What's the single most evil thing one of your PCs has ever done in a game?

What's the single most evil thing one of your PCs has ever done in a game?

The Kind of Tired That Sleep Won’t Fix Shirt $21.68

Yakub: World's Greatest Dad Shirt $21.68

The Kind of Tired That Sleep Won’t Fix Shirt $21.68

  1. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    What is the measure of evil?

  2. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Flake on me.

  3. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    when our group was robbing a subarban family house I ate their cookies and drank their beer

  4. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    kill people

  5. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    In a game of Vampire: the Masquerade we got a friendly mechanic to host our on-the-run group up for a night, he grilled up some burgers for us and one of the players didn't want to use his blood points to make his digestion work so he waited for the guy to turn his back and hurled the burger into the woods. He failed the check so the guy noticed and was really sad.

    • 3 months ago
      Anonymous

      Damn, I know you're an abomination, a soulless corpse enslaved by the devil, a walking parody of humanity, but that shit crosses the line. Just eat the guy's family in front of him, it'd be less hurtful than insulting his grillskillz.

    • 3 months ago
      Anonymous

      🙁

    • 3 months ago
      Anonymous
    • 3 months ago
      Anonymous

      He lost Humanity for that, right?

    • 3 months ago
      Anonymous

      Coulda just said you're allergic to red meat or something.

  6. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Playing a Mechwarrior campaign, started taunting a bunch of pirates. The GM dropped that we had just killed their kid with a wienerpit shot.

    He did *not* expect me to double down by telling them "Man, you must have really hated her to train her so badly" along with a bunch of other shit. I ended up shooting their ejection seats down at the end of the fight due to a misreading of the rules about getting reputation.

    • 3 months ago
      Anonymous

      Deliberately killing mechwarriors in battle is an butthole move, but killing helpless mechwarriors after they've ejected is straight up villainy. Everywhere you go for the rest of your life should be made difficult by your GM. Lowball contracts because employers don't want fallout from your bad rep, dropship pilots hesitant to take you as cargo, people walking out of bars as soon as you walk in, vendors charging higher prices, up and coming mechwarriors trying to earn a name by killing you, and all the extra attention in battle on principle. Not to mention every mechwarrior murdered in such a way is a new opportunity for an insane, relentless death oath against you sworn by someone who cared about your victim.

      • 3 months ago
        Anonymous

        >killing mechwarriors
        Pirates. Distinction needs to be made.

      • 3 months ago
        Anonymous

        >Deliberately killing mechwarriors in battle is an butthole move
        Kill the meat, spare the metal.
        >but killing helpless mechwarriors after they've ejected is straight up villainy.
        Pirates are not afforded the same protections and status “proper” mechwarriors are. If it became common knowledge, certainly it would give them a darker reputation. But the average pilot is not going to be shedding any real tears over pirates being deliberately killed. I would probably accuse a GM of targeting the played if they received such extreme treatment over this.
        >Not to mention every mechwarrior murdered in such a way is a new opportunity for an insane, relentless death oath against you sworn by someone who cared about your victim.
        This is good. Some pirate lord swearing revenge against you because cooked one of their ejecting friends or family members is fuel for exciting games.

  7. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Not saying "Hi" to his neighbor.

    • 3 months ago
      Anonymous

      Hope you're not playing a paladin. You're about to fall.

  8. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    It wasn't evil, but my character shot a napalm rocket into a barracks full of raiders before they had the chance to suit up and get into battle. It upset him to think about after the incident even though they were thieves and killers, but he didn't talk about it.

  9. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Other PC made a deal to free an npc in exchange for information by that NPC. My PC insisted that person be her slave and threatened to kill the other PC if they didn't comply. Got her way despite the fact that the NPC already coughed up.

    The campaign is still pretty young, so I expect her to commit even greater acts of villainy.

  10. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Bombed a city from orbit because a primitive was trying to hold me hostage.

  11. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    He has been building up a giant ritual circle and started to spread rumors about some kind of party there in order to attract enough sacrifices to kill at once to please Bhaal

  12. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    you first, nogames

  13. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    The villain was holed up in his fortress mansion but his kid still went to school. My character infiltrated the school, distracted the kids bodyguards and then manage to put a remote detonated bomb and a surveillance kit in the kids backpack. When she returned home and hugged her father my character detonated the bomb.

    • 3 months ago
      Anonymous

      That's just clever, not evil.

      • 3 months ago
        Anonymous

        Seconding. There's nothing wrong with killing children as long as you're killing the right ones. Children of evil or defective bloodlines, children of inferior races, children who have deviant morals, genders, or religions. Those sorts. It's basically just pruning the tree of humanity from undesirable offshoots.

  14. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    >wasteland, group steals a shipment of cabbages and shoves them into every enemy's orificies they meet for the rest of the campaign (to kill them)
    >blow up a skyscraper, then escape to a remote island and enslave women they kidnapp from random tourist ships
    >win a friendly arena show fight, proceed to gouge out rival's eyes and parade them around the arena (she was playing a wise and peaceful seer)
    >poisoning a random old kiosk lady to gain access to her shop with nothing but a few supplies which the group had plenty of
    >military guard points gun at girl PC, threatens to shoot, PC says do it and guard shoots, PC makes new char, father of girl PC, joins grp to search for daughter, grp never tells him

  15. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    They cut out the hearts of three priests during a dark ritual right in the middle of the street before the forest god who asked them to do it could even mention the reward. They knew him for about five minutes.
    Well, the priests attacked first, and the forest god killed them himself and joked (for the third time) that “I can’t do it myself because I have paws” (he is a giant four-eyed wolf covered in shadows).
    They apparently really liked the guy.
    It wasn't surprising - they just adored a demon living in a bloody chest (think of Pride from Full Metal Alchemist, but made of fine gore and black splinters) who essentially took over the kingdom and didn't remove the king because he liked him.
    He sold them and the previous group a bunch of magic swag for their services, so that’s probably a factor, but still.
    The stupidest thing is that they are fairly heroic otherwise.
    Also, this captcha is a beast fricking hell

  16. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    vivisecting elves for science.

  17. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Farmed an Ethiopian anorexia support group image board for clickbait for his wife's boyfriend's Youtube channel.

    • 3 months ago
      Anonymous

      That's pretty evil. Neckbeardia campaign?

  18. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Lit the thatch roof of a nearby tavern on fire, barred the back door, and summoned an earth elemental to block the main exit as a distraction whilst we robbed a stagecoach, also to kill/inconvenience the owners of said coach.
    Dozens died in the ensuing blaze including two party members, one of whom was asleep in a guestroom and another that was too drunk to escape. They were not missed as this meant better loot shares on the robbery which gave us funds to upgrade gear and hire top tier mercs at the next town for the dead guys' players to run.

  19. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Sniping a stoneage alien. They used a thermal scope and popped the poor bastard while it was taking a dump in the woods.
    It was a very petty kind of evil.

  20. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    I had an investigative game once; character was murdered, there were six plausible subjects, and the players were sent to find out whodunit. Well, they found the mystery a little too much work to properly investigate, so eventually decided to grab one of the suspects (who was innocent, not that it really mattered), drag her back to the base they were operating out of, tortured her into signing a false confession for the crime, and then executed her on the basis of that confession.

    • 3 months ago
      Anonymous

      What a nightmare.

  21. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Killed all the elves just to piss off a party member that was a polymorphed bugbear that wanted to return to being an elf but now couldn't because the elf killing spell plague would immediately kill him if he polymorphed back.

    This was an evil campaign.

  22. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Mass mind control on an opposing country: to deliberately crater their birth rate, I turned them all into raging feet fetishists

  23. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Remember that evil doesn't mean "disgusting"

  24. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    It happened in a one shot were me and the DM's girlfriend were playing DND 5e, I was a pigeon man bard (can't remember the race's name, was inspired by pigeon from Mike Tyson Mysteries), the GM's girlfriend was a changeling. We were sent on a job by our dwarf boss to steal a item and when we came to the town gate, we saw two shady guards that were searching for me due to a petty squabble. We disguised ourselves as lumberjacks and convinced the guards what we were and was able to walk pass them. We walked to the the village stables in an attempt to get a carriage were we saw a gnome owner. We tried to convince the guy that we were in his list but failed. I then came up with an idea were the changeling would cast the throw voice spell. She succeeded in the voice part but failed with hiding her hand. The gnome owner heard the voice and saw the hand so he screamed for help. The two guards from earlier came by hearing the commotion and we successfully convinced them that the gnome was having a mental breakdown from work stress. When they were dragging the gnome away to a nearby tavern we took one of the carriages, but before we rode away, we turned towards the screaming gnome while behind the guards back and changed back into our actual selves. Then the gnome had a actual mental breakdown. And that was story of how me and another player broke a innocent gnome's mind, just so we didn't have to pay for a ride.

    • 3 months ago
      Anonymous

      Comedy gold.

      • 3 months ago
        Anonymous

        The best part was that my alignment was chaotic neutral.

  25. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Made supercomputer using 10,000 living children to calculate the world seed of this universe and make a 100% accurate simulation of reality to trap every living creature in.

  26. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    there was never any personal level evil since i try not to, but i did kind of nuke a few cities once with one of my characters

  27. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Gassed a city with hallucinogens to make them act heretical so their security system would gun them all down purely to create a distraction so we could take out one particular guy
    Black Crusade game

  28. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Uh, welllll... genocide, I guess (but it was the lesser of two evils, the greater being failure to ensure their timely extinction).

  29. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Playing VtR for the first time, me and another player with some heavy occult-leaning characters decided we wanted to shortcut our way to power so we found ourselfs a Not!cronomicon then followed to instructions in it (ritually murdering a bunch of orphans) to summon a demon to grant us power.
    We didn't get a demon but we did get the attention of a true fae (we couldn't tell the difference, storyteller told us about it after the game) who was amused enough by the whole thing that he granted us a small token of his power in exchange for eternal servitude. Mechanically we gained access to some powers from CtL using vitae instead of glamor. The campaign kinda fell apart but the GM later told us how he was cooking up some fun ideas about making our characters and our new bloodline into "bloodhounds" for this fae, helping track down and capture his escaped changelings.

  30. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    >Players gets poisoned by treacherous sailors
    >Kill the sailors
    >Go back to the sailors shop
    >Slaughter them after they set a course for their home port
    >HANG THEIR BODIES FROM THE SAILS AS YOU SET THE SHIP TO CRASH INTO THE DOCKS
    >When it smashes ashore firebomb the sailors that come to stop the fires and repair the damage.
    >Somehow that's not enough
    >Using enhanced strength they throw boulders and trees at their cottages until protectors managed to respond.

    I'm glossing over that the players were using biotech, the villagers were being forced by robots to dress and act like it was medieval times, and the robots protecting the village but that's is an accurate summary. Total nodycount was 81 with 3 being eaten by the players to fuel their biotech.

  31. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    convince his own brother to fight in fixed matches (WFRPG)
    destroy a planet with a summoned gigahomie monster (as a group effort, at the end of black crusade rpg campaign)

  32. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Stole 41 cakes

  33. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    When we had already defeated his guards, subdued him, and had a clear exit out, instead of taking the renegade warlord to the kingdom for a public sentencing and execution under the law as ordered, we instead tied him to his throne and set him on fire until he burned to death while we watched.
    To be fair, he 100% deserved it. King was only mad because he wanted a public execution to keep his authority solidified.

  34. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    I was DMing a 5e game that my brother was playing in several years back. He was playing a semi stereotypical true neutral druid. He had wiped out a group of goblins that were fricking up a forest grove so i decided to reward him with a familiar (lore wise he earned the favor of a forrest spirit who gifted him a Fey Horned Owl). He really liked the owl and used it for alot of cool and fun Rp stuff. Fast forward a month or two, the party is chasing down a wizard slave master. My brothers druid summoned a bunch of wolves in the fight so the wizard fricking nuked him, his wolves and his familiar with a fireball. After the fight was over they captured the wizard. The druid ended up resumoning his owl before casting grasping vines on the wizard and sending his owl to gouge out his eyes, he also cut the wizards tongue out and fed it to a wolf spirit as an apology and a form of vengeance.

  35. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    I once played a Patrick Bateman knockoff who had been keeping it barely under control until the night he was turned into a vampire of the Assamite clan. There is a whole laundry list of awful shit he did, but the worst was probably after he started a city-wide riot in Detroit for clout.
    >vampires are a generally 'known' aspect
    >Run a real estate company
    >hopes of turning it into a megacorp
    >7th gen brujah metal head has a herd of friends about to expose the nitty-gritty of the clans to the people of Detroit mid-concert
    >Send in ghoul security squad #1 "Night Shift"
    >Snipe the band while on stage
    >Brujah loses it seeing her friends killed, and starts a week of mass embracing and bloody riots
    >4 days later, expose ourselves and the clans, point to my security forces who have been saving cops and civs all week before pulling out the 'but don't worry, we're the good ones' card
    >Bruja knows immediately, but the city doesn't I had the band killed or that I'm using the whole thing for clout and to start a wave of """vampire inclusivity and solidarity"""
    >Find brujah
    >screams and rails against the rest of the party for killing her friends to protect ourselves only to out everything 4 days later.
    >Some of the group start questioning their morales when I make my entrance
    >mock her dead friends but, despite everything, I'm going to make the world a better place for kindred and kine thanks to their deaths (true in his messed up perspective)
    >"Then Again, I wouldn't expect a disgruntled pet owner to understand that."
    >Bust out the horrid form I was taught by a tzimisce methuselah who was infatuated with me, carve the bruja down to a head, torso, and part of one arm, tell the boys about my own diablerie and dangle her in front of them like a juicy steak
    > Watch two of them utterly dump their morales and bite into her like junkyard dogs while the third tries to wrestle her away for a mercy kill, fails, then curls up and cries

    today city hall, tomorrow the white house

  36. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    In SR I dirty bombed an island with a bunch of slaves that we were trying to free.

  37. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Ate about a 200+ people to save her loved one. In her defense, they were a super villain organization

  38. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    I once played an evil Cleric in a D&D 5e mini campaign who worshipped the goddess of Death and Muder in a friend's homebrew setting. Picking a single evil is hard considering all of the things this character did in pursuit of treasure, but a highligh reel includes:

    >Slaughtering a troop of tribal teenage boys undergoing their rite of passage into adulthood
    >Interrogating their elderly mentor through brutal torture to make him give up secrets related to guarded treasure
    >Capturing, torturing and interogating one of said boys while gaslighting him into thining this was part of his trial
    >Laying waste to a tribal village and slaughtering its elders, fighters and leaders in pursuit of the tomb it guarded
    >Frequently resorting to torture by means of kneecapping and mutilating anyone who didn't immediately provide answers
    >Taking solace when he and his 'friends' were trapped in a corridor and slaughtered to a TPK by tribal reinforcements because he knew his actions and the violent death of him and his companions would please his goddess.

    True evil is a hell of a drug

  39. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    an evil PF2e game where a player pried a child off the arms of their dead mother, and proceeded to throw said child with such force that the targets ribs shattered when the kid made contact at terminal velocity, dying on impact.

    It was a critical success, so the aftermath was messy, and that's not even covering the fact the target was still alive, but injured, and the player took the time to pick up and eat the child's corpse in such a way that the entrails would pour all over their face, in a position like pic related (less eroticism, more intimidating horror)

    That player worried me a bit for that campaign.

  40. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    He's Canadian.

  41. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    >player minmaxxed his VTM character into seduction at the cost of every other social stat
    >gets into a situation where he has to lure away some children to keep them safe from the rest of the party's squabbling
    >roll Seduction on a 9-year old to get him to follow his character out of the building
    >succeed

  42. 3 months ago
    Anonymous

    Pushed a guy into the water with Thunderwave, used Hold Person to hold him underwater for the next twenty some turns, zapping him with Mind Sliver to give him disadvantage.
    He eventually made his WIS save, but surrendered after I made an Intimidation check.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *