Sinnoh Starters

Which Route is canon?

Schizophrenic Conspiracy Theorist Shirt $21.68

Homeless People Are Sexy Shirt $21.68

Schizophrenic Conspiracy Theorist Shirt $21.68

  1. 4 weeks ago


  2. 4 weeks ago

    piplup and barry always sticks out in my mind as canon but I'm convinced the mach 10 moron would choose the mach 10 moron chimp over the slow turtle or penguin

  3. 4 weeks ago

    Dawn has all three. The boys cry about it.

  4. 4 weeks ago

    Piplup and Dawn are the iconic duo, plus I picked Turtwig, so the middle one.

  5. 4 weeks ago

    Dawn and Piplup are iconic together. Chimchar is the only one that fits Barry's personality. Lucas gets Turtwig by process of elimination, but I think they go together well enough.

  6. 4 weeks ago

    Chimchar was tailor made for Barry's character.

    • 4 weeks ago

      >Chimchar was tailor made for Barry's character.
      He seems to get paired with Piplup more often than not, though.

  7. 4 weeks ago

    There is no canon starter. You morons don’t know what canon means.

  8. 4 weeks ago

    >Dawn and Barry both had Piplup in the anime just for Ash to have the other two.
    Privileged to be the main character.

  9. 4 weeks ago

    It makes the most sense for Dawn to Piplup and Barry to have Chimchar

  10. 4 weeks ago

    I play as the girl so in my mind Dawn gets Turtwig and Lucas gets Piplup

  11. 4 weeks ago


  12. 4 weeks ago

    A Piplup for each one.

  13. 4 weeks ago

    I personally choose turtwig but C feels most canon to me, infernape is just such a protagonist mon and empoleon just feels right with barry, that said there's good arguments for any of them

  14. 4 weeks ago

    none of these because i played as dawn and chose chimchar

    • 4 weeks ago

      So A then?

      • 4 weeks ago

        lucas is the protag in all the scenarios in the OP because barry has the starter with the type advantage against him

  15. 4 weeks ago

    B barry and infernape always seemed right

  16. 4 weeks ago
    Canon starters

    A friendly reminder that it's

    Red: Charmander
    Blue: Squirtle
    Green: Bulbasaur

    Gold: Cyndaquil
    Silver: Totodile
    Kris: Chikorita

    Brendan: Treecko
    May: Torchic

    Lucas: Turtwig
    Barry: Chimchar
    Dawn: Piplup

    Hilbert/Hilda: Oshawott
    Cheren: Snivy
    Bianca: Tepig

    • 4 weeks ago

      Red uses a Bulbasaur in LGPE, Generations and the manga.
      Blue uses Charmander in LGPE and the manga.
      Blue uses Bulbasaur in Evolutions.
      Green uses Squirtle in LGPE, manga, and Evolutions.
      Generations takes place in two different Gen 1 timelines - one where Red picks Bulbasaur.
      (Episode 1), and the one where he picks Charmander (Episode 3).
      Kris chooses Totodile in the anime and Masters EX.
      Brendan chooses Mudkip in the anime and manga.
      May chooses Mudkip in Masters EX.
      Lucas chooses Chimchar in Evolutions.
      Dawn chooses Turtwig in Masters EX.
      Barry chooses Piplup in the anime and Masters EX.
      Hilbert chooses Tepig in the manga.
      Hilda uses Tepig in Masters EX and temporarily in the manga. She uses Snivy in the manga.
      Bianca uses Oshawott in the manga.

  17. 4 weeks ago

    B. The only reason Barry gets paired with empoleon is because Ash cucked him out of chimchar in the anime. Infernape was made for his personality. Dawn and Piplup are iconic. Lucas and turtwig just feel right with each other

  18. 4 weeks ago

    Obviously the dp / bdsp opening
    >Lucas - Turtwig
    >Dawn - Chimchar
    >Barry - Piplup
    Ok but seriously the anime/manga totally fits the characters the best since Lucas is slow (slow game haha), Barry is fast and Piplup/ Impoleon just seems perfect for Dawn with contests and just the general color scheme

  19. 4 weeks ago

    B or C

  20. 4 weeks ago

    B, definitely. Chimchar's the only one that suits Barry and Piplup works best for Dawn.

  21. 4 weeks ago

    A is the most aesthetically pleasing, b is canon

  22. 4 weeks ago

    C, the fire starter us always the canon choice

  23. 4 weeks ago

    B, as in the manga and the anime (the MC gets Turtwig, the rival gets Chimchar and the female companion gets Piplup)
    Barry only gets Piplup in the anime because we need an Empoleon user and Dawn's doesn't evolve

  24. 4 weeks ago

    B of course

  25. 4 weeks ago

    2nd one
    infernape fits berry so much better then empoleon
    yet my game is the 1st one since i chose piplup as lucas

  26. 4 weeks ago

    none of these
    dawn piplup, lucas chimchar, barry turtwig
    i like lucas and barry having starters that balance out their mellowness and hyperactivity respectively, makes for a better character arc, needing to learn from the other's main trait in order to work better with their pokemon because they got them in a rush from the professor's bag
    and dawn is the protag

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *