Witcher 3 is legit an awful Game, and even the strongest part of the "Game", the story, is mediocre at best. How it won GotY, in a year that gave us Bloodborne no less, is still mindblowing to me.
yeah for real i don't know, i am just playing through the W3 and gonna finish Blood and Wine today and most of the quests are okay but nothing incredible i am not sure where the W3 is the gold standard for quests came from.
yeah for real i don't know, i am just playing through the W3 and gonna finish Blood and Wine today and most of the quests are okay but nothing incredible i am not sure where the W3 is the gold standard for quests came from.
>How w3 won goty and not bb
Because w3 played by so many people because it's targeted audience were normies, only 3 people played bb and you can't just give goty to a art game
This except I never played Breasts of the Wild and Skyrim is only good modded but Zelda is better than Witcher just because of Zelda's cartoonishly large ass.
Are a new framework of what games can be, but within that arent great: >BotW >Skyrim
Are a good execution of an honestly outdated formula >Elden Ring >Witcher
might as well add RDR2 to this
never played nintendo game and never will frick them fomo for consolists
Skyrim as much as has usually worse quests than W3 atleast has much more better made world and immersiveness going for it.
Elden Ring is kino genuinely one of the few open world games that don't bore me or tire me out unlike W3.
I never played BOTW so I'll replace it with TOTK.
TOTK > Witcher 3 > Skyrim > Elden Ring
Elden Ring shouldn't have been open world. All it does is pad the game length
this but with TiktoK nu zeldas shouldn't have chased the zoomie audience and make the open world zelda meme real plus its just fricking DLC, ER managed to squeeze quantity and quality bigger than any nintendo game in a decade with the same amount of time TotK was worked on, let that sink in.
Black person elden ring is the most braindead simple ass game ever made. You never have to change your strategy to fight any of the bosses because everything is one size fits all. You can't travel freely because the only places you can walk are the hallways the devs made (even if they don't look like hallways). You can't even frick around in the game because there's nothing to do but dodge roll out of the way of attacks and then hit enemies.
I'm not saying the souls formula doesn't work but it's much better in a smaller game
>the most braindead simple ass game ever made
that fits new zeldas imho >You never have to change your strategy to fight any of the bosses because everything is one size fits all
incorrect >You can't travel freely because the only places you can walk are the hallways the devs made (even if they don't look like hallways)
you can travel wherever you want, you have secret alternative passages in certain dungeons or locations overall and i will rather take handcrafted paths rather than something like modern Zeldas where you literally just skip the fricking content by flying over it lmao
Skyrim is a really fun open world game with lots to explore and to do. You can pickpocket npcs clothes and smith your oiwn weapons now. The best RPG on the list.
Elden Ring has the best combat and is a fun action game, but not really RPG. It's also a fashion simulator.
Zelda has fun exploration, a very detailed world and physic puzzles, but is too easy and you can't kill NPCs.
Witcher 3 is Netflix trash goyslop with poor weapons and no helmets.
Put down the drugs.
In Skyrim you can be a warrior, a mage, a spellsword, a rogue, a stealth archer, etc.
Moreover you have to actually Play those Roles to increase your skill.
Ironic post considering Skyrim is a game that feels much closer to its predecessors, while Elden Ring and BOTW are bastardizations of the series' former values (especially the latter) made in order to sell as many copies to normies a as possible
It depends.
Elden Ring has definitively the better combat. You can't deny that. But Skyrim is more interesting to explore with quests and NPCs and side activities like pickpocketing and a more interesting, less empty world.
If you want a good combat game, Elden Ring is better.
If you want an immersive game, Skyrim is the choice.
Every one of those is just a goyslop version of its franchise. lowest common denominator designed shit made to sell as many copies as possible instead of simply trying to be a good game.
Only morons can think that Skyrim and Witcher are good (adding RDR2 too). No shit gaming is in this state nowdays. Zelda and ER at least were able to change the shitty oper world formula. Western garbage will always be inferior to real games made by japanese
All pretty good but Witcher 3 is still the best and one that the rest of the industry can't reach no matter how hard they try. Elden Ring has an interesting world but is rivaled by the likes of Xenoblade. BotW got devalued by its own sequel. Skyrim is finally outdated in 2023.
The only game I beat is Elden Ring.
Skyrim bored me after 50 hours. Zelda after 20 hours. Never played Witcher 3.
So for me Elden Ring > Skyrim > Zelda > Witcher 3, I guess?
>Skyrim mod-ability >Witcher quest design storytelling >BOTW/TOTK World interactivity >ER combat design
why does every one of them shit the bed at what each other game does individually right?
Skyrim directly influenced Witcher 3 and Zelda so even if those two games surpass it in certain aspects it's only because of the developers playing Skyrim and picking and choosing mechanics from it. Elden Slop is just dark souls 1 reskinned for the tenth time except now the monsters are 1000 steps apart instead of 100
>The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
9/10, Peak kino at it's time, major influence on gaming culture and development, great modding sandbox, comfy and fun. It has aged a lot nowadays. >The Witcher III - Wild Hunt
10/10, The greatest vidya of all time. Not much else to say. >The Legend of Zelda - Breath of the Wild
7/10, I don't see what's interesting about it, I emulated it and quit it after 15 hours since it was not appealing. >Elden Ring
8.5/10, Another fromsoftware classic, very fun gameplay and atmosphere, lacking in story/dialogue/characters. Nothing genre defining.
Skyrim > Witcher > Zelda >Elden Ring
Skyrim has more replay ability than the Witcher with better modding and roleplay potential. The size of the world makes it timeless.
The Witcher 3 is the worst in the Witcher trilogy. It has good DLC content and thematically is a very fun game. Monster hunting and doing sidequests are great but the MSQ is really uninspired and the game is drawn out for far too long. The open world is largely empty. Sexy women
Zelda is innovative but the Switch limitations make it a weaker open world than the other two. It has some mechanical and grind shortcomings but a decent game
Elden Ring is uninspired and derivative. The open world is better at environmental storytelling than the Witcher but almost completely hollow. From has been milking the same formula of le grimdark gothic medieval boss rush for too long and I am not a fan
I cannot comprehend how someone can legitimately think Skyrim is a bad game. I understand preferring Morrowind or Oblivion, those games did some things better than Skyrim, but Skyrim is unquestionably a good game
its a good but dissapointing game coming from Oblivion into Skyrim so much cut content and underutlized ideas not to mention even bigger casualization of the series.
I've only played Skyrim and BotW. Weapons breaking in 5 hits and having the stamina bar of a chain smoker aren't fun for me so I'll say Skyrim is better.
3>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>BotW >Elden Ring
Most diverse combat among souls series, has the most consistent boss quality and otherwise is the most polished Souls game when you take into the account it's size. Did frick up few things like double boss battles and they should have cut map size by 15-20% to remove some padding like repeating catacombs. >Skyrim
Even with all the Bethesda jank and simplifications it's still a good game but needs mods to fix half of the shit. >Witcher 3
It's like the western open world RPG but boring, the main interesting thing about it was Slavic medieval setting for a time, most of the things are forgettable/meh. >BotW
Few steps forwards and a 666km run backwards. Literally took everything good about Zelda and trashed it. It used to stand out among open world games because your progression was meaningful, unlocks meant shit and were not just side grades +1 fire damage and dungeons were different even with repeating themes from game to game.
I've played them all with exception of BoTW, they are all good in their respective way, skyrim has the best exploration, they witcher has some of the most interesting quests and stories and elder ring has uhhhhhhh the fashion I guess.
skyrim was the best. unmodded vanilla skyrim. a perfect video game. everything else is trying to be it, THey are fun but they arent the source material.
The ones I like > the ones you like
But I like the ones you like
Elden Ring>Skyrim>>>>>ToK>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
3
Witcher 3 is legit an awful Game, and even the strongest part of the "Game", the story, is mediocre at best. How it won GotY, in a year that gave us Bloodborne no less, is still mindblowing to me.
yeah for real i don't know, i am just playing through the W3 and gonna finish Blood and Wine today and most of the quests are okay but nothing incredible i am not sure where the W3 is the gold standard for quests came from.
>witcher 3
no replayability, no replay value on witcher 3.
>ToK
Not even on the list idiot.
>How w3 won goty and not bb
Because w3 played by so many people because it's targeted audience were normies, only 3 people played bb and you can't just give goty to a art game
This except I never played Breasts of the Wild and Skyrim is only good modded but Zelda is better than Witcher just because of Zelda's cartoonishly large ass.
Are a new framework of what games can be, but within that arent great:
>BotW
>Skyrim
Are a good execution of an honestly outdated formula
>Elden Ring
>Witcher
might as well add RDR2 to this
>might as well add RDR2 to this
RDR2 pioneered the chore simulator genre.
W3>ER>Skyrim>Zelda
Elden Ring > Skyrim > Witcher 3 > nu Zeldas
never played nintendo game and never will frick them fomo for consolists
Skyrim as much as has usually worse quests than W3 atleast has much more better made world and immersiveness going for it.
Elden Ring is kino genuinely one of the few open world games that don't bore me or tire me out unlike W3.
ER>Skyrim>W3>Zelda
Disclosure: I only played like 10 mins of BotW and it was the only Zelda I played since MM.
I never played BOTW so I'll replace it with TOTK.
TOTK > Witcher 3 > Skyrim > Elden Ring
Elden Ring shouldn't have been open world. All it does is pad the game length
this but with TiktoK nu zeldas shouldn't have chased the zoomie audience and make the open world zelda meme real plus its just fricking DLC, ER managed to squeeze quantity and quality bigger than any nintendo game in a decade with the same amount of time TotK was worked on, let that sink in.
Black person elden ring is the most braindead simple ass game ever made. You never have to change your strategy to fight any of the bosses because everything is one size fits all. You can't travel freely because the only places you can walk are the hallways the devs made (even if they don't look like hallways). You can't even frick around in the game because there's nothing to do but dodge roll out of the way of attacks and then hit enemies.
I'm not saying the souls formula doesn't work but it's much better in a smaller game
>the most braindead simple ass game ever made
that fits new zeldas imho
>You never have to change your strategy to fight any of the bosses because everything is one size fits all
incorrect
>You can't travel freely because the only places you can walk are the hallways the devs made (even if they don't look like hallways)
you can travel wherever you want, you have secret alternative passages in certain dungeons or locations overall and i will rather take handcrafted paths rather than something like modern Zeldas where you literally just skip the fricking content by flying over it lmao
lol the only way i can honestly see someone enjoying TotK is if they never played BotW
1. Skyrim
2. Elden Ring
3. Zelda
4. Powergap
5. Witcherslop
Skyrim is a really fun open world game with lots to explore and to do. You can pickpocket npcs clothes and smith your oiwn weapons now. The best RPG on the list.
Elden Ring has the best combat and is a fun action game, but not really RPG. It's also a fashion simulator.
Zelda has fun exploration, a very detailed world and physic puzzles, but is too easy and you can't kill NPCs.
Witcher 3 is Netflix trash goyslop with poor weapons and no helmets.
>The best RPG on the list.
>game has no player choice what so ever
Put down the drugs.
In Skyrim you can be a warrior, a mage, a spellsword, a rogue, a stealth archer, etc.
Moreover you have to actually Play those Roles to increase your skill.
>level up boring skill tree to do 20% more damage
damn that’s some in depth roleplaying right there
>getting better from doing the thing
Unitonically, it is far more in depth than every other RPG.
get perk mods, you low IQ console peasant
>bro just fix the game yourself
how bout no homosexual
Yeah because in rpgs leveling up your competency with weapons doesn't give you a percentage damage bonus
tell me you dont care about videogames and only care about shitposting without straight-up telling me
1. Skyrim
2. Witcher 3
3. Reddit Ring
4. Breath of Slop
these are the most lowest common denominator posts in this thread
The Fromshill has exposed itself
Ironic post considering Skyrim is a game that feels much closer to its predecessors, while Elden Ring and BOTW are bastardizations of the series' former values (especially the latter) made in order to sell as many copies to normies a as possible
I can't take anyone seriously who actually thinks Skyrim deserves a place at the top.
It depends.
Elden Ring has definitively the better combat. You can't deny that. But Skyrim is more interesting to explore with quests and NPCs and side activities like pickpocketing and a more interesting, less empty world.
If you want a good combat game, Elden Ring is better.
If you want an immersive game, Skyrim is the choice.
>I can't take anyone seriously who actually thinks Elden Ring deserves a place at the top.
FTFY
Every one of those is just a goyslop version of its franchise. lowest common denominator designed shit made to sell as many copies as possible instead of simply trying to be a good game.
Skyrim is the only good game there
Only good post ITT
Elden Ring >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> The Witcher 3 >>>>>>> Blood in my stool > Skyrim >>> Getting AIDS >> TOTK
correct
Only morons can think that Skyrim and Witcher are good (adding RDR2 too). No shit gaming is in this state nowdays. Zelda and ER at least were able to change the shitty oper world formula. Western garbage will always be inferior to real games made by japanese
All pretty good but Witcher 3 is still the best and one that the rest of the industry can't reach no matter how hard they try. Elden Ring has an interesting world but is rivaled by the likes of Xenoblade. BotW got devalued by its own sequel. Skyrim is finally outdated in 2023.
Kino: Skyrim, TW3, BOTW
Goyslop: ER
>Bethesda and Nintendo shills still mindbroken
Dogshit | Meh, could be worse but still basically dogshit
Tied for second best Zelda and Adventure genre game of all time, with it's sequel | Dogshit
Not sure what the point of putting a Japanese action adventure game in with 3 western/westaboo action RPGs was but whatever.
BOTW - I love this game so much its unreal
Skyrim - Fun, but I prefer Oblivion
Witcher 3 - Its ok
Can't rank it:
Elden ring - never played it
The only game I beat is Elden Ring.
Skyrim bored me after 50 hours. Zelda after 20 hours. Never played Witcher 3.
So for me Elden Ring > Skyrim > Zelda > Witcher 3, I guess?
modded skyrim > Witcher 3 > zeldor > vanilla skyrim > Artificial Difficulty Ring
why? they have nothing in common, you just wanna start a pointless debate, homosexual
elden ring>zelda>>>
clunky slop
Zelda copied ubisoft
Skyrim>ToTK=elden shit>Witcher 3
Skyrim > ER > BOTW > W3
Modded Skyrim>Zelda>ER>Witcher>Vanilla Skyrim.
A: ER
B:
C:
Modding platform tier: Skyrim
D: Zeldalsop
F:
Dogshit tier:
Omega dogshit tier:
9 hours played on steam tier: Witcher 3
low IQ post
high IQ post
Elden Ring>>
>>>>>>>w3>>>>>>>>>>>botw
>Skyrim mod-ability
>Witcher quest design storytelling
>BOTW/TOTK World interactivity
>ER combat design
why does every one of them shit the bed at what each other game does individually right?
>ER combat design
>right
before giving a meme reply, name one of those other 3 that has better combat
>Witcher 3 storytelling
Elden Ring>TotK>Witcher 3>BotW>Skyrim
Skyrim directly influenced Witcher 3 and Zelda so even if those two games surpass it in certain aspects it's only because of the developers playing Skyrim and picking and choosing mechanics from it. Elden Slop is just dark souls 1 reskinned for the tenth time except now the monsters are 1000 steps apart instead of 100
Why didnt elden ring get cancelled for having gay pedo?
you can't judge a game for the player
>The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
9/10, Peak kino at it's time, major influence on gaming culture and development, great modding sandbox, comfy and fun. It has aged a lot nowadays.
>The Witcher III - Wild Hunt
10/10, The greatest vidya of all time. Not much else to say.
>The Legend of Zelda - Breath of the Wild
7/10, I don't see what's interesting about it, I emulated it and quit it after 15 hours since it was not appealing.
>Elden Ring
8.5/10, Another fromsoftware classic, very fun gameplay and atmosphere, lacking in story/dialogue/characters. Nothing genre defining.
>Elden Ring
>very fun gameplay
I hate the witcher but love all three
Skyrim
Elden Ring
BOTW
Shitcher 3 doesnt even belong among these games, it is actually terrible and wildly overrated.
1. Elden Ring
2. Zelda
3. Skyrim
4. Witcher 3
This is actually hard to rate because all these games are mediocre lingering between a 5 or 6 out of 10.
He posted it!!!
He posted the image!!!
Skyrim > Witcher > Zelda >Elden Ring
Skyrim has more replay ability than the Witcher with better modding and roleplay potential. The size of the world makes it timeless.
The Witcher 3 is the worst in the Witcher trilogy. It has good DLC content and thematically is a very fun game. Monster hunting and doing sidequests are great but the MSQ is really uninspired and the game is drawn out for far too long. The open world is largely empty. Sexy women
Zelda is innovative but the Switch limitations make it a weaker open world than the other two. It has some mechanical and grind shortcomings but a decent game
Elden Ring is uninspired and derivative. The open world is better at environmental storytelling than the Witcher but almost completely hollow. From has been milking the same formula of le grimdark gothic medieval boss rush for too long and I am not a fan
ER > everything else
>Linear corridors...le good when they are pretty
>Linear
A rope bridge and the gate of a castle are pretty linear yes. It's not like you can jump down and scale the cliff.
You need to jump off the cliff to progress tho...
AND THAT IS LINEAR
HA
BAITED
OH NO NO NO NO
ABSOLUTELY DDSTROYED
Why do you post Photoshopped screenshots
nice promotional renders gay
Skyrim>TW3>BOTW>>>>>>>>
Dogshit
This is the objectively correct ranking
why every post that has word objectively in it is always the most moronic in the whole thread
Fromdrone cope
you will never be a real woman discorder
unironic slop that only gets shilled by german millenials
Skyrim>botw>>>>>>>>
3>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
ring
I cannot comprehend how someone can legitimately think Skyrim is a bad game. I understand preferring Morrowind or Oblivion, those games did some things better than Skyrim, but Skyrim is unquestionably a good game
its a good but dissapointing game coming from Oblivion into Skyrim so much cut content and underutlized ideas not to mention even bigger casualization of the series.
I absolutely hated the amount of quests involving dwarven ruins/dungeons, I didn't care about the dragons or main quest line either.
game is okay but I stopped playing after 25 hours
questing sucks
combat sucks
all npcs are voiced by the same 3 people so world sucks
But enough about Elden Ring
I've only played Skyrim and BotW. Weapons breaking in 5 hits and having the stamina bar of a chain smoker aren't fun for me so I'll say Skyrim is better.
Elden Ring>Witcher
I've no plans to play the other 2
Haven't played them.
Elden Ring >= Skyrim >>> Witcher 3 >>> BotW
schlop
slop
slosh
slosch
They're all shit.
Tepid water > ER > BotW > Shit > Skyrim > W3
BotW > Eldin Ring >>> The Witcher III >>>>>>>>> Skyreddit
>Reddit Ring
>goyslop
>Skyrim is the only good game there
>Goyslop: ER
>The Fromshill has exposed itself
>Artificial Difficulty Ring
>elden shit
they seem to be all good in their own way.
Elden Ring>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
3>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>BotW
>Elden Ring
Most diverse combat among souls series, has the most consistent boss quality and otherwise is the most polished Souls game when you take into the account it's size. Did frick up few things like double boss battles and they should have cut map size by 15-20% to remove some padding like repeating catacombs.
>Skyrim
Even with all the Bethesda jank and simplifications it's still a good game but needs mods to fix half of the shit.
>Witcher 3
It's like the western open world RPG but boring, the main interesting thing about it was Slavic medieval setting for a time, most of the things are forgettable/meh.
>BotW
Few steps forwards and a 666km run backwards. Literally took everything good about Zelda and trashed it. It used to stand out among open world games because your progression was meaningful, unlocks meant shit and were not just side grades +1 fire damage and dungeons were different even with repeating themes from game to game.
I've played them all with exception of BoTW, they are all good in their respective way, skyrim has the best exploration, they witcher has some of the most interesting quests and stories and elder ring has uhhhhhhh the fashion I guess.
1: BOTW
2: Witcher III. (It's hard to put witcher in 2, but I enjoyed BOTW more).
3: Skyrim (it's actually just shit).
I've never had any interest in elden ring, and I've never played it, thus I cannot rate it.
Elden Ring>>>
3
>>>>>>>>>>>>>BOTW
skyrim was the best. unmodded vanilla skyrim. a perfect video game. everything else is trying to be it, THey are fun but they arent the source material.