrible and or mediocre so they got it right. But they are schizophrenic with their picks. No Red Dead Redemption 2, no Last of Us 2, No Breath of the Wild for some reason. Skyrim is absent

  58. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    A half of these are just picking random names. Gears 4 and Halo 4 overrated? Max Payne 3 and not 2? DMC2 and not 5? I don't get it, although the other half are overrated.

  59. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    almost everything made by nintendo

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      >Nintendo gay mad that people like actually good games not made by Nintendo
      Lmao

      Looks like the sony sisters are done watching the feel good game of the century.

  60. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Skyward Sword
    it was highly divisive though
    >DMC2
    you fricking what? It's the most hated game in the series next to the reboot.
    >Tekken 8
    It's not even out yet!

  61. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Not gonna go through the whole list because a lot of them are just truly overrated games, but I would like to say most of them are also critical darlings so this list is "journalists" saying "these games we totally overhyped to hell and back are really not as good as we desperately tried to convince you they were guise!" which is hilarious
    >Witcher 3
    Agreed, but putting it here and not Skyrim should be a capital offense
    >New Vegas
    Other way around, "journalists" underrated the frick out of the game because they unironically thought Fallout 3 was a masterpiece and that New Vegas was just "more of the same"
    >Half Life 2
    Kind of agree, but most people hype it because of how revolutionary it was in terms of technology, not actual gameplay, which makes it less overrated than people make it out to be. If it was truly overrated you'd see people defending the airboat shit and nobody does that
    >Cuphead
    this is just a contrarian pick
    >Halo 4
    >Skyward Sword
    Does anyone even like these games let alone rate them highly? I see nothing but people shitting on Halo 4/SS everywhere I go or at the most saying "it's not *that* bad!"
    >Max Payne 3
    I haven't met a single human being who wasn't majorly disappointed by this game.
    >Candy Crush
    >Angry Birds
    >Pkmn GO
    If mobileshit counts then this list should just be the top 100 mobile games list.
    >La noire
    This is another game i see people constantly shit on, it only ever gets praise for things it objectively did well like facial expressions and the historical accuracy of the map or things like that. Everyone shits on every other aspect of it from what I see.
    >Oblivion
    How does someone with a functional brain put this on the list but not Skyrim? What the frick am I reading?
    >Pokemon Gen 1
    Contrarian opinion
    >DMC 2
    lmao what, is this a joke entry? There isn't a single soul that likes DMC2, it's so fricking bad that even the hardest DMC fan will admit that Donte's Infornication is better than it and that game is shit and insulting.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      https://i.imgur.com/GlaZukW.jpg

      Their list starts with Witcher 3
      Witcher 3
      New Vegas
      Half Life 2
      GTA4
      Fortnite
      Guitar Hero
      SA2
      Bioshock Infinite
      Call of Duty
      Dead Island
      Cuphead
      Nu-God of War
      Gears 4
      MK 2011
      LBP
      AC4 Black Flag
      Inside
      FF7
      COD Black Ops
      Skyward Sword
      Carmageddon
      Halo 4
      Borderlands
      Max Payne 3
      Candy Crush
      Mario Galaxy
      GTA San Andreas
      La noire
      Slenderman
      Pokemon Go
      Overwatch
      Sims
      Ace Attorney
      Angry Birds
      FNAF
      WOW
      Among Us
      Minecraft
      Oblivion
      Pokemon Gen 1
      Timesplitters
      DMC 2
      Tomb Raider 1996
      Bully
      Crazy Taxi
      Goldeneye
      Battlefront (original)
      DK64
      Pitfall
      POP Forgotten Sands
      Bioshock
      Portal (2007)
      Fallout 3
      Uncharted 2
      Tekken 8
      Mario Kart 64
      MGS4
      Pokemon Legends
      Flappy Bird
      Horizon Zero Dawn
      RE7
      The Last of Us
      Tetris (all versions)
      Smash Bros Franchise
      Kingdom Hearts
      Lemmings 2
      Fifa
      Wii Fit
      Gran Turismo 7

      >Bully
      I have no strong opinion about this but is there a single other game with the same premise? I don't know of any; it's hard to be overrated if there's nothing else to compare it to.
      >Goldeneye
      While this definitely belongs here it's disingenuous to put it on here but not Perfect Dark.
      >Battlefront (original)
      Other way around, almost everyone says Battlefront 2 is strictly better but Battlefront 1 had some god tier map design.
      >Tekken 8
      I haven't heard a single soul talk about Tekken 8
      >Mario Kart 64
      Agreed, later entries are better, CTR and even Diddy Kong Racing blew it out of the water and I enjoyed Super Mario Kart more.
      >MGS4
      Another game everyone shits on. At most I see people praise the final boss fight and some of the cool tech stuff, just like HL2.
      >Horizon Zero Dawn
      Nobody gives a shit about Horizon besides Snoys pretending to because their consoles have no games.
      >The Last of Us
      I'm honestly surprised this made it on here, but again it's another case of "why is this here and not the worse sequel?" Still the most deserving game on the list.
      >Tetris (all versions)
      Never been a better block stacking puzzle game so I'm inclined to disagree.
      >Lemmings 2
      wat

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      >Other way around, "journalists" underrated the frick out of the game because they unironically thought Fallout 3 was a masterpiece and that New Vegas was just "more of the same"
      They would be right but Chad Vegas is kino Shit Vegas is troony

  62. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    breath of the wild is the most overrated game ever

  63. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Game "Journalists"

  64. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Nintendo gay mad that people like actually good games not made by Nintendo
    Lmao

  65. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >google list of top video games of all time
    >rename to Most Overrated
    >farm clicks
    >repost on Ganker
    >farm (you's)

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      >These pieces of shit
      >Best games of all time

  66. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Oh boy I never tire of hearing what people dont like.

  67. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >no BoTW
    I liked the game but it's not the masterpiece journalists like to sell it as, although I'd argue ToTK is the more glaring ommission, since it's just an asset flip sequel which despite improving in some areas (bosses being the most notable of them imo) still carries over a lot of the previous entry's issues (such as copypasted content) and also somehow manages to make some things worse (the Fuse mechanic, worse menuing and the moronic story come to mind)

  68. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >games I hate
    based
    >games I like
    cringe

    Overall some weird choices, at least here DMC2 was bashed heavily on release and never really grew on people.

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      DMC2 is one of the most hated games of all time. I could see it being a dark horse pick on a "most underrated games of all time list" just by sheer virtue of how much visceral hate it gets from everyone. It's become one of those games that's hip to hate on without even playing and hyped up as one of the worst things to ever exist. Which isn't incorrect in this case, but damn people won't shut up about how bad it is.
      I think whoever put it on this list must have meant DMC3 and just put the wrong number because they'd never played a DMC game in their life and couldn't tell them apart. Or they meant DMC5 and thought it was DMC2 because they only know about DmC and DMC5

  69. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Witcher 3
    >Overrated
    take this shitty list and shove it

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      Witcher 3 is extremely overrated, the combat was hot ass even for it's time.

      • 6 months ago
        Anonymous

        It's not as good as DS combat but it's not bad

        • 6 months ago
          Anonymous

          >it's not as good as mediocre combat but it's not bad
          We have a word for something that's worse than mediocre anon: bad.

          • 6 months ago
            Anonymous

            DS combat is good

  70. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Where Zelda?

  71. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Red Dead Redemption 2. Woke boring sluggish trash with shit controls and game play.

  72. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Tomb Raider 1996
    FILTERED

  73. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Honestly that is a pretty good list of overrated shit.

  74. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >no titanfall 2
    game journos slopping it up again

  75. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Skyrim isn't even on the list
    All I needed to see. Naturally, the game with "put the square peg in the square hole" tier puzzles is a masterpiece to your average game journalist.

  76. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Skyward Sword
    >not OOT, BOTW, or TOTK
    >no Persona 5

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      OOT is a masterpiece that defined video games, just like Beethoven defined classical music.

  77. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >list every popular game ever released
    >call them overrated
    "journalism"

  78. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Most overrated video games chosen by a "literally: who?" website trying to drum up outrage traffic by picking popular games the author doesn't like

    OP, by posting this here you are part of the problem, you are giving them publicity, which is the only reason they wrote this trash article

  79. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >New Vegas
    >but also Fortnite
    >and Minecraft
    Rage bait

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      Also
      >fricking Tetris
      Bait, definitely

    • 6 months ago
      Anonymous

      No it is true bait!
      Shit Vegas is trash

  80. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Transenliste

  81. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >no zelda shit listed

  82. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Looks about right

  83. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Some of these little wiener suckers "journalists" weren't even born when some of those game were made.
    You have to rate a game relatively to it's own era first. What a fricking joke.

  84. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Tetris (all versions)
    This is what exposes the bait.
    If they specifically said just the original Game Boy version was overrated then that would actually be something I'd agree on, there's quite a few other puzzle games and other versions of Tetris that outclass the GB version despite it being the most popular.

  85. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Which "Game Journalists"? Be more specific. Plus I have never even heard of a website called "gosocial.co" which leads me to believe it's probably some AI generated shit or something.

  86. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    BotW
    TotK
    GTA
    RDR
    Last of Us
    Undertale
    Hades
    Oblivion
    CoD
    Fortnite
    Divinity
    Control
    Outer Wilds
    Subnautica
    Don't Starve
    Hollow Knight
    Persona

    Off the top of my head a lot of these are barebones as frick or so shallow it's like wandering around a desert. Others have core gameplay issues like persona literally being rock paper scissors: the game series or hollow knight being everything wrong with indie games in general. Some are just insufferable like divinity or tlou

  87. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Not a SINGLE Zelda title, including the defacto most overrated game of all time OoT
    >Not a single Dark Souls or FROMsoft game either
    >Games no one really praises like Halo 4, Wii Fit, and Pokemon GO here
    >Has fricking Pitfall, a game almost no one younger than 30 knows about
    What the frick is this list? Do Journos not fricking know what "overrated" means?

  88. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    List made by an obvious Zelda gay.

    They included an obligatory entry that no one likes in the first place.

  89. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    If Witcher 3, one of the best singleplayer RPGs ever is overrated, I wonder whats not overrated then since none of the rpgs since W3 hold a candle to it even 8 years later

  90. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Timesplitters
    That's it, they've crossed the line. I'm going to make a twitter account just to tell every games journalist to kill themselves.

  91. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Caring about clickbait.

  92. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    i really dont give a shit which games they think are overrated
    if anything that just means theyre better games than they would want to admit
    i can already see a bunch of entries on that lists that are vastly better than much of the ridiculous shit that gets released today
    they are just hatin because those games arent as political as they are now or some shit

  93. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Where the frick is Zelda?

  94. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >New vegas, cuphead, crazy taxi
    moron

  95. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Witcher 3
    >Half Life 2
    >GTA4
    >Fortnite
    >Guitar Hero
    >SA2
    >Bioshock Infinite
    >Call of Duty
    >Dead Island
    >Cuphead
    >Nu-God of War
    >Gears 4
    >MK 2011
    >LBP
    >AC4 Black Flag
    >Inside
    >FF7
    >COD Black Ops
    >Skyward Sword
    >Halo 4
    >Borderlands
    >Max Payne 3
    >Candy Crush
    >Mario Galaxy
    >GTA San Andreas
    >La noire
    >Slenderman
    >Pokemon Go
    >Overwatch
    >Ace Attorney
    >Angry Birds
    >FNAF
    >WOW
    >Among Us
    >Minecraft
    >Oblivion
    >Pokemon Gen 1
    >Timesplitters
    >DMC 2
    >Tomb Raider 1996
    >Bully
    >Crazy Taxi
    >Goldeneye
    >Battlefront (original)
    >DK64
    >Pitfall
    >POP Forgotten Sands
    >Bioshock
    >Fallout 3
    >Uncharted 2
    >Tekken 8
    >Mario Kart 64
    >MGS4
    >Pokemon Legends
    >Flappy Bird
    >Horizon Zero Dawn
    >RE7
    >The Last of Us
    >Tetris (all versions)
    >Smash Bros Franchise
    >Kingdom Hearts
    >Fifa
    >Wii Fit
    >Gran Turismo 7
    to be fair all of these are correct
    casualgay normie cashgrab shit, none of these are above a 6/10

  96. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Carmageddon
    >Crazy Taxi
    >Lemmings 2
    >MGS4
    Who in the frick is taking about these games so much that they had to be labeled overrated?

  97. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Interesting how you can make a list of popular games this big and yet I wouldn't call any of them my favorite.

  98. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    I started writing arguments but honestly this is a moron list for morons by morons and I can't be bothered.

  99. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Some of these are based but some are moronic beyond belief
    >timesplitters
    In what fricking galaxy???

  100. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >chosen by game journalists
    stopped reading there

  101. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >google best video games list
    >copy and retitle to 'most overrated'
    >post in hopes to generate ad revenue

  102. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    WHERE THE FRICK IS
    OCARINA
    OF
    TIME

  103. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Why do journalists love Nintendo so much

  104. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Exclusively in spheres of the internet where users are likely to watch video essays, New Vegas absolutely is the most overrated game of all time and it's not remotely close.

  105. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    low effort

  106. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    I think when it comes to being overrated, Persona 5 takes the cake over FFVII. For all the praise, the high review scores you don't really feel the love that it gets from its fans, compared to VII. The cast of VII easily beats P5s all day, everyday. Story, themes, music. The only thing that P5 does better is balance/game mechanics. But let's not pretend it's a big brained, hyper strategized gameplay. It's literally spamming enemy weakness and party attacks. The boss is a bit harder, but you'll just weave in buff/debuffs in between turns.

  107. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    How is L.A. Noire overrated?

  108. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Lemmings 2
    What the frick am I reading?

  109. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >No Ocarina of Time
    >But instead Tomb Raider (1996) the game everybody whines about tank controls

    ...lol, journos seriously have zero self awareness and should kill themselves

  110. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    I was ok with this until Battlefront (original)
    Kill yo'self

  111. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    Most of them are right, but some are objectively wrong. such as:

    >Guitar Hero
    the game is fun, its praise and historical value is deserved.

    >Call of Duty
    the franchise or the original game? CoD 1 isn't overrated, the franchise, yes, maybe, but definitely not the first game.

    >Carmageddon
    no one talks or remembers it. The original games are good fun, the only overrated thing about them is all the stupid ~~*muh violence*~~ criticism it got.

    >(Super) Mario Galaxy
    definitely not overrated, the series is great and they are some of the best 3D Mario games and some of the best games on the Wii, how could this be overrated? They deserve the praise.

    >Prince of Persia Forgotten Sands
    I never seen anyone even praise or remember those games (the entire PoP franchise) letalone consider them overrated, Assassins Creed, maybe? Yes, definitely overrated, but not Prince of Persia. Maybe within the context of the franchise, I can agree, but not as a game as a whole.

    >Portal
    Portal is a great game and it's execution is almost flawless. It deserves the praise it gets.

    >Tekken 8
    yeah, so far yes, but the game hasn't even been released. All betas get a disproportionate amount of attention from their respective fanbases because that is the point of them. To get seen and discussed about in time to make changes for the final release.

    >Tetris
    what? Tetris fits in the same realm of Portal, it's gameplay is great and it's execution is short of flawless. What else negative can be said about it? It's a good game and stood the test of time.

  112. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    anything people like is overrated i guess

  113. 6 months ago
    Anonymous

    >no breath of the wild
    I have no clue who these guys are, but they are moronic. Botw is by far the most overrated game ever made.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *