>unfunny >boring >fricking degen weirdo >also has terrible taste in vidya
Color me surprised kek. I have no idea how his channel ever took off; been blocked from my recommendations for years.
Not even a big problem. I could see SV being bottom of the second tier in a list like this. As shitty as it runs, it’s already better than some of the other games, and we can safely bet on a lot of future content to round out the experience. Its average ranking will change over the next year or two, without question. Likely for the better. SWSH in A? PLA in S? Now that’s bullshit.
>crystal >not S tier
have a nice day my man
This is a true thought crime. Crystal is the pinnacle of GB Pokemon, and it’s not even close (unless you’re REALLY into glitch shenanigans / the goofy Gen 1 mechanics). HGSS didn’t even manage to completely replace GSC, and it’s considered the best of the remakes.
Literally playing so morons can frick off.
So far I don't see the fricking "OMG SO GOOD" anywhere yet. It is just tedious.
Surely battles might get harder later, but I am not amused.
You are correct but PLA is literally about living in a high-trust community with a strong culture, no israeli subversion, no israeli poison, healthy food and lots of physical exercise when hiking in nature, therefore it is based.
>mid-series games good >new games mid >old games outperformed
yeah that's expected, BDSP being shit tier is most definitely deserved for being a soulless adaptation at least
God, I hate those people.
They run through the same "new is bad" shit that older fans did while being completely unaware of it.
Just like Sonic Adventure / Dark Age fanboys
RBYG are failures as games that make Fallout 76 look like a well-designed game in comparison, and to say anything else is to be blinded by nostalgia or to be a zoomer contrarian.
Difference is RGBY were well recieved at release while Fallout 76 was poorly recieved. I know /vp/ hates Gen 1 mostly to be contrarian but this is embarrassing.
>I know /vp/ hates Gen 1 mostly to be contrarian but this is embarrassing.
Gen 1 has been replaced twiceover by FRLG and LGPE, there is no reason to play RGBY because they are broken, unfinished, buggy, poorly-designed games that don't even function as intended. I'm 30, I grew up with pokemania, I had all the us-released gameboy games and I STILL say that Gen 1 has no redeeming qualities in this day and age and in hindsight Pokemon should have been a flop.
OH NO NO NO NO NO DISCORDBROS??????? YOU TOLD ME ONLY REDDIT MAKES LISTS LIKE THAT?!? WE FRICKING LOST AGAIN, I CAN'T TAKE IT ANYMORE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
A single shitty filler aera, sprites with 2 frames of animation and some Johto shitmons is enough for Emerald to be considered way better than Ruby/Sapphire, the exact same game! Oh shit i missed something, they added the items sprites in the bag like in FR/LG... Sorry my bad!
Hell no. Pirate it if you feel like you need to try it. It’s a fairly divisive game and for good reason.
Alpharad's fricking stupid and his list reflects that >SV & SwSh in the same tier as HGSS and Platinum >USUM and Let's Go Pee above Crystal and Yellow
Checked the list on his twitter, and he pretty much said “Johto is unsalvageable lol” as if HGSS doesn’t exacerbate many of the issues people meme on GSC for. He’s a dipshit with no redeemable or original opinions. This has been known for a long time.
Yep
But he was also just straight enough to harass Jaiden into asexuality
Guy's a homosexual scumbag
kek It’s not surprising. I could smell his lurking degeneracy when he was a nobody. Still can’t wrap my head around his popularity when he oozes unlikable energy. You just know he’s miserable to be around irl.
For those who don’t know, this jackass is someone who got famous for making moronic Smash videos meant for middle school dropouts. He is arguably part of the reason why Smash is (rightfully) seen as a stupid kiddie game.
I'm always confused when I see Emerald several tiers above Ruby and Sapphire. I understand putting it a tier higher, because the changes and additions make it objectively better. But the way people rank them makes it look like they're completely different games.
I think those people are ranking them by comparison as a whole, instead of to each other 1-on-1.
I'd much rather play Ruby and Sapphire to Sword and Shield - but given a comparison of every single title I'd rather play Emerald as a nearly objective improvement.
I do not have to be a huge fan of GSC to reject it being below Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl. And Let's Go Pikachu and Eevee. And Sword and Shield???
The rest of the tierlist is acceptable - if not a bit cliche. I will never understand how a man can unironically want to play Sword and Shield over Ruby and Sapphire, though.
But it doesn't. That's why it's not S Tier. Same thing with HGSS. It's an amazing game by endgame, then you remember how slow it takes to get there (as in, the game just runs really slow).
X/Y feels more like A 3DS tech demo more than anything, while I liked the change of pace of sun/moon trying something new with the island challenges. Out of the 3DS Pokemon games I played I think it might've disappointed the least, but at least OR/AS was based on a good game. Any good will I had for Sun/Moon got ruined by the US/UM announcement anyway.
Tell me about it, PLA is a snooze fest with a story that is shit and yet wastes my time.
[...]
pretty sure all the grooming scandals have more to do with the smash ridicule anyway
Literally playing so morons can frick off.
So far I don't see the fricking "OMG SO GOOD" anywhere yet. It is just tedious.
Surely battles might get harder later, but I am not amused.
>unfunny >boring >fricking degen weirdo >also has terrible taste in vidya
Color me surprised kek. I have no idea how his channel ever took off; been blocked from my recommendations for years.
Not even a big problem. I could see SV being bottom of the second tier in a list like this. As shitty as it runs, it’s already better than some of the other games, and we can safely bet on a lot of future content to round out the experience. Its average ranking will change over the next year or two, without question. Likely for the better. SWSH in A? PLA in S? Now that’s bullshit.
[...]
This is a true thought crime. Crystal is the pinnacle of GB Pokemon, and it’s not even close (unless you’re REALLY into glitch shenanigans / the goofy Gen 1 mechanics). HGSS didn’t even manage to completely replace GSC, and it’s considered the best of the remakes.
you don't have to flex hard we know you didn't ever play the unova games or legends arceus
>coping this hard over something so dumb
Never mentioned Gen 5 in my post either, schizo. PLA is a game with an abysmal battle system and an incredibly small amount of content variety. Once you get bored of the main gimmick, the fun is over, and that happened pretty early for a lot of us. The story is utter shit (not surprising); SV actually blew it out of the water by comparison kek. PLA also has several blatant, unnecessary features that aim to waste the player’s time (distortion-exclusives; having to reload areas because the game decided certain mon wouldn’t spawn). There are neat aspects of the game, but there are vastly overshadowed by the flaws. It feels like a simple tech demo that drags on for way too long.
How to know if someone is a zoomer with terrible taste? Gen 5 in S tier, Ruby/Sapphire 2 tiers under Emerald and the classics (gen 1/2) in the lowest tier.
>HGSS >better than GSC
Black person, what? HGSS actually made the games worse in several areas. The level curve is a non-meme issue in HGSS because of the removed badge boosts. Combine that with a complete lack of rebalancing after the attack split, and many of the old mon are significantly worse than in GSC despite having better learn sets. Subtract some points for the sluggish Gen 4 engine, as well.
Subjectively, none of the battle sprites in HGSS hold a candle to Crystal’s, and many of the remixes miss the feel of the originals. At best, HGSS is a sidegrade to GSC.
Not that guy. HGSS soundtrack is pretty good, but it isn’t nearly as memorable / catchy as GSC’s. Going “bigger” with the OST isn’t a flat upgrade when the original is already top tier, as is.
I wish I could say HGSS was better than GSC. The QoL, extra content, and bonus features are fantastic, but it gets dragged down by questionable game mechanics (really it’s a lack of rebalancing…still waiting on that kek) and an art / sound direction that isn’t strictly better than the originals.
>1 perfect sequel
Crystal >2 maximum soul
Blue >3 last hurrah
B2W2 >4 pretty good
Emerald, Platinum >5 great but later improved
Red Green, Gold Silver, diamond pearl >6 disappointing but playable
Yellow, black white, ruby sapph >7 utter drek
Everything else
Slightly altered >>1 perfect sequel
Crystal >>2 maximum soul
Blue red green >>3 last hurrah
B2W2 >>4 pretty good
Emerald, Platinum, Colosseum, XD >>5 great but not premier options
Gold Silver, diamond pearl, HGSS, Pinball GBC >>6 disappointing but playable
Yellow, black white, ruby sapph, FRLG, TCG GBC >>7 utter drek
Everything else
>gold below crystal, crystal below HGSS >>>>frlg at the top >>>>>>>the shitty fricking GameCube games at the top
Actually objectively the worst taste in the thread
Hell no. Pirate it if you feel like you need to try it. It’s a fairly divisive game and for good reason.
[...]
Checked the list on his twitter, and he pretty much said “Johto is unsalvageable lol” as if HGSS doesn’t exacerbate many of the issues people meme on GSC for. He’s a dipshit with no redeemable or original opinions. This has been known for a long time.
[...]
kek It’s not surprising. I could smell his lurking degeneracy when he was a nobody. Still can’t wrap my head around his popularity when he oozes unlikable energy. You just know he’s miserable to be around irl.
I'm not surprised. He's always had that creepy b***h energy. He reminds me of every bisexual internet guy who attaches himself to a more popular female internet popularity and tries to siphon off as much as he can. I don't like Jaiden's content that much but being stuck in a "friendship" like that is horrible because the guy never stops hitting on her and making jokes about being in a relationship.
LGPE is objectively better than Crystal or Yellow. The catching mechanics are the most immersive in the series and it's the definitive way to play Kanto. Yellow is gen 1 and therefore buggy, unfinished dogshit that fails to work as intended and crystal is just a worse version of HGSS.
>HGSS over GSC
You guys keep saying this, but HGSS gets absolutely mogged by GSC when it comes to the single-player experience (start to Red). GSC’s engine is snappy, and the story(?) has fewer interruptions. Badge boosts make the level curve irrelevant in GSC. The expanded learnsets in HGSS are wasted on a roster of mon that weren’t redesigned alongside the attack split.
HGSS only wins out by having better pvp (largely irrelevant) and a battle frontier.
>GSC’s engine is snappy
The battles are slow as frick, almost DPPT tier slow, what the frick are you talking about >the story(?) has fewer interruptions
Literally irrelevant unless you're an ADHD zoomer autist that idolizes troony speedrunners >badge boosts make the level curve irrelevant
Which is fricking moronic and kills what little challenge the game has
HGSS significantly improved several fights from GSC and made it so that you couldn't just walk into the league at level 30 with no strategy and win easily, it is far superior to GSC >The expanded learnsets in HGSS are wasted on a roster of mon that weren’t redesigned alongside the attack split
This is actual gibberish formed from you trying to make a valid point and wording it horribly >HGSS only wins out
By having far better graphics, music, presentation, battles, attention to detail, QoL, actual fun gameplay.
GSC is an archaic wreck, HGSS is the modernized and fully realized version of the game. Only zoomers trying to fit in with the oldgay crowd say GSC is better and the actual oldgays all say HGSS runs laps around GSC qualitywise anyway
>not liking cutscenes makes you a zoomer / speedrunner
El Oh El
Black person, your arguments against GSC are subjective garbage. You didn't even try. I don't care if you like HGSS more, but the quality between GSC and HGSS is pretty comparable, overall. Certainly much closer than a S - D tier gap kek.
>Only zoomers like GSC
Strawman. And a poorly built strawman based on (You)r personal opinion. I'm fricking ancient by /vp/ standards and grew up with the GB games. I really doubt zoomers give a frick about anything pre-GBA.
>Delusional levels
Okay, so thanks for establishing you haven't actually played the game you're putting on a pedestal. This allows me to safely categorize you as a moron and not have to take anything else you say seriously. >El Oh El
This is not an argument. >your arguments against GSC
Are primarily rebutting the stupid fricking arguments you made, and claiming that HGSS is vastly superior to GSC in every category, which it objectively is.
Most Pokemon games are bad. HGSS takes a mediocre game, cleans it up, gives it a great coat of paint and polishes it, and it's good. This isn't difficult to process. >Strawman
That isn't what a "strawman" is.
You sound extremely young, and the reddit spacing just outright confirms it. Even if you were "ancient" by /vp/ standards you'd still be young to me. You are a zoomer, or a millennial, but they're both bad and don't actually recognize what makes a game good.
>attacking me instead of defending position
Genuinely: why bother posting? You type a whole lot without really saying anything. Why should I argue with you when your opinion can easily be reduced to “I just like it better, and new = good” and you’d rather talk shit than elaborate? It doesn’t make your position look good, and it’s why you’ve only received low effort posts in response.
1 year ago
Anonymous
>It doesn’t make your position look good, and it’s why you’ve only received low effort posts
You started off your position with several outright incorrect arguments and an argument that didn't make logical sense and I asked you to clarify what you were trying to say. I corrected them and stated why HGSS was the better game. You responded with a low effort shitpost. I responded by restating what I'd done so far and reaffirming my position.
You just don't sound very intelligent. I'm typing "a lot" because I want to try and reason with you or make you realize why you're fricking up, but you're refusing to meet me halfway. I don't really care to again restate from a meta level how this discussion is going, so if you don't actually want to expand upon the points you made in your first post and continue slinging lazy shitty moronic posts like this I'll be happy to stop posting if that makes you feel like you've "won" this discussion.
1 year ago
Anonymous
>trying to reason with me >by writing off my statements, making assumptions, and talking shit
Yeah. Ok, buddy. You were definitely trying to have a conversation in good faith. I absolutely believe you.
Honestly do agree with him
Everything is in the correct place except maybe DP
Irida will be on the correct place when she bounces on my wiener.
"I like pokemon"
Not with that tierlist lmao
Who?
Pedo enabler
Context?
popular person bad
Anon's ass.
He defended a smash player who fricked a kid
That doesnt exactly narrow it down
literally who?
>Scarlet and Violet
>A tier
Don’t know who that guy is but holy shit what a terrible taste
yeah, gen 5 being in the highest tier gives it away
Nah it was because he ranked xy too high
>unfunny
>boring
>fricking degen weirdo
>also has terrible taste in vidya
Color me surprised kek. I have no idea how his channel ever took off; been blocked from my recommendations for years.
Not even a big problem. I could see SV being bottom of the second tier in a list like this. As shitty as it runs, it’s already better than some of the other games, and we can safely bet on a lot of future content to round out the experience. Its average ranking will change over the next year or two, without question. Likely for the better. SWSH in A? PLA in S? Now that’s bullshit.
This is a true thought crime. Crystal is the pinnacle of GB Pokemon, and it’s not even close (unless you’re REALLY into glitch shenanigans / the goofy Gen 1 mechanics). HGSS didn’t even manage to completely replace GSC, and it’s considered the best of the remakes.
>NEW BAD
Kys
Your forced meme died right when PLA was released.
>PLa shitter
I have played 2 hours and so far I am not impressed. Where is it supposed to get good, moron?
Tell me about it, PLA is a snooze fest with a story that is shit and yet wastes my time.
pretty sure all the grooming scandals have more to do with the smash ridicule anyway
Literally playing so morons can frick off.
So far I don't see the fricking "OMG SO GOOD" anywhere yet. It is just tedious.
Surely battles might get harder later, but I am not amused.
you have been groomed by shitsui tards
I was bored and wanted to see how bad it was.
But guess I wasn't wrong.
>New bad
Unironically yes. All new products are objectively shit, as they're produced in a world run by pozzed bullshit.
You are correct but PLA is literally about living in a high-trust community with a strong culture, no israeli subversion, no israeli poison, healthy food and lots of physical exercise when hiking in nature, therefore it is based.
agreed, sv is s tier, pla and bw are f
>normalgay likes Pokemon games that appeal to normalgays
Yeah, not surprised
so he likes all pokemon games
Jacob "Icarus" Alpharad everybody....
This must be shitposting btw, specially with Sw/Sh's placement...
>influx of Let's Go posts over the last few days
That's weird, why now
>YouTube starts recommending clips of this guy playing it
Sheep, the lot of you
I've noticed that too, never watched him even in incognito. I think the algorithm associates him with Smashtubers though.
he IS a smashtuber, I guess he's branched out since
>mid-series games good
>new games mid
>old games outperformed
yeah that's expected, BDSP being shit tier is most definitely deserved for being a soulless adaptation at least
God, I hate those people.
They run through the same "new is bad" shit that older fans did while being completely unaware of it.
Just like Sonic Adventure / Dark Age fanboys
except new is not good, moron
neither is sa though, it's the same moronic shit as the new games
RBYG are failures as games that make Fallout 76 look like a well-designed game in comparison, and to say anything else is to be blinded by nostalgia or to be a zoomer contrarian.
How would you know? You've never played any gen 1 game you homosexual.
Difference is RGBY were well recieved at release while Fallout 76 was poorly recieved. I know /vp/ hates Gen 1 mostly to be contrarian but this is embarrassing.
>I know /vp/ hates Gen 1 mostly to be contrarian but this is embarrassing.
Gen 1 has been replaced twiceover by FRLG and LGPE, there is no reason to play RGBY because they are broken, unfinished, buggy, poorly-designed games that don't even function as intended. I'm 30, I grew up with pokemania, I had all the us-released gameboy games and I STILL say that Gen 1 has no redeeming qualities in this day and age and in hindsight Pokemon should have been a flop.
I would play RGBY over LGPE any day of the week, and i say that as someone who started with gen II. Frick off.
>crystal
>not S tier
have a nice day my man
>normie tier opinions on the games
>SS that high
breh
Would put SWSH in F and ORAS in C, otherwise I agree
He's right honestly. Though I feel like SwSh is only A if you count the DLC.
considering alpha openly shittalks SwSh, it's probably because bullying it makes for good content
OH NO NO NO NO NO DISCORDBROS??????? YOU TOLD ME ONLY REDDIT MAKES LISTS LIKE THAT?!? WE FRICKING LOST AGAIN, I CAN'T TAKE IT ANYMORE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I shall give this rating as much credence as every other rating I see on /vp/.
probably the most reasonable list ever posted on this site.
very good taste
A single shitty filler aera, sprites with 2 frames of animation and some Johto shitmons is enough for Emerald to be considered way better than Ruby/Sapphire, the exact same game! Oh shit i missed something, they added the items sprites in the bag like in FR/LG... Sorry my bad!
Maybe you should actually play the game before making such a shit take.
I played it, the highlight was when Scott interrupted me for the 3rd time to shill the BF
>A single shitty filler aera is enough for Emerald to be considered way better than Ruby/Sapphire
yes
The hate train on LGPE is moronic and putting it below FRLG is stupid as shit, maybe try and form your own opinions for a change
Is Legends Arceus that good? I skipped out on it
Hell no. Pirate it if you feel like you need to try it. It’s a fairly divisive game and for good reason.
Checked the list on his twitter, and he pretty much said “Johto is unsalvageable lol” as if HGSS doesn’t exacerbate many of the issues people meme on GSC for. He’s a dipshit with no redeemable or original opinions. This has been known for a long time.
kek It’s not surprising. I could smell his lurking degeneracy when he was a nobody. Still can’t wrap my head around his popularity when he oozes unlikable energy. You just know he’s miserable to be around irl.
Would sawp USUM for SS, but pretty reasonable list.
>Legends Arceus in S
If your favorite RPG is Skyrim, sure.
>SuMo in D
Game literally revived Pokemon, but go off.
For those who don’t know, this jackass is someone who got famous for making moronic Smash videos meant for middle school dropouts. He is arguably part of the reason why Smash is (rightfully) seen as a stupid kiddie game.
yeah man I'm sure somebody who got popular during smash 4 was responsible for the lifetime of ridicule smash fans have gotten since melee
Didn’t this guy get divorced like a month after his honeymoon lmao.
I'm always confused when I see Emerald several tiers above Ruby and Sapphire. I understand putting it a tier higher, because the changes and additions make it objectively better. But the way people rank them makes it look like they're completely different games.
I think those people are ranking them by comparison as a whole, instead of to each other 1-on-1.
I'd much rather play Ruby and Sapphire to Sword and Shield - but given a comparison of every single title I'd rather play Emerald as a nearly objective improvement.
I do not have to be a huge fan of GSC to reject it being below Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl. And Let's Go Pikachu and Eevee. And Sword and Shield???
The rest of the tierlist is acceptable - if not a bit cliche. I will never understand how a man can unironically want to play Sword and Shield over Ruby and Sapphire, though.
>alpharad
i don't care this guy was never funny
borts are a disease
there has never been more solid proof that gamefreak pays """influencers""" to slam Gen 2 than this
Test
Legends Arceus is mid and Platinum is shit
who cares lol
This is a fair and accurate list.
Is FR/LG let you evolve golbat/chansey/scyther/etc before the postgame it would be an S tier Pokemon game.
But it doesn't. That's why it's not S Tier. Same thing with HGSS. It's an amazing game by endgame, then you remember how slow it takes to get there (as in, the game just runs really slow).
Yeah. If HG/SS was remade in Gen 5 it would be the best pokemon game ever made.
>if HGSS was the same thing but with fricking horrible looking sprites and no Battle Frontier it would S!
yeah ok unovatard
at what point did I say no battle frontier?
I almost agree but I would put x and y over sun and moon
I liked roller skating and I feel like it's the best one of the 3ds titles
X/Y feels more like A 3DS tech demo more than anything, while I liked the change of pace of sun/moon trying something new with the island challenges. Out of the 3DS Pokemon games I played I think it might've disappointed the least, but at least OR/AS was based on a good game. Any good will I had for Sun/Moon got ruined by the US/UM announcement anyway.
Alpharad's taste in pokemon is notoriously dogshit. He's a moronic zoomer gen 5 fanboy like 99% of this shitty board.
captcha: GAGYR
Idk who this is, but he sure has awful taste.
>Unovabort and Hoenngay
>Fake hair and gay overall look
Can't say I'm surprised tho
you don't have to flex hard we know you didn't ever play the unova games or legends arceus
>coping this hard over something so dumb
Never mentioned Gen 5 in my post either, schizo. PLA is a game with an abysmal battle system and an incredibly small amount of content variety. Once you get bored of the main gimmick, the fun is over, and that happened pretty early for a lot of us. The story is utter shit (not surprising); SV actually blew it out of the water by comparison kek. PLA also has several blatant, unnecessary features that aim to waste the player’s time (distortion-exclusives; having to reload areas because the game decided certain mon wouldn’t spawn). There are neat aspects of the game, but there are vastly overshadowed by the flaws. It feels like a simple tech demo that drags on for way too long.
Oh really?
idk who this is but I know he's mentally moronic due to his SwSh placement.
S tier is correct. Everything else is wrong.
No mistakes on my list.
How to know if someone is a zoomer with terrible taste? Gen 5 in S tier, Ruby/Sapphire 2 tiers under Emerald and the classics (gen 1/2) in the lowest tier.
Ruby and Sapphire really are that lame though.
>sword and shield in the same tier as the others
lmfao
PLA shills, not even once
bump
>HGSS
>better than GSC
Black person, what? HGSS actually made the games worse in several areas. The level curve is a non-meme issue in HGSS because of the removed badge boosts. Combine that with a complete lack of rebalancing after the attack split, and many of the old mon are significantly worse than in GSC despite having better learn sets. Subtract some points for the sluggish Gen 4 engine, as well.
Subjectively, none of the battle sprites in HGSS hold a candle to Crystal’s, and many of the remixes miss the feel of the originals. At best, HGSS is a sidegrade to GSC.
Also they made the music worse
>music worse
actual moron
Not that guy. HGSS soundtrack is pretty good, but it isn’t nearly as memorable / catchy as GSC’s. Going “bigger” with the OST isn’t a flat upgrade when the original is already top tier, as is.
I wish I could say HGSS was better than GSC. The QoL, extra content, and bonus features are fantastic, but it gets dragged down by questionable game mechanics (really it’s a lack of rebalancing…still waiting on that kek) and an art / sound direction that isn’t strictly better than the originals.
>Galatians 4:16
Bad list ngl
Fake fan
this might be the most "i want to please le internet" tier list i've ever seen
i wonder what his actual opinions are
>1 perfect sequel
Crystal
>2 maximum soul
Blue
>3 last hurrah
B2W2
>4 pretty good
Emerald, Platinum
>5 great but later improved
Red Green, Gold Silver, diamond pearl
>6 disappointing but playable
Yellow, black white, ruby sapph
>7 utter drek
Everything else
Slightly altered
>>1 perfect sequel
Crystal
>>2 maximum soul
Blue red green
>>3 last hurrah
B2W2
>>4 pretty good
Emerald, Platinum, Colosseum, XD
>>5 great but not premier options
Gold Silver, diamond pearl, HGSS, Pinball GBC
>>6 disappointing but playable
Yellow, black white, ruby sapph, FRLG, TCG GBC
>>7 utter drek
Everything else
>I like pokemon
>all the Gen1 and Gen 2 games are in bottom tier
it's another attention prostitute pretending to be a pokemon fan to get clout
>all these gen 5 dicksuckers
garbage taste. the lot of you.
>Gen 7,5, and 8 below 6
Somehow the only poster here with worse taste than alpharad
>a 4 hour game of endless repeated corridors and filler battles at the top
yes. better than almost every other game in the franchise. no i will not elaborate further.
>gold below crystal, crystal below HGSS
>>>>frlg at the top
>>>>>>>the shitty fricking GameCube games at the top
Actually objectively the worst taste in the thread
Why do HGSSgays have the worse takes imaginable?
>illiterate homosexual hates good Pokémon games
Makes sense
DENSETSU NO KUSOGE
Lower S&S a tier,and I think I can pretty much agree with this list
>alphagay
>wife left him because he liked taking it up the ass
Wait, really?
Yep
But he was also just straight enough to harass Jaiden into asexuality
Guy's a homosexual scumbag
I'm not surprised. He's always had that creepy b***h energy. He reminds me of every bisexual internet guy who attaches himself to a more popular female internet popularity and tries to siphon off as much as he can. I don't like Jaiden's content that much but being stuck in a "friendship" like that is horrible because the guy never stops hitting on her and making jokes about being in a relationship.
Alpharad's fricking stupid and his list reflects that
>SV & SwSh in the same tier as HGSS and Platinum
>USUM and Let's Go Pee above Crystal and Yellow
LGPE is objectively better than Crystal or Yellow. The catching mechanics are the most immersive in the series and it's the definitive way to play Kanto. Yellow is gen 1 and therefore buggy, unfinished dogshit that fails to work as intended and crystal is just a worse version of HGSS.
>SV, SWSH and PLA all in the top two tiers
Lmao wtf
ok but lets be real
>another poketuber hates gen johto
what the hell
I give it two years before he's outed as a groomer
If you disagree, you only like pokemon for nostalgia or are a contrarian homosexual.
>HGSS over GSC
You guys keep saying this, but HGSS gets absolutely mogged by GSC when it comes to the single-player experience (start to Red). GSC’s engine is snappy, and the story(?) has fewer interruptions. Badge boosts make the level curve irrelevant in GSC. The expanded learnsets in HGSS are wasted on a roster of mon that weren’t redesigned alongside the attack split.
HGSS only wins out by having better pvp (largely irrelevant) and a battle frontier.
>GSC’s engine is snappy
The battles are slow as frick, almost DPPT tier slow, what the frick are you talking about
>the story(?) has fewer interruptions
Literally irrelevant unless you're an ADHD zoomer autist that idolizes troony speedrunners
>badge boosts make the level curve irrelevant
Which is fricking moronic and kills what little challenge the game has
HGSS significantly improved several fights from GSC and made it so that you couldn't just walk into the league at level 30 with no strategy and win easily, it is far superior to GSC
>The expanded learnsets in HGSS are wasted on a roster of mon that weren’t redesigned alongside the attack split
This is actual gibberish formed from you trying to make a valid point and wording it horribly
>HGSS only wins out
By having far better graphics, music, presentation, battles, attention to detail, QoL, actual fun gameplay.
GSC is an archaic wreck, HGSS is the modernized and fully realized version of the game. Only zoomers trying to fit in with the oldgay crowd say GSC is better and the actual oldgays all say HGSS runs laps around GSC qualitywise anyway
>almost DPPT tier slow
Delusional levels of cope.
>not liking cutscenes makes you a zoomer / speedrunner
El Oh El
Black person, your arguments against GSC are subjective garbage. You didn't even try. I don't care if you like HGSS more, but the quality between GSC and HGSS is pretty comparable, overall. Certainly much closer than a S - D tier gap kek.
>Only zoomers like GSC
Strawman. And a poorly built strawman based on (You)r personal opinion. I'm fricking ancient by /vp/ standards and grew up with the GB games. I really doubt zoomers give a frick about anything pre-GBA.
>Delusional levels
Okay, so thanks for establishing you haven't actually played the game you're putting on a pedestal. This allows me to safely categorize you as a moron and not have to take anything else you say seriously.
>El Oh El
This is not an argument.
>your arguments against GSC
Are primarily rebutting the stupid fricking arguments you made, and claiming that HGSS is vastly superior to GSC in every category, which it objectively is.
Most Pokemon games are bad. HGSS takes a mediocre game, cleans it up, gives it a great coat of paint and polishes it, and it's good. This isn't difficult to process.
>Strawman
That isn't what a "strawman" is.
You sound extremely young, and the reddit spacing just outright confirms it. Even if you were "ancient" by /vp/ standards you'd still be young to me. You are a zoomer, or a millennial, but they're both bad and don't actually recognize what makes a game good.
>attacking me instead of defending position
Genuinely: why bother posting? You type a whole lot without really saying anything. Why should I argue with you when your opinion can easily be reduced to “I just like it better, and new = good” and you’d rather talk shit than elaborate? It doesn’t make your position look good, and it’s why you’ve only received low effort posts in response.
>It doesn’t make your position look good, and it’s why you’ve only received low effort posts
You started off your position with several outright incorrect arguments and an argument that didn't make logical sense and I asked you to clarify what you were trying to say. I corrected them and stated why HGSS was the better game. You responded with a low effort shitpost. I responded by restating what I'd done so far and reaffirming my position.
You just don't sound very intelligent. I'm typing "a lot" because I want to try and reason with you or make you realize why you're fricking up, but you're refusing to meet me halfway. I don't really care to again restate from a meta level how this discussion is going, so if you don't actually want to expand upon the points you made in your first post and continue slinging lazy shitty moronic posts like this I'll be happy to stop posting if that makes you feel like you've "won" this discussion.
>trying to reason with me
>by writing off my statements, making assumptions, and talking shit
Yeah. Ok, buddy. You were definitely trying to have a conversation in good faith. I absolutely believe you.
>LGPE in A
>XY and FRLG over B2W2
what the frick is this
Just bump BW down a tier or two and keep B2W2 where it is and this is pretty much on point
>implying he ever played the original JP versions of RG
Not really trying to be objective but wanted to make a list anyway. I'm still super bummed that I don't like SV as much as I hoped I would.
Is there any legitimate argument for Emerald being above Platinum that's not just Gen 3 nostalgia?
Platinum is slow
better map design
better pokemon distribution
better performance
better battle facilities
platinum is literally just an emerald rehash but categorically worse in every way outside of online capabilities.
>better map design
Sinnoh isn't 50% water, so it's already better.
>better pokemon distribution
Than Platinum? What makes you say this specifically?
Not arguing the other two because they're right and I'm not a lame contrarian. I just dispute one thing and am looking for information about another.
>move BW1 down a tier
>move SV down a tier as well
fixed
I'm sorry who is this guy again? I think I've watched like one video of his and I remember it being terribly unfunny.
>annoying homosexual youtuber has dogshit taste
Color me surprised.
>swooshi and scarvi over usum
How can anyone have such shit taste