What's the best open world in any video game? I feel like it's a tie between MGS5, RDR2, and Elden Ring
 Shopping Cart Returner Shirt $21.68 |
 |
Shopping Cart Returner Shirt $21.68 |
What's the best open world in any video game? I feel like it's a tie between MGS5, RDR2, and Elden Ring
Based solely on map alone both those games are okay. I loved LA Noire's overall design of it's environments. If there was more to do, it might be at the top of my list. I actually love Skyrims open world, but the missions and dungeons are so tepid it sullies the experience. FFXII was mindblowing to me back in the day, and I always loved how populated that game felt.
>I actually love Skyrims open world
This homie likes copypasted content LMAO
is john skyrim a joke made by trannies or something? I don't get it.
John Madden
AEIOU
best open world in a game?
rdr2 I guess, dont really care about the world itself if I cant enjoy being in that world
fallout 76 would be my first choice in that case
>fallout 76 would be my first choice
have a nice day
RDR 2 feels alive. npcs talk about you and recognize you in the street if you helped them, rewarding you.
Birds fly slighty above water and catch fish.
There's more but I remember these details
bodies stay where they drop, decompose and become skeletons.
The open world in mgs5 is fricking awful what the hell are you talking about? Its literally just a bunch of empty nothingness
Elden Ring>Xenoblade X>Witcher 3>TotK>RoDR2
MGS V doesn't rank
>What's the best open world in any video game? I feel like it's a tie between MGS5
I love this bait. Makes sure you get replies to get it going.
Rdr2 and its not close
RDR2 is the winner.
None of those.
Elden Ring > RDR2 > TW3
>MGS5, RDR2, and Elden Ring
All trash.
It's absolutely RDR2 still. Other open worlds are simply empty of life and detail in comparison. Only GTA6 may possibly be able to compete against it at this point.
Gothic one or two
BotW and RDR2.
MGSV would be better if it wasn't open world.
>MGSV
I don't agree on Elden Ring but I'll give you a pass because I enjoy the game, but fricking MGSV?
>I feel like it's a tie between MGS5, RDR2, and Elden Ring
You got the shittiest taste and no understanding of game development whatsoever.
All three of those are prime examples why you should NOT use open-world maps for most games. They only hurt all three games, especially MGS5, which was also an unfinished game.
Only Breath Of The Wild and ToK have truly utilized the open world to its fullest. No restrictions, no obstacles, crazy amount of interactive systems to play with, and everything's hand-built like a video game level.
STALKER gets close second for its A-Life system and interesting setting + lore.
>No restrictions, no obstacles,
This is terrible open world design
It's actually the definition of open world.
Incorrect.
Why have a large, open world, if you are not allowed to explore it without proceeding forward in a linear story?
Fallout NV
The best moments of Breath of the Wild are linear and restrictive, so no
RDR2 only has high production value. Its open world is terrible
>Its open world is terrible
Tell me any mission, whether main or secondary, that makes good use of the open world? Absolutely none
>mission
>open world
hahaha
>The best moments of Breath of the Wild are linear and restrictive
No they aren't.
I played BotW for 80+ hours before even attempting any of the story content. It's the emergent gameplay and the thrill of discovery and exploration that elevate BotW and its sequel far above the typical Ubishit.
Most games listed in this thread do open world concepts completely differently from one another. It's really stupid to say RDR2 is the best just because of the attention to detail, when all the quests in that world suck compared to Witcher 3 and the systemic design elements are a joke compared to BotW and TotK.
So, just basing purely on enjoyment of the games I'd rank my top 10 as:
1. Witcher 3
2. Elden Ring
3. Cyberpunk
4. Tears of the Kingdom
5. Breath of the Wild
6. RDR2
7. Skyrim
8. Arkham City
9. Forza Horizon 5
10. Fallout 4
Witcher 3, especially Toussaint.
Toussaint is good because it's not open world.
Open world has ruined a generation of gaming.
skyrim >>>>> huge gap >>>>>>>>> everything else
>er
>mgs5
lame bait
RDR2
botw and totk.
GTA 6 has potential tho in my opinion. Biggest issue is really if rockstar will double down on "YOU FAILED" gameplay. Like give us a little bit of freedom in missions
real homies will know
Morrowind